Mini 472 - Cartman Mafia - Game Over

[Off the Mark]

I am very confused by this.

I don't even pretend to be mafia to prevent myself from being nightkilled like many people do.

Who would pretend to be mafia? That's a surefire way to get lynched. And actually, your worry about being nightkilled was one of the most suspicious things about your early posts. It's like you were patting yourself on the back for being such a great pro-town player, when you were nothing of the sort. You barely posted, didn't help the town at all, and every post looked very suspicious.

Your whole thinking on this seems ass-backward, which makes me think you must be looking at everything from a mafia perspective.

[ryan]

Actually OtM, it almost seemed like Sorin was trying to stay away from a possible SK at night but the "acting like a mafia" comment is just plain strange, not really pro town thinking there.

[Estes]

Can we get a prod on anyone who hasn't posted in the last two pages?

[Off the Mark]

Gee whillickers, this game died fast. Why aren't we lynching Sorin?

[Off the Mark]

FOS: Earwig and Dean

for sitting on the sidelines. Either you trust Estes or you don't and you should vote Sorin. You need to state an opinion either way. Trying to lurk through this situation is incredibly suspicious.

[Off the Mark]

Just thinking about the sanity test... what does it mean if J-man gets a guilty result on Zeek?

Possibilities:

1) J-man is a sane cop, Gatorguy and Zeek are both scum - possible but unlikely, because why would Zeek expose himself this way?

2) J-man is scum, but wants us to think that scenario 1 is true, so we lynch Gator or Zeek. <--- quite possible, but it doesn't match my read of J-man

3) J-man is an insane cop, Gatorguy is innocent, Zeek is godfather - now this is interesting... here, Zeek as godfather claims Miller in order to "force" himself to be investigated. Every godfather really wants to be investigated, or else they might as well just be normal mafia. In this case, when J-man comes back with guilty, Zeek would have to convince us that scenario 2 was the truth. I find this highly doubtful and very risky for Zeek.

Just realized I missed one real obvious possibility here.

If Zeek comes up guilty, it could mean J-man is sane, Gatorguy is scum, and Zeek is Miller. In fact, that is probably the most likely case if Zeek comes up guilty.

[ZeekLTK]

They've been sitting on the sidelines since before I claimed miller...

[ryan]

Calling them lurkers is actually a compliment, I'd much rather call them "non contributors"

[ryan]

ryan's unofficial vote count

SorintheSeeker - 4 (OfftheMark, ryan, ChaosOmega, ZeekLTK)
DeanWinchester - 3 (Estes, Gatorguy91, SorintheSeeker)
Earwig- 1 (DeanWinchester)

6 to lynch

Not Voting: J-man, Earwig

[Gatorguy91]

As long as I'm not hammering, I think it would be beneficial for an

Unvote, vote Sorin

[ryan]

^^^You just did that to make my Vote Count look bad didn't you?

[Off the Mark]

As long as I'm not hammering, I think it would be beneficial for an

Unvote, vote Sorin

What makes you not want to hammer?

[Gatorguy91]

As long as I'm not hammering, I think it would be beneficial for an

Unvote, vote Sorin

What makes you not want to hammer?

I'd like to hear from him first. Y'know, see what i can learn.

[ZeekLTK]

We've already heard from him... he thinks the claimed cop (j-man) and someone likely to be town (you) are the most "suspicious" people, and one of the guys he said was "least suspicious" (Estes) then claimed cop and said he got an "innocent" result on Sorin... the + and - post...

What more do you need?

[ZeekLTK]

So, I'm kinda more suspicious of you because of that post. Either your not paying attention or you are trying to delay the hammer saying "wait until we hear from him"... even though we've already heard from him, and he did nothing to make anyone who already had a vote for him change their mind.

j-man, finish Sorin off!

[ryan]

ZeekLTK: Agreed, the problem is (as I stated earlier) we have 4 people doing the brunt of the posting right now and need some insight/content/posting/something from DeanWinchester, Earwig and J-Man on what they think of the Sorin lynch. Estes has already said that Sorin is innocent (by his investigation) Sorin isn't going to self vote so that leaves the above mentioned players that need to weigh in.

[Gatorguy91]

That is a bad state of mind, though. Anything is nice for the town, and if it doesn't matter to get info, you can lynch.

We won't know his role, we'll just know if he's protown- or anti-town.

[J-man]

gladly

Unvote, Vote: Sorin

whether or not your town you deserve this, when people play summy with no redeaming qualities they deserve to be lynched

and Dean IGMEOY

[J-man]

it is now twilight

[ZeekLTK]

We won't know his role, we'll just know if he's protown- or anti-town.

What do you mean?

[Gatorguy91]

Rules

:

• A special rule for this game is that for lynches, the role is not revealed until the next morning. The alignment is know immediately, however.

[ZeekLTK]

Well that was a bit suspicious. j-man hasn't posted in days and then comes in within minutes of the 5th vote to lynch Sorin....

[ryan]

it is now twilight

Which means we can still discuss till night hits (Stewie locks the thread) So any ideas for Day 2 we should talk about right now?

[ZeekLTK]

Rules

:

• A special rule for this game is that for lynches, the role is not revealed until the next morning. The alignment is know immediately, however.

Yeah so we will know his role... just not until morning. That won't matter.

If he is "anti town" then we know Estes is likely to be mafia and the doc should definitely protect j-man. If he was "pro-town" the doc needs to make a random choice I guess.

[ZeekLTK]

[quote="ryan"So any ideas for Day 2 we should talk about right now?[/quote]

Day 2 will depend on if j-man is insane or not (pending my investigation). If he is sane, it'll be a quick day... lynch Gatorguy and identify someone to investigate the next night.

If not, and Sorin was town, probably lynch Estes if the SK doesn't kill him for us tonight.