NY 188: Delicious Mafia II (Post-game chatter)

[Shinobi]

I'm aware, but it's enough to consider the replace inconclusive.

[GrayFoxxxx]

[quote="In post 364 or keep being meh?[/quote]

Probably this.

Maybe it will be good for my town meta variance.

Maybe scum won't believe I'm VT.

Maybe not.

I've been town like my last 4-5 games, just trying to mix it up this time.

[ika]

I'm aware, but it's enough to consider the replace inconclusive.

thats what i meant if your responding to me. i think i jsut did wording fails

anyone want to tubo lynch SW so we dont have to get a replcemtn?

[GrayFoxxxx]

On mobile, sorry for bad format.

[GrayFoxxxx]

I'm aware, but it's enough to consider the replace inconclusive.

thats what i meant if your responding to me. i think i jsut did wording fails

anyone want to tubo lynch SW so we dont have to get a replcemtn?

Sure I'm down for a quick D1 lynch

[Nosferatu]

That rage seems a bit different from this one, this one involves more profanity and general sensitivity. More townish rage if you ask me.

[Nosferatu]

Also I'm against the SW lynch just so you don't have to deal with a replacement, often in games replacements scumhunt with a different perspective from the rest of us, and might reveal something we overlooked.

Though I''m sure it'll be another scumread on me ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[Mahonster]

I would definitely call Silver town until late game.

[Shinobi]

VOTE: greyfoxx

There is zero reason for that early claim, beyond hurting town. The red vote was atrocious. Posts are three naked votes, an unneeded claim, and a "So what".

He's actively NOT ENGAGING, and just slinging votes.

Greyfox, are you going to engage at this point, or keep being meh?

Yeah I didn't really like this scumread.
Claiming vt doesn't mean he's claiming scum.
Lots of surface-level stuff that doesn't really relate to his alignment tbh.

[Skybird]

I don't know what to think of SW's replace request. I know she was really looking forward to this game so I don't know why she would replace out this quickly.

[Wake1]

Reading this thread, someone said I'm playing my scum meta, but I'm actually busy with work and school.

I can't make it any clearer: my work life

does

affect my ability to play, as in post frequency and intensity.

Because of this, the way I play

has

to change to something far more brief and succinct, or I just drop Mafia.

The days of me providing large, thorough posts are over.

I don't know what to think about Wolfie's replace request. She did replace out once as Scum. I can't remember which game, and I may be wrong, but I could have sworn she reacted more angrily in one of our games when she was Scum, because it was tough keeping up the facade [and weight] of being Scum. I can't remember past games too well, and I definitely don't have time taking notes of how other players played months past.

Gonna skim through and see what's what.

[T S O]

Yes, yes, we know SW is scum.

[T S O]

Also, people who are highly suspect, like Mahonster and Nosferatu, calling SW town makes me even more uncomfortable with the idea.

[T S O]

I don't know what Fox is like as scum, since he posted like three times in Masquerade, but I think I have a vague townread on him for the sheer badness of his play so far. He doesn't really seem interested in looking good, which is ...kinda town? But really not something anyone else should try emulating.

[T S O]

Ika is town, Shinobi could be anything but at least he's capable of coherency.

[T S O]

Sala is ...probably town, but I am not particularly confident on that. It's really not a stable townread.

[T S O]

In fact, make Shinobi town for now, he did some good stuff early.

[T S O]

I'm assuming singleball, so Red-thing is probably not scum. Confession: I literally haven't read a single post of his.

[T S O]

Lapsa is still probably scum, Ozgin is probably town.

[Annadog40]

Why did you break that up into tons of posts when you only needed one reads post?

[Ozgin]

"I haven't read a single one of red's posts" = "red is town."

I... what?

[Ozgin]

Well, "red is probably not scum," is more accurate. Still, why?

[T S O]

Why did you break that up into tons of posts when you only needed one reads post?

It's a playstyle, dear. I suggest you try making some reads, in one post or many, rather than asking stupid questions.

Well, "red is probably not scum," is more accurate. Still, why?

Well, you can deduce red-town from things like scum pushing it, as well as many dubious people on it with dubious votes... but mainly because I read the game and remembered none of his posts. If he's that unmemorable, it's highly unlikely that the reasons people have for voting him are shit.

[Mahonster]

I'm suspect for calling Silver town until late game? That replace out says town to me, and I'm not judging based entirely on meta like everyone else is here. I prefer the idea that meta really doesn't mean anything, especially in Silver's case.

[T S O]

No, your shaky reasons for voting redd make you suspect.

Silver's towngame and scumgame are quite different, so meta is an effective tool. Nacho and ABR caught her using it here, for example. Disdain of meta might be the new cool kid, but meta definitely has its place. At any rate, you've just been shown that Silver has replaced out as scum in the past, so regardless of your opinion on meta, I don't understand why you feel it would make her town until lategame, unless you are simply incredibly naive.