NY 187: Pariah's Mafia [/FIN]

[Kitty Galore]

Too risky IMO. Thoughts on Hermit please?

I been know to take risks. That slot can die I am up for that lynch.

I wonder why myself or Garmr didn't die. I'm also wondering why there was only two kills.

I wish I hadn't got so fucking annoyed at start of D2.

I'll probably die after a couple of scum have dropped. Scum team a(daves) Need to kill the other scum to = the field scum team B need to kill scum team a to have breathing room.

I could get behind kitty. She hasn't done a lot.

I don't think I could get behind BBT, though. I actually do see the Odd-night vig claim as plausible, but I feel like he would have said Odd-night to begin with if he were lying. I sort of wonder why he'd still be alive, though at this point.

Garmr what do you think of Key? I feel like he was really prominent and talkative early on and now he's basically nowhere.

Bit suspicious was going to wait a little longer to see what he does.

Ok lets try this from a new angle
People I know are town-
Me
People who I feel are town
Titus
Blue waffle-maybe a sk still with his power role scum need to be shooting him soon anyway.
ank- feels like his you could be anyone 2&3

I feel like
Aero
Kitty
Faq2

Are pretty good candidates for scum. In fact

VOTE: KittyGalore

Can I be added to your town list?
I will be your best friend

No but seriously, why Kitty?

Kitty attacking DS day 1 wagon early is a trait shared with dave
Her staying away from the two wagons day 2 (me and dave) is a pretty good indicator she didn't want to be on any of the lynches. Espically since she had a scum read on me which makes me think she knew I was going to flip town and she didn't want the negative attention on her for tipping the scales towards me.

That is terrible. DS was town? I was attacking a wagon on town. Lol
Also, I explained why I joined neither wagon. I didn't like the people on the wagons and I didn't feel confident enough to make a vote on either one. Nice try though.

So, instead of trying to edit the above post like I did before, I will just leave it be. This is what I intended my original post to look like. Garmr, please don't try to "fix" my posts. Thanks.

I like how you changed some of it to be quotes from me, when they are yours! Isn't there some kind of rule against that?

I will post your "fix" and respond now.

[Kitty Galore]

Bit suspicious was going to wait a little longer to see what he does.

I did not say that. It was you.

Ok lets try this from a new angle
People I know are town-
Me
People who I feel are town
Titus
Blue waffle-maybe a sk still with his power role scum need to be shooting him soon anyway.
ank- feels like his you could be anyone 2&3

I feel like
Aero
Kitty
Faq2

Are pretty good candidates for scum. In fact

VOTE: KittyGalore

Can I be added to your town list?
I will be your best friend

No but seriously, why Kitty?

Kitty attacking DS day 1 wagon early is a trait shared with dave
Her staying away from the two wagons day 2 (me and dave) is a pretty good indicator she didn't want to be on any of the lynches. Espically since she had a scum read on me which makes me think she knew I was going to flip town and she didn't want the negative attention on her for tipping the scales towards me.

That is terrible. DS was town? I was attacking a wagon on town. Lol
Also, I explained why I joined neither wagon. I didn't like the people on the wagons and I didn't feel confident enough to make a vote on either one. Nice try though.

Well, apparently I suck this game.

I do have to wonder why BBT is still alive though.

I am thinking that may be the point of him still being alive.

But...

@BBT-why did you vig kill Bulbs?

Tried to fix kittys formatting here but this is simple.

I call her likely to be scum she goes off and calls me suspicious which I think is her counter reaction to being suspected.

you attacking the DS wagon may of been to try and gain town cred as you never did make a good case as to why dragon was town and only said it to gain town cred.

You didn't like the people on the wagons of a scum read and null read coming to the end of the day when your vote was defiantly not going to be lynched where is the town logic in that. If you were town You should of pushed the lynch to what you thought was scum and placed your vote on me day 2. Not liking people on two wagons you don't have town reads on is a pathetic excuse I would expect out a newbie game.

It would make sense if your were hesitant to if you were scum seeing the support for a dave wagon the easiest option would to be vote neither as there's a chance your scum buddy dave might survive and if he dies latter on they won't be pinning you for pushing the votes over my side of the spectrum. There's plenty of scum motive here.
Her reasoning

So misrep #1- I didn't call you suspicious, those are your words referring to someone else.

Dave I was leaning more town on, but didn't care for a couple of his posts. I wasn't willing to vote either one of you. I was leaning on both of you as being opposite of the lean on the people on your wagons. It was confusing, so I let it alone. I figured in time it would sort itself out, and it did.

I KNEW I didn't like Titus' entrance and scumread her for it and voted her. What is scummy about that again? Oh, and you would expect my play from a newb? I am a newb. It made sense at the time to not vote either of you because my feelings were conflicted. I think that is pretty townie, I don't understand why you don't.

[Kitty Galore]

Ugh and I messed up again, the top lines, the one that says, "I didn't say that, you did" was referring to the bolded by me, above.

[Garmr]

Ok I didn't realize those were my words my bad.

My points still pretty much stand even with the misunderstanding of one line.

[Titus]

@Duppin, normally I am inclined to agree. Regardless, most of the wagon was wierd yesterday. If the wagon D2 was all or mostly town, scum knew they could start a riot on Dragon/ronit and get them lynched. That's my biggest reservation with the wagon. Sure Aero is fmpov, the most likely scum.

[pisskop]

Prodding St Constantine the Hermit, Aeronaut, and Ankamius.

You have all weekend to respond.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

Pisskop, you need to relax on people man

[Firebringer]

Yes, I have been surprised how many times I have gotten out of being lynched. I hide behind others scumhunting passion.

The only time I actually get lynched is when ppl are just seriously confused/frustrated, so they lynch me as a last resort.

Teach me your ways!
You have so much to offer an aspiring player like me who wants to get out of lynches more often.

I am currently running at getting lynched in 17% of games so far in my games (1/6 completed)

This must be answered Hermit.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

Well you could always lurk

[Titus]

VLA tomorrow

[Garmr]

@my tip for town or scum is to just point out every thing you see maybe chuck out a case that is null and see how the person reacts

[Garmr]

@fire bringer

[Garmr]

Also is it bad I think the D's slot lynch was beneficial to town

[Kitty Galore]

Adding Garmr to my scum list. Not because he is voting or accusing me. Mostly for trying to make the argument that I didn't vote him because I "knew he would flip town". Actually I was scum reading him more and town reading Dave more. I was wrong, and I was surprised. I was leaning the opposite of the people on the wagons. I am not, and was never certain he would flip town.

So Boon, you gonna play this game or not?

And I have been feeling Aero scummy for awhile now, that train had lost steam.

VOTE: Aeronaut

[Firebringer]

Can we get a VC here?

EVERYONE PUSH FOR AERONAUT! BELIEVE IN THE WAGON

[Aeronaut]

Oh jeeze

[Aeronaut]

If I'm not already lynched I'll post in a bit.

[pisskop]

Votecount 4.02

---

Aeronaut

- (5) BlueBloodedToffee, Titus, Firebringer, St Constantine the Hermit, Kitty Galore

Kitty Galore

- (2) garmr, Aeronaut

St Constantine the Hermit

- (1) Boonskies

Not Voting:

Kitty Galore, Keyser Söze, duppin, FA_Q2, Ankamius

---

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch.
Deadline is 09SEP15, (expired on 2015-09-09 14:00:00)

Keysor Soze is V/LA until 31AUG15
Titus is V/LA until 8/30/15

[Ankamius]

Hi.

Can someone point me to the Aero case?

[Aeronaut]

Hmm... Ok I may have been wrong here.

UNVOTE:

[Aeronaut]

My original thoughts about Kitty were that she would just show up now and then and comment on one or two select things. I had also thought that what she said and what she voted were usually inconsistent, but looking back, (especially at the dragon wagon), Kitty actually had been saying she thought Dragon was town or at least null for a lot of the game before that. I also found a lot of posts of hers that were catchup that I guess I missed or just didn't see.

I don't really know why I had her pegged as being as shady and lurky as I did, but that just tells me that I need to read up on a few more things and see what I'm missing here.

[Aeronaut]

Boonskiies
Firebringer
FA_Q2
Saint Constantine the Hermit
Ankamius

[Aeronaut]

These people are total mysteries to me.

[Firebringer]

I am the most interesting man in mafia.

[Aeronaut]

Garmr was counter-wagon to Dave - Garmr is town.

People who pushed Garmr/avoided Dave need to be looked at.

VOTE: Fire

This is scum.

VOTE: davesaz

Null on Gamr

Obvious bussing. Even gives himself a reason to jump off by 'looking into them both more later'. He had already done a 'bit of reading' and decided Dave was a good vote.

I vote Dave cause gamr wasn't pinging scum to me so went for next best thing

Making his vote look weak so he can easily backtrack from it.

Hmmm UNVOTE: davesaz

This wagon isn't that good either.
I am getting town from davesaz most.

While gamr is more active most of his content is well lackluster. I don't think it is really coming from scum though.

I don't really like either of these tbh.
Feels like two wagons on town.

Now he is getting town from Dave? Where did this come from? Unfortunately, Fire was so generic and vague about his reads that it's hard to criticize them. It does show a very clear lack of read progression though.

I guess gamr is a better wagon, but idk.
Don't really trust it.

Looking to hop on Garmr if presented with the opportunity of just Garmr or Dave.

I don't know who to vote!!!!

Someone give me compelling case in either.
This is frustrating neither appear scummy.

Acting like nobody had provided reasons for either Dave or Garmr being scum.

Can we speed lynch this?

Hey BBT, I really liked this case, and it seems like you did to. What happened to it, why stop pursuing this and switch to voting for FA's "scum slip?"?