NY 187: Pariah's Mafia [/FIN]

[Aeronaut]

[BlueBloodedToffee]

VOTE: Dave

[Aeronaut]

Yea.

VOTE: Dave

[Aeronaut]

Garmr is still really town in my opinion though. I think.

FA I don't know. RC I don't know. Dave seems like scum to me so thats probably where my vote's staying today

[Aeronaut]

Titus, Boon, Garmr all seem town.

Was thinking key was pretty town but some of what BBT said there was kind of true

[Bulbazoor]

True, my scumdar ws pinged by dave a few times.

VOTE: DAVESAZ

[Aeronaut]

The reason Garmr seems town to me is that the whole "RC was telling me to fake cop" thing, while misguided, also seems pretty genuine to me. Like I don't see a scenario where scum says it like that.

[Kitty Galore]

I guess because BBT claimed a PR.

VOTE: unvote

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Nowhere better to place your vote?

[Kitty Galore]

I hate the votes on kop. There is not much to be gained by that lynch.

I said I didn't like the Titus entrance. Nothing has really changed my mind.

VOTE: Titus

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Thoughts on Dave?

[FA_Q2]

The reason Garmr seems town to me is that the whole "RC was telling me to fake cop" thing, while misguided, also seems pretty genuine to me. Like I don't see a scenario where scum says it like that.

Really because I see that as a really scummy move. I didn't scum read him until that point.

It looks to me like he wanted to use the 'dragon was copped guilty by someone else' as a ploy to push a mislynch with the force of a cop claim and then be able to squirm out of it the next day if dragon flipped town.

Right now I am willing to go with bulb, garmr or bbt. All three are scummy IMHO.

[FA_Q2]

Titus, Boon, Garmr all seem town.

Was thinking key was pretty town but some of what BBT said there was kind of true

How in the heck can you town read boon?

He has posted nothing.

[TheDominator37]

UNVOTE:
thinking time again

[Aeronaut]

Titus, Boon, Garmr all seem town.

Was thinking key was pretty town but some of what BBT said there was kind of true

How in the heck can you town read boon?

He has posted nothing.

Well, it's not a strong townread. I've just played with boon a few times before and had him in my games and know this is pretty usual for him.

[Titus]

@Kitty,

What do you think of Dave?

What do you think is terrible about my entrance?

[Titus]

@FAQ2, talk to me about Bulb.

[Garmr]

The reason Garmr seems town to me is that the whole "RC was telling me to fake cop" thing, while misguided, also seems pretty genuine to me. Like I don't see a scenario where scum says it like that.

Really because I see that as a really scummy move. I didn't scum read him until that point.

It looks to me like he wanted to use the 'dragon was copped guilty by someone else' as a ploy to push a mislynch with the force of a cop claim and then be able to squirm out of it the next day if dragon flipped town.

Right now I am willing to go with bulb, garmr or bbt. All three are scummy IMHO.

so you think dragon is actually town can you tell me why

[Titus]

For 1215 , I want to know more than pings. I want why.

[dragonspawn]

The reason Garmr seems town to me is that the whole "RC was telling me to fake cop" thing, while misguided, also seems pretty genuine to me. Like I don't see a scenario where scum says it like that.

Really because I see that as a really scummy move. I didn't scum read him until that point.

It looks to me like he wanted to use the 'dragon was copped guilty by someone else' as a ploy to push a mislynch with the force of a cop claim and then be able to squirm out of it the next day if dragon flipped town.

Right now I am willing to go with bulb, garmr or bbt. All three are scummy IMHO.

so you think dragon is actually town can you tell me why

Could you tell me why I am?

And why you need to fake a guilty on me if its so obvious?

[Garmr]

I have made cases in 5he past they are in my iso. Also I really thought you were guilty. Phone post

[davesaz]

I dunno, maybe I'm overreacting. My knee jerk reaction was towards Garmr's attempt to reinforce the Dragon read with a "guilty". It was OK when it seemed he just picked up on a crumb, but when it came out that he was doing it on purpose (after getting a suggestion to do exactly that no less) that didn't set right with me. I don't want an actual cop to be outed by mistake. I mean if I had a guilty result on someone I'd want to try to push it myself without interference. If someone picked up on my crumb I'd appreciate the vote but would not want them to call it out as s crumb. Imagine if it were an innocent crumb -- that would be even worse because we wouldn't even get a scum lynch in exchange.

Now sure, being willing to take a NK by taking a crumb and saying it's

your

guilty, that would be a noble gesture. I must admit I probably would not think to do that. I don't think that is what happened here BTW.

RC would be mega scummy if he let the guilty by proxy fly. Owning up to it right away doesn't seem to come from scum motivation, unless the idea was to hang Garmr in the process. But the smart play would be to let it run for a while, almost get to a lynch, and then call it off.

What if it was still a scum ploy, to get a wagon started on Dragon and then throw icewater on it. I could see doing that if Dragon was scum and RC was the buddy. But only if RC could predict what Garmr would do, and he could predict the lynch wouldn't go through.

So many possibilities. I bet scum are watching us run in circles, laughing their asses off. I think I'll poke around the edges of this mess a bit.

Garmr -- one last thing before I let you go. You say the case is in your ISO but could you do the old guy a favor and summarize please? Maybe Dragon is scum after all -- I was willing to go along and believe the crumb we both saw because I had no confidence he is town.

[Titus]

I don't think Dragon's scum her but I should hear this out.

[pisskop]

Ankamius replaces TheCow

[Ankamius]

Confirming.

Anything specific I need to look at right away?