Mini 480 - Boring Town Mafia *GAME OVER*

[Nanosauromo]

Here are your random numbers:

5

Vote: Haschel Cedricson

[Nanosauromo]

Sorry I can't use Bold font for some reason. My Computer's a Mac

So is mine. Just put bold tags around your vote.

Code: Select all

[b]Vote: Bob[/b]

comes out as

Vote: Bob

[Nanosauromo]

Alrighty then!

unvote: Haschel Cedricson

Vote: Haut Boy

He's posted but once in the entire game.

[Nanosauromo]

If we just splurt all over the people in here, the pressure will be too scattered to do anything. So for now, I shall

Unvote, FOS: Everyone Lurking

You say that putting pressure on several people is too scattered to do anything. Then, IN THE SAME POST, you decide do FOS an entire group of players? Way to contradict yourself!

[Nanosauromo]

Unless, of course, you're not scum.

[Nanosauromo]

Also, what I mean when I said, me being suspected and lynched would help in uncovering scum, is that it would eliminate me as a suspect, thus narrowing down the number of people in the game who could be scum.

Time for some numbers.

Right now we have (presumably) 3 scum and 9 townies. If we lynch you today, then yes it will confirm your non-scumminess. However, it will also change the scum-to-town ratio. making it 3 to 8. Then the scum kill someone on night 1, and when Day 2 dawns, we'll have 3 scum to only 7 townies, and no information gained. (Apart from investigations by the Cop.)

To make a long story short: lynching townies is not a Good Thing.

[Nanosauromo]

For the sake of getting discussion going...

unvote; Vote: Daxam

I'll unvote when you start making sense.

[Nanosauromo]

I quit, I'm to busy.

PS: I was a manson.

Alrighty then...

[Nanosauromo]

Okay, I'm really confused. Could someone direct me to where this "Mason claim" occurred?

[Nanosauromo]

(Also, all content in this post is utter BS)

[Nanosauromo]

shut ur mouth .. i hate nerds and turbans

Alrighty then...

[Nanosauromo]

Here.

[Nanosauromo]

I'm still here. Not sure on who to pressure yet.

[Nanosauromo]

Look at the lovely bandwagon. At this rate, we'll speed lynch by the end of the page! Keep it up

scummy.

Are you saying that it's scummy that A: You may have caused a speedlynch on me or B: That Faerie Lord is pointing this out?

If it's B, that seems like you're saying that it's a bad idea to point out the flaws in others, unless it's you doing it.

[Nanosauromo]

Nano and Yagami: don't put words in my mouth. I never stated any reason why I found it to be scummy.

Then why DO you find it to be scummy? For that matter, WHAT did you find scummy? The only reason we were putting words in your mouth was because there was only one coming out.

[Nanosauromo]

I am a cop. On night 1 I investigated IH and got an innocent result. His (unfortuate) death confirms my sanity.

I realize the fact that I'm claiming cop after my only investigatee is dead makes the claim slightly unbelivable, but that's just my luck.

[Nanosauromo]

I agree with Haschel on the subject of FaerieLord, but I don't want to hammer him before he has a chance to actually defend himself one last time. FL, If you haven't posted by Wendsday evening, my vote's going to you. (I'll be asleep when the deadline hits.)

Meanwhile, who does everyone think I should investigate tonight?

[Nanosauromo]

*sigh* I don't have time to present a case and turn a town. Bit more than 24 hours are left. My claim is rubbish since I'm a vanilla and I couldn't defend against a case I could not see anywhere. You still haven't told me the case on me. You just said that I should have made a case on someone.

Whatever

It would take you about the same amount of time to answer our questions as it would to explain why you shouldn't answer them.

[Nanosauromo]

...and with 6 hours left, I highly doubt you'll get around to it, which is why I'll go ahead and

Vote: FaerieLord

(Woohoo, my first hammer!)

[Nanosauromo]

I protected the cop. Who did you investigate Nano?

I investigated Simenon and got an innocent result.

Hm... both people I investigated turned up dead. Maybe I'm a vig and don't know it?

[Nanosauromo]

Nanosauromo, why did you choose to investigate Simenon in preference to any other candidates for investigation? Did he seem most suspicious to you?

In a word, yes. He had a very irregular posting style; sometimes they were detailed analysis, sometimes they were one-liners. His posts were the hardest to understand. Due to a combination of this and gut instinct, I had been suspicious of him for a while, and wanted to know the truth once and for all.

But enough of making a case on someone who's already dead. Who should we pressure next?

[Nanosauromo]

there is either no cop in this game, or there is a real cop who knows you are mafia and is waiting to figure out the third scum before busting you

And what would the "real cop" gain from waiting to bust me? If the "real cop" even exists, me being alive makes it less likely that he will get doc protection. Furthermore, he'd be letting a known (to him) scum live. If there were a "real cop," he would have busted me long before now. I am the real cop.

I suppose it is possible that you are some kind of cop/vig but if so I think you're a scum cop/vig.

What would be the point of having a scum cop/vig? If anyone I investigated was going to die anyway, and I was scum, wouldn't that just make me an SK?

Before this day ends, I'd like you to embed a code in one of your posts that says who you will be investigating. That way you can at least prove to us that you're not just picking the person who was NK'd as the person you "investigated."

You're asking me to breadcrumb? Fine, I have no problems with that. However, keep in mind that the scum may find and decipher the code before they send in their night choice.

"Real cop," if you're out there, go ahead and counterclaim. We'll see who turns up as scum first.

[Nanosauromo]

Simenon looks a stupid move in light of the nightkill (that nano presumably didn't know of), and because both masons claimed I wouldn't have done it were I cop.

Think about it: If we have a claimed mason pair, and one of them turns up as town by investigation, then we pretty much have two confirmed townies. Good, yes?

[Nanosauromo]

I agree that with all but 3 people claimed, we should put pressure on the unclaimed. Yagami has made one post in the past week, so I'll

Vote: Yagimi

.

[Nanosauromo]

Now I'm fairly certain that Yagami is scum. If he was innocent, the real scum would have hammered him by now.

Either that or the two remaining scum are already voting for him. (i.e., Setael and Bookitty)

[Nanosauromo]

Now I'm fairly certain that Yagami is scum. If he was innocent, the real scum would have hammered him by now.

Either that or the two remaining scum are already voting for him. (i.e., Setael and Bookitty)

I wasn't saying that Setael and Bookitty were scum. I was merely pointing out that they were the two non-Nano people voting for him.

[Nanosauromo]

One thing I just noticed though, if he is cop, then he might be naive, as he got innocent with both results.

I got innocent on both results because both people who I investigated turned out to be innocent upon death.

[Nanosauromo]

So you're saying I could be naive because I got innocent results on two people who actually were innocent? I'm naive because I'm getting accurate results?

I'm not following your logic.

[Nanosauromo]

Nanosauromo, how about it? Will you promise not to waste an investigation on TCS or Setael tonight?

Yes, I already know who I'm going after.

A naive cop only gets innocent results Nano, of course they would be innocent for the innocent, they would also be innocent should you investigate scum though.

If I'm naive, then there's probably a real cop. If this were true, he would have counterclaimed by now.

[Nanosauromo]

I'm posting from school. My computer has died, so i'll have VERY limited access for a while.

Just a heads up.

[Nanosauromo]

I'm back online!

Why doesn't nano just confirm me tonight?

Because that would be wasting an investigation.

I

know I'm not scum, so the only reason I'm still alive is that the doc (you) is protecting me.

Another thing, the scum might go after you tonight (killing the doc is a good thing for them), so that would just be another investigatee who turns up dead.

[Nanosauromo]

Yagami, you're at L-1 again. Anything you want to say before hammer time?

[Nanosauromo]

But what happens if

we're both innocent?

Give me one more chance. Lynch an unclaimed today, I'll do another investigation tonight. If the investigatee turns up scum, we lynch him.

[Nanosauromo]

Bah. This is annoying. I had hoped we'd get a replacement who agreed with me...

The "If we go to night"-summary:

The cop investigates one of the

unclaimed

. No one else.
The doc protects one of the

confirmed

. Either Setael or TCS is fine with me.

But if I die due to lack of the doc's protection then you'll never get to hear my investiagation.

[Nanosauromo]

Okay, I investigated Samruc and he's innocent. Where do we go from here?

[Nanosauromo]

FLOC being a godfather would definately explain why I'm still alive. With him turning up innocent, he'd be more concerned with trying to find and kill the vigilante. However, if FLOC is scum, then is there a real doc, and who is it?

[Nanosauromo]

Just to clear this up:
Me = Cop
FLOC = Doc
pete d = mason
Bookitty = unclaimed
Samruc = unclaimed

If this is true, then...

Boo, you said that pete d will likely be NK'd tonight if the person we lynch is town. Why is he a more likely target than anyone else?

[Nanosauromo]

But with his partner dead, pete d is essentially a vanilla townie.

In the case of confirmed townie vs. claimed Doc, the Doc is more likely to prevent the scum from winning. (This assumes that FLOC is town.)

If the scum is one of the unclaimed, then me, pete d, and the other unclaimed have equal odds of being killed, with FLOC having slightly higher odds.

[Nanosauromo]

To the one remaining scum, EVERYONE is confirmed town. If he goes after pete d, there's a possibility that FLOC could protect him. However, the doc can't protect himself, so if FLOC gets targeted, he's dead for sure. If I were scum, then I would definately pick FLOC over pete d for my kill.

[Nanosauromo]

We're not going to get anywhere with just the two of us arguing. pete d, FLOC, what do you guys think?

[Nanosauromo]

I investigated FLOC, and he's innocent. Pete d is confirmed town, and I know I'm not scum, so unless FLOC is a godfather, Bookitty is our only choice left.

Vote: Bookitty

Let's see where this takes us. Remember guys, if we lynch a townie today, then we lose.

[Nanosauromo]

Hang on.

Unvote

We only lose today if we mislynch. Let's go to night without lynching anyone. I'll investigate Bookitty tonight.

Vote: No lynch

In a worst case scenario, I'll get killed, leaving the fate of the game up to pete d. In a best case scanario, the mafia will pull a repeat of last night and not kill, and Bookitty will turn up as guilty.

[Nanosauromo]

I'm not, but the only way to know for sure is for me to investigate you. (Or for you to die.)

[Nanosauromo]

Again, I am not assuming there is no GF, I am saying there is no way for me to know for sure without investigating Bookitty.

[Nanosauromo]

Yes, pete, any input?

[Nanosauromo]

UnVote

So the time has come to choose between Bookitty and FLOC. After looking back, I think I can safely make my choice.

Vote: Bookitty

There was no kill on Night 4. Since the deadline was not reached, it's safe to say that the doc and scum targeted the same person. FLOC protected pete d. Boo, hoping to kill the only confirmed townie and get me lynched on Day 5, tried to kill him.

If FLOC were scum, he would have targeted pete d, for the same reasons as I stated above for Boo. Pete's presence on the List of the Living proves that this is not true. FLOC is doc, Boo is scum.

Pete and FLOC, I hope you'll agree with me.

[Nanosauromo]

It all comes down to this. Either Pete d moves, or I do. If we lynch a townie, we lose. I belive that the remaining scum is Bookitty, so unless one of you can fully convince me that FLOC is scum, my vote stays where it is.

[Nanosauromo]

Pete d can't possibly be scum, and I'm fairly confidant that FLOC is town. Thus, you're the only person left.

You'll find that I'm town (and probably dead, but I don't mind that so much) but if I survive, then you'll be in the same position of knowing there's a godfather in the game

Now that I think about it, going to night is pointless. If you weren't innocent/GF, then I highly doubt you'd risk saying that. Additionally, the scum wouldn't let me live through the night.

If you were a vanilla scum, you would kill me so my investigation results couldn't be made public. If FLOC were, he'd kill me and pin the blame on you.

Pete, any input?

[Nanosauromo]

AND ANOTHER THING:
Look back to Day 3, when Yagaimi was still alive.

Now I'm fairly certain that Yagami is scum. If he was innocent, the real scum would have hammered him by now.

Either that or the two remaining scum are already voting for him. (i.e., Setael and Bookitty)

Yagami turned out to be scum. Setael was town. What say you, Bookitty?

[Nanosauromo]

Fuck, I read that wrong. Disregard my last post.

Unvote

I'm not sure what to think anymore. Pete presents a good argument, plus he's thoe only one I know I can trust, so I'm unvoting for now.

FLOC, if you can't convince pete (and re-convince me) of Boo's guiltiness within a reasonable time, then I'm hammering you.

[Nanosauromo]

Ah, screw it.

Vote: FLOC