New York 181 -- Game Over

[Egg]

@Egg: I'm not surprised that you did - I prefer to get cold reads off of personality and gauging whether a person believes what they are saying at any point. I'd have to imagine Texcat thinks her play is good if she shot Drixx on Night 1. (Same would go for anyone using that logic really). You are probably right in saying that an SK who thinks they are playing poorly wouldn't make a post like that.

If texcat is town, then that is a weird assumption. I originally disliked her making that argument because it ~felt~ wrong. I.E., Why would hunting for an SK hurt town and why can't hunting for it be done in parallel with mafia hunting? Granted, things like VCA and interaction tells only work on mafia so if that is what she is using for scumhunting then trying to stick to mafia hunting makes sense. Assuming the SK is necessarily a strong town player IS kind of weird though. I need to reread from around that time.

Teexcat could be the droids we're looking for.

Hmm. Good point about the Drixx kill. Nailing scum at night feels good and boosts confidence assuming that's what the SK was trying to do. Still though, I'm not so sure it aligns with that comment. I need to think and the library computer kicks me off in like 3 minutes.....................

[Egg]

Tex, why did you think we'd lose good players by SK hunting? Why did you want to hunt mafia over SK when we had one mafia remaining?

[dragonspawn]

Interesting turn on Texcat. I haven't been scum reading him but I like the pressure

[dragonspawn]

Tex, why did you think we'd lose good players by SK hunting? Why did you want to hunt mafia over SK when we had one mafia remaining?

Where did Tex say this?

[Egg]

Here:

Egg, I take it that you agree with going after the SK first? I still think that the remaining scum is easier and we won't

end up losing valuable players in the hunt.

I understand that it makes our cop worthless, but I haven't seen that much value in the cop so far anyway. Although I haven't been able to understand any of the coded messages going back and forth between Ika and Titus.

[dragonspawn]

Maybe ars was killed because she was seen as a firm town read more than suspecting the sk.

Seems that's as reasonable as the other.

[Egg]

Yeah, could be. Like I said, I realize that post made more assumptions than I typically care to make but it seemed like it was worth looking into.

[dragonspawn]

I agree. But does that mean texcat is the sky?

[dragonspawn]

Sk

[Egg]

Not necessarily. Did you read the most recent posts by AP and myself?

[dragonspawn]

Yes. I'm thinking outloud

[AngryPidgeon]

Actually kind of leaning towards voting Texcat now, but I'll feel bad if I'm wrong about it at this stage so let me have some time to let it simmer.

[texcat]

Are you sure you dont want to lynch AP?

Yes.

AP, I forgot about that post. But I dunno. The assumption that the SK is a good player feels weird. But at the same time, I'm not sure if Tex views herself as a good player or not. Or rather I'm not sure if she views her play here as being good play. And at the time she said that, it may have been less true than here. So let me ask you this. Would a person who isn't playing well as SK make a post like that that assumes the SK is a good player? Note that I'm not disagreeing with you. Just trying to look at this critically and encourage you to do the same. Now. If Tex is town, I still want to know why she'd make that assumption. It doesn't look like that was ever explained.

My top reads for SK were Delta and Pisskop and ABR. I didn't want to lynch them when they could still help us find mafia.

[texcat]

I suspected that we would be able to find the scum with fewer mislynches than the SK. I didn't want to go through a whole series of mislynches looking for the SK when we still had scum out there.

[Egg]

Because Delta, Pisskop, and ABR have been so helpful this game....

[pisskop]

doublevote: Texcat

[texcat]

Some were more helpful than others.

[dragonspawn]

You don't have a double vote.

[pisskop]

You don't know that.

[texcat]

UNVOTE: AP
VOTE: Pisskop

[dragonspawn]

Yes I do. We know exactly what roles do or do not exist.

[Egg]

You don't know that.

Lol

[RIP]

Tex is jumping around without care

[RIP]

RIP should be town if I have his meta down right.

His meta of zero completed games?
And "well AP is a good scum player" is a bullshit reason to be voting me. My scumgame is discernible and also better than this.

I have complted3 or 4 games and currently in 7 more

[RIP]

Looking at that list egg why I'm ur number 2? Everyone is calling me town or PL but not scum or Anythang...
I'm confused. Are those people town or scum?