Mini 472 - Cartman Mafia - Game Over

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #10 (isolation #0) » Mon Jul 16, 2007 8:58 am

Vote J-man

for taking forever to confirm.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #18 (isolation #1) » Mon Jul 16, 2007 2:27 pm

J-man wrote:well im happy with my vote on Off the Mark for now.

i would like to hear some more from Gatorguy tho IGMEOY (omgus ftw)

What the F? The game just started, and you already want me to contribute many pages of material when some people HAVEN'T EVEN POSTED YET?

Confirm Vote: J-man

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #55 (isolation #2) » Thu Jul 19, 2007 1:32 am

Unvote J-man, Vote Deanwhinchester.

Why did you vote for Earwig at l-3? It's Page 3, We need to get more contributions before lynching anyone.

FoS Earwig

for scummy behavior.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #79 (isolation #3) » Sat Jul 21, 2007 4:18 pm

Bump. This Game is slipping down and I'd like to keep it up on the top of the page

Dean

, you haven't responded to my vote. Please do so.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #100 (isolation #4) » Mon Jul 23, 2007 12:03 pm

K:
Thoughts: I'm still waiting for Dean to respond. Not Ready to do anything til' I hear his defense.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #104 (isolation #5) » Tue Jul 24, 2007 1:04 am

Gatorguy91 wrote:
Unvote J-man, Vote Deanwhinchester.

Why did you vote for Earwig at l-3? It's Page 3, We need to get more contributions before lynching anyone.
FoS Earwig
for scummy behavior.

There. Respond, please.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #153 (isolation #6) » Fri Jul 27, 2007 4:50 am

J-man wrote:
Vote:Gatorguy91

Could you explain?

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #156 (isolation #7) » Fri Jul 27, 2007 7:03 am

Dean Still hasn't responded... all he said is

The reason I have been quite: harry potter. finished it.

Ok, what is the argument against me?

And estes the reason I have been attacking you is that your "that is just how i play, don't lynch me." Which nobody else has commented on.

I still have my suspiscions because he hasn't responded still..

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #168 (isolation #8) » Fri Jul 27, 2007 1:27 pm

unvote vote J-man

Why would you claim cop so early? How am I supposed to believe that? REAL COP, Please do not take the bait.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #173 (isolation #9) » Fri Jul 27, 2007 4:05 pm

J-man you are either
a: lieing scum
b: worst cop ever.

No offense but you aren't the best player (frankly, me either) so it'd be easy to believe you are the cop.

However, I am Vanilla. So you can't be the cop. Maybe it was the flavor of an innocent or something, IDK.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #215 (isolation #10) » Sat Jul 28, 2007 11:35 am

J-man wrote:lol another stupid comment couretsy of Zeek

Likewise.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #241 (isolation #11) » Sun Jul 29, 2007 2:14 pm

That makes me think you are the SK. In that episode Cartman wanted to kill anyone that wasn't ginger.

unvote vote zeekltk

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #243 (isolation #12) » Sun Jul 29, 2007 2:53 pm

You've got a point, but I just wanted to hear zeek's response.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #259 (isolation #13) » Mon Jul 30, 2007 7:16 am

Off the Mark wrote:
Gatorguy91 wrote: However, I am Vanilla. So you can't be the cop. Maybe it was the flavor of an innocent or something, IDK.
Hey I just noticed that Gatorguy claimed Vanilla. Gatorguy, do you have any Cartman flavor or episode # to go with that claim?

Nice Cartman, 417 (Red Sleigh Down)

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #261 (isolation #14) » Mon Jul 30, 2007 7:29 am

ryan wrote:Gatorguy91: Any thoughts on ChaosOmega, DeanWinchester and Earwig you have? (strictly a discussion starter conspiracy people)

I think Dean has been a bit bandwagon-happy, Not really sure about Chaos and i think Earwig is a newbie.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #266 (isolation #15) » Mon Jul 30, 2007 9:35 am

ryan wrote:
Gatorguy91 wrote:
ryan wrote:Gatorguy91: Any thoughts on ChaosOmega, DeanWinchester and Earwig you have? (strictly a discussion starter conspiracy people)
I think Dean has been a bit bandwagon-happy, Not really sure about Chaos and i think Earwig is a newbie.
Newbie to the game or newbie scum/town?

To the game

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #267 (isolation #16) » Mon Jul 30, 2007 9:37 am

Gatorguy91 wrote:
Off the Mark wrote:
Gatorguy91 wrote: However, I am Vanilla. So you can't be the cop. Maybe it was the flavor of an innocent or something, IDK.
Hey I just noticed that Gatorguy claimed Vanilla. Gatorguy, do you have any Cartman flavor or episode # to go with that claim?

Nice Cartman, 417 (Red Sleigh Down)

Sorry, by 417 I meant 617

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #272 (isolation #17) » Mon Jul 30, 2007 10:32 am

It's still on zeek? Damn, forgot. That was a vote for the response

unvote

Well, anyway I'm suspicious of Off The Mark, Dean whinchester, and Estes

mod DW needs prodding

OTM, as well as J-man to a certain point seem to be using Argumentum ad Hominem https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?ti ... the_Person against ZeekLTK, claiming not to answer his questions because they are stupid.
Dean just can't defend himself.
Estes has been hardcore lurking..

vote OTM

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #276 (isolation #18) » Mon Jul 30, 2007 2:33 pm

Off the Mark wrote:Gatorguy, I am in 2 games with you and in both of them you are voting me for no reason whatsoever.

Blatant Lie- I'm not voting for you in 460.

Off the Mark wrote:
Yes, I have thought some of Zeek's arguments have been stupid. But since he finally shared the details of his role, I have said he most likely really is a miller after all.

Off the Mark wrote: Please quote some of my posts where I "did not answer his questions because they were stupid". That never happened, you pulled that out of thin air.

Off the Mark wrote:No, it's not, because I am not mafia. Your confidence is making look scummy, particularly since you are wrong.

Off the Mark wrote:
Besides, you thought he was the SK after his flavor reveal. And now you are attacking me for attacking him? You're all over the map.

So Do I. As I told you, I wanted to get Zeek's Response.

Off the Mark wrote: Let me make this clear, Gatorguy - I am in the "Do the sanity check" camp - keep Zeek alive, and have J-man investigate him. This is your only chance of being cleared. By voting for me, you are establishing yourself as "Against the sanity check" - which only makes sense for you to do if you are scum.

confirm vote OTM

Where have I established I am against the sanity check? I wanted to hear Zeek's response to the possibility that he was an SK, and you're just being plain retarded about it.

Off the Mark wrote: Unless you want to clearly state that you agree with all my analysis, but you still want to vote to lynch me. That'd be a little weird, but feel free. Is there something about my playstyle that rubs you the wrong way? Is it my avatar? Because it's seriously weird that you seem predisposed to vote for me in two different games where I've given you no reason to do so. Oh well.

You give me plenty of Reasons.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #277 (isolation #19) » Mon Jul 30, 2007 2:34 pm

Sorry,

Off the Mark wrote:No, it's not, because I am not mafia. Your confidence is making look scummy, particularly since you are wrong.

was meant to be a response to

Off the Mark wrote: Please quote some of my posts where I "did not answer his questions because they were stupid". That never happened, you pulled that out of thin air.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #300 (isolation #20) » Wed Aug 01, 2007 10:58 am

Unvote, Fos OtM, Vote Dean

The "I'm busy" line is overused as translation to "I'm scum, and don't want discussion or to have to defend myself [/b]

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #301 (isolation #21) » Wed Aug 01, 2007 10:59 am

EBWOP: [/b] to "

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #343 (isolation #22) » Thu Aug 02, 2007 1:34 pm

Estes wrote:Don't lynch Sorin...he's ok. I investigated him night one.

I'm the Dawg, episode 1010.

If there is a doctor...you better save me.

FoS: Estes

K, Lemme Get this straight. There are 2 mafias/mafia & sk, a miller, and 2 cops in A MINI. '

Really this just sounds like a way to possibly protect scumbuddies and get J-man killed tonight.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #367 (isolation #23) » Sat Aug 04, 2007 10:22 am

Off the Mark wrote:
Please let me know if I've missed any possibilities. And sorry if this seems like I'm distracting from the current lynch, I was just thinking more about the sanity test and I wanted to get my thoughts out there before the end of Day 1.

You missed that He could be paranoid.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #368 (isolation #24) » Sat Aug 04, 2007 10:22 am

EBWOP: J-man is "he"

(Zeek, EBWOP means Edit by way of post)

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #384 (isolation #25) » Tue Aug 07, 2007 6:42 am

As long as I'm not hammering, I think it would be beneficial for an

Unvote, vote Sorin

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #387 (isolation #26) » Tue Aug 07, 2007 7:04 am

Off the Mark wrote:
Gatorguy91 wrote:As long as I'm not hammering, I think it would be beneficial for an
Unvote, vote Sorin
What makes you not want to hammer?

I'd like to hear from him first. Y'know, see what i can learn.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #391 (isolation #27) » Tue Aug 07, 2007 8:28 am

That is a bad state of mind, though. Anything is nice for the town, and if it doesn't matter to get info, you can lynch.

We won't know his role, we'll just know if he's protown- or anti-town.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #395 (isolation #28) » Tue Aug 07, 2007 8:34 am

Stewie wrote:
Rules
:

A special rule for this game is that for lynches, the role is not revealed until the next morning. The alignment is know immediately, however.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #414 (isolation #29) » Tue Aug 07, 2007 2:05 pm

WIFOM OTM WIFOM

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #415 (isolation #30) » Tue Aug 07, 2007 2:06 pm

EBWOP: Forgot to add a :-p to indicate I was kidding.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #436 (isolation #31) » Wed Aug 15, 2007 10:46 am

I'll put an

FoS on Ryan

for now, but i remember mathcam doing something like that being a mafia roleblocker..

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #442 (isolation #32) » Wed Aug 15, 2007 2:55 pm

Where the f*ck is J-man?

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #477 (isolation #33) » Thu Aug 16, 2007 6:51 am

Off the Mark wrote:
ZeekLTK wrote:So you think it's 3 mafia then?

Right after I posted that I was thinking "hmmm... the town has a vigilante and there is a SK, so there has to be more than 2 mafia because there is a high chance of one of them dieing at night."

So I'm also thinking 3 mafia... and this is the set up:

3 mafia
1 serial killer
-
2 masons
2 cops (1 sane, 1 insane)
1 doctor
1 vigilante
1 roleblocker
1 miller

If this is the case (and no one has lied about their claims) then the doctor has a huge advantage here because he knows who the remaining mafia/SK is. The only problem is a) do we believe the people who have claimed? and b) how does the doctor let the rest of us know who to go after without revealing himself?
Gatorguy claimed vanilla. Maybe we don't have a doc. Also your idea about the doc knowing who is scum assumes that none of the claimers are lying.

Cartman never claimed doing anything medically, so no doc= understandable. There IS a roleblocker, but I'm not sure there's 3 mafia.
3 mafia + sk would be too hard for the town. So I'm guessing:
2 mafia, one maybe having an extra role (Like a roleblock, etc..)
1 Serial killer
1 vig
1 miller
2 masons
1 roleblocker
2 cops
2 townies

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #487 (isolation #34) » Fri Aug 17, 2007 6:54 am

ryan wrote:Your right about one thing OtM, somebody has lied about their roleclaim and I believe that somebody to be you. Convenient suspicion thrown at me because you blocked me last night (from doing what, twiddling my fingers hoping to not be night killed?) We have alot of roles that we THINK we know what they are but we have no proof. As much as you are trying to drive who's claimed what, I believe you know more than you are letting on, probably because you already know the roles of the players in this game. Looking back I had suspicion on you in the beginning of the game and it's starting to shine through again.

Vote: Off the Mark

Somebody DEFINITLY Lied about their roleclaim. But You know what, I think it doesn't matter at this point. You're scum, I'm pretty sure.

Vote ryan

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #508 (isolation #35) » Fri Aug 17, 2007 12:08 pm

ZeekLTK wrote: Well, if he is SK he'll get an innocent investigation (or guilty to an insane cop)

An sk will get a guilty investigation, that is just stupid Zeek.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #509 (isolation #36) » Fri Aug 17, 2007 12:09 pm

EBWOP: That makes everything you've said irrelevant.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #532 (isolation #37) » Sat Aug 18, 2007 9:20 am

Also, Zeek, If I'm so Obviously the serial killer, why aren't you voting for me?

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #562 (isolation #38) » Mon Aug 20, 2007 1:15 am

vampyrusddg wrote:I'd rather see Ryan lynched and Earwig/STS investigated

Let's go with vise versa.

Vote: Earwig/SorintheseekerII

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #599 (isolation #39) » Tue Aug 21, 2007 6:25 am

Off the Mark wrote:I was just rereading the day2 posts and I couldn't resist sharing this.

ryan wrote: 2) I'm not a doc but I do have a pro town flavor.
Uh, what? He just claimed doc! Can we lynch this scum now please? Oh, I suppose we should hear from Jman first, but I think we've got this game figured out.

Ryan has not stated that he was indeed a doctor, just has a protect.

But seriously ryan, wtf.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #625 (isolation #40) » Wed Aug 22, 2007 6:22 am

This seems like a jester move.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #647 (isolation #41) » Thu Aug 23, 2007 8:33 am

I bet OTM's talking about me, lol. why does everyone think I'm the sk, I'm just nice cartman from Red Sleigh down (617)

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #666 (isolation #42) » Sat Aug 25, 2007 6:06 am

This game is strange.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #703 (isolation #43) » Mon Aug 27, 2007 9:04 am

I don't understand you guys. Why aren't we lynching Sorin II

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #731 (isolation #44) » Tue Aug 28, 2007 9:09 am

Nice look on that, Zeek. Because In that episode, Cartman was doing that exclusively for money.

So Possible SKS:
Off The Mark
Ryan
Roach

And Possible Mafia:

Ryan
OTM
Sorin II

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #777 (isolation #45) » Sun Sep 09, 2007 1:44 pm

Erm, SK? WTF? dude. Do you know how likely it is that the sk no killed to fool you. If i was the sk i would certainly do that.

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #782 (isolation #46) » Mon Sep 10, 2007 11:43 am

Weird you guys. At this point i think its OTM, and that Roach is insane cop.

Vote OTM

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #797 (isolation #47) » Wed Sep 12, 2007 9:08 am

I'm a townie, people. I don't have special powers, but I try to be nice unless insulted.

Red Sleigh Down (417)

Gatorguy91 · Post Post #798 (isolation #48) » Wed Sep 12, 2007 11:52 am

Off the Mark wrote:For my own entertainment, I decided to see if Roach is like this in all his games. Here's some comments I enjoyed from another game:

Guys, please, I may or may not be caught up, but I know well enough who deserves to be lynched and who does not. As of right now, what day are we on? Day 1? Let it pass.

I am advocating a No-Lynch for day one. I would like it if others did the same.
He knows who deserves to be lynched, but he wants a no-lynch.

If we don't lynch today, AND TODAY ONLY, the scum won't NK a townie come N1.

Huh?

Well, at least I'm generating discussion.

Well, I still say that a No-Lynch for today is good. We give the Cop an extra night to investigate, y'know...
Good plan!

But a No-Lynch brings Night faster, and therefore exposes the scum IF they NK (which is highly likely they would, but still, they might not). See my tactic?
Comedy gold!

Erm, what? You shouldn't insult anyone like this. This is insane dude.

Vote OTM

cuz i forgot to bold obv