NY 188: Delicious Mafia II (Post-game chatter)

[Annadog40]

And me and fro99er. Our whole neighborhood

[Skybird]

I had reasons to both like and dislike that post.
Who is scum, exactly?

ive kind of been caught up on pushing tso so i haven't been thinking about this too much but mahonster annadog and kop are my strong scumreads rn

who do you think is scum shinobi?

Red, I don't think you've ever explained why Mahonster is scum. Could you explain please?

[Lapsa]

check SW

@Shin

it's "lets turbolynch someone" slot

end of day1 plays were strange. but that reminds me how off Titus feels when replacing in

I've lurked her game before. same game which happens to be first mafiascum game for SilverWolf.
she was PR there iirc. plays seem familiar but I doubt she's PR again

I think that TSO is groupscum and SwampCat helped to make SK claim plausible

I also find it harder to trust SilverWolf for the very same reason.
Wake wagon grew fair amount after mentioning that SilverWolf's town alignment ain't definitive.
especially now after she flip-flopped her vote back to TSO and then to redFF

I don't really understand push on Mahonster

Can you talk to me about your vote and your read on me?

Eventually.

there's now an update regarding this topic which seems equally shit to me:

I've been busy with school stuff, so I'm trying to work up the momentum to read the pages I haven't read all in one go so I can stop thinking about it.

here's a new thing I'm puzzled about:

I've mostly changed my mind on you because of your claim, which would make reasonable sense from Town or a Maf Traitor but not from groupscum probably.
I'm discounting the Traitor atm because it's not very likely.
Though that would be one hell of a coincidence.

mafia traitor hood inspector?! o_0

being fairly inactive, whining about talkativeness yet writing shit she finds highly unlikely herself seems off

also - SwampCat still sits on "fuck me - I haven't read game yet" excuse.
I learned it hard way that town should keep mouth shut when behind

[Skybird]

Lapsa, is GM SwampCat? I'm guessing that is the case since you are quoting her.

[Lapsa]

Lapsa, is GM SwampCat? I'm guessing that is the case since you are quoting her.

Aero is SwampCat

[Skybird]

Lapsa, is GM SwampCat? I'm guessing that is the case since you are quoting her.

Aero is SwampCat

Aero is the mod, not a player. So how can Aero sit on a "haven't read the game" excuse not to vote?

[ika]

my god how hard is it to get a damned scum lynch

SW the reason why i can get ayway with doing nothing is cus i generate enough town cred during a part of the game that people shrug me off. after that if ppl start suspecting me i can easily come in and change it.

like i said check SW

[Lapsa]

Aero is the mod, not a player. So how can Aero sit on a "haven't read the game" excuse not to vote?

Aero is omnipotent. he can use excuse of reading game by not reading his excuses

[Shinobi]

Lapsa, gm is lazy as town.
Wait until she contributes, then we can read into her.

[Nosferatu]

Lapsa, is GM SwampCat? I'm guessing that is the case since you are quoting her.

Aero is SwampCat

Aero is the mod, not a player. So how can Aero sit on a "haven't read the game" excuse not to vote?

Lapsa is being satirical.

[T S O]

In fairness, it's so bizarrely deadpan that it's easy to misintepret.

[T S O]

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Dilemma

One of these is what TSO will most likely attempt to achieve. I'm fine with putting him on a leash, but make it tight. And preferably with a built-in electrocution device.

I wanna vote TSO, but it's L-2, there's no point in keeping him of no one wants to leash, but I don't want ika to hammer suddenly...

Can you explain why you were willing to leash in #2225, but not in #2421? Because more people support the leash now than they did then, so your reason for voting is pretty suspect.

[Lapsa]

Because more people support the leash now than they did then

[Nosferatu]

People started to oppose the leashing. I am fine with lynching or leashing you. If it comes to a point where people don't want you around I will just switch my vote back. Simple.

[Nosferatu]

*people where opposing the leashing

[Nosferatu]

*were

[T S O]

Meh, I'd rather you took your vote off, but that makes sense.

[Mahonster]

You apparently missed the entire point of the "just trust me part". It's not supposed to be discussed because hey guess what that's anti-town.

No, that's not how this game works. You don't get to not explain your reads and call people out for asking you why by saying "that's anti-town."

No, there can definitely be anti-town discussion based around some reads

occasionally

.
The difference there is if I were to claim anti-town regularly and not explain my reads. Which I haven't.

I'm not saying that we shouldn't discuss, there just becomes a point where people want to avoid accidentally edging for a softclaim or information outing.

-Mahonster-your recent posts confuse me, you are kind of all over the place

Yeah, that's pretty normal.

[redFF]

lol @ people listening to the confirmed not town

[T S O]

Keep up the mindless rhetoric, my dear.

[Nosferatu]

Meh, I'd rather you took your vote off, but that makes sense.

I'm pretty sure I'm voting RedFF rn.

[goodmorning]

Goodmorning and Ozgin, could you two vote Red? Thank you.

There are eleven days left in this Day phase. Maybe I'll vote Red once I'm caught up, maybe I'll start defending Red once I'm caught up, I don't know but I'm not moving my vote til I've read the rest.

@Lapsa: Not sure you've noticed, but catching up is difficult when the game grows as quickly as this one.

[T S O]

Turns out I missed four posts, one of which was your vote. Thanks for your time.

[Quaroath]

VOTE: redff posting from phone, but this is the dir ed crooning want to go today. Here or texcat/mah

Can you explain this vote? Also, explain if you still think mah is scum or who else is scum?

Firebringer-Who do you think is scum? You read on Red especially considering you are in a hood with him?

Shinobi-What's your objection to Texcat kill? Why is she town? I'm tired and can't remember if I asked you that in my last quote wall.

@Ozgin-If you don't want to lynch TSO, do you have a good idea on who you do think is scum today?

Skybird-Same question as Ozgin.

Basically, the three names I listed are my top 3 for scumgroup.

I think RED's flip will peg more associative tells than Mah.

I'm confident that red is the better play long term. Mah is going to trip himself up eventually with the tactics he's using to stay "active". He's focusing on neighborhoods, rather than scumhunting.

Well, he's trying to scum hunt through hoods. Not quite the same thing. It REALLY reminds me hard core of Billi's play in Zed. It's the primary reason he's my #2 scum.

[Quaroath]

Narrowed things down to:

-Red-still not sure why he's town

-Quaroath-sheeping every popular vote

-Mahonster-your recent posts confuse me, you are kind of all over the place

-Lapsa-need some stronger stances on things

-Texcat-not doing anything resembling scumhunting or anything at all really

-And maybe GM-not enough explanation for reads, votes, and entrance still bugs me

-maybe Shinobi but this is the least likely, mostly here because I am having trouble finding good scumreads and he seems defensive about what happened in the hood with the "scumslip" business

Well, I could always vote the non-scummy people if you like.