NY 190: Molla's Large Normal

[Luna Fox]

Then why did you vote performer?

[Luna Fox]

Sky, who'd you send to? Everyone's alive, no one can duck out.

Also what is even this?

[Aj The Epic]

Because I was thinking about keeping that to myself (about neighbor) and seeing if there's a chance he'd just out his scum buddy. However, I felt I gave too much away if there was something wrong and a truthful role claim ought to be enough.

As for Performer, bar incriminating evidence on someone else, he's my lynch. I don't think I need to explain why I think he's scum.

[FA_Q2]

There is the possibility that I got hit as well. However considering yesterday's events, I'm betting it was you that got shot at.

Sky, who'd you send to? Everyone's alive, no one can duck out.

Why?

[Aj The Epic]

very productive question. Could only be topped if I knew what the hell you were asking about.

[FA_Q2]

Okay to be less cryptic, Worst is a friendly neighbor. This is almost exactly what choof/skybird have claimed. There's almost no way I expect there to be TWO in this game.

This is interesting. I have not been in a game with this particular role before so I don't know how rare it would be to have two in the same game. Sky claimed:

I have stuff to do today and will be afk quite a bit. I will send my message to one of these three players:

FA_Q2, VeeGee, IamInnocent.

As soon as the thread re-opens for D2, I will post who I sent it to. I ask that the player who receives the message confirm it in their first post on D2.

I received nothing. I guess we will see when veegee or innocent shows up.
pedit: Why do you think the target last night was you or luna?

[Luna Fox]

Because I was thinking about keeping that to myself (about neighbor) and seeing if there's a chance he'd just out his scum buddy. However, I felt I gave too much away if there was something wrong and a truthful role claim ought to be enough.

As for Performer, bar incriminating evidence on someone else, he's my lynch. I don't think I need to explain why I think he's scum.

What i mean is wouldnt skybird be confscum to you, so why is your vote on performer instead.
As for the outing the friendly neighbor thing you could've played along with the amnesiac cop theory, but oh well.

[Aj The Epic]

@Faq2: I can spell it out for you: I'm a 2 shot bullet proof doctor.

@Luna because I'm not sure what exactly it means right now. Friendly neighbors aren't anything more than innocent children who need night phases to work.

[FA_Q2]

Of note: friendly neighbor, if I understand the role correctly, would be an absolute horrible scum claim - it would give them little town credit but tie them with whoever had to lie about receiving the message. I am not quite sure what to take from the possibility that we have 2 claiming it.

[Aj The Epic]

That's part of why I'm currently giving Skybird the benefit of the doubt. Better claims exist and choof technically didn't have to claim.

[FA_Q2]

@Faq2: I can spell it out for you: I'm a 2 shot bullet proof doctor.

@Luna because I'm not sure what exactly it means right now. Friendly neighbors aren't anything more than innocent children who need night phases to work.

Not sure what to take from that.

Why claim now? this does not make sense to me.

[FA_Q2]

I get that the BP gives you some protection for that claim but...

[Luna Fox]

You said this before:

There's almost no way I expect there to be TWO in this game.

Which is why im asking
Besides, about TheWorst's Friendly neighbor claim we got nothing more than your word as of right now.
Anyway, i'll wait for other people to give their opinion.

[Luna Fox]

I do agree tho, that Choof probably didn't fake claim, because that'd be the worst thing ever. There's another possibility but im putting it in the back for now.

[Aj The Epic]

Why claim now? this does not make sense to me.

Two reasons: Titus isn't driving this town a second longer and I'm just clearing luna for good.

Tbh it scum doesn't have a strongman, they aren't going to come after me. Wasting two more kills before they can get me is suicide to them so it's about as safe a time to claim as ever.

Luna, you've become quite the critic. See if you get someone to counterclaim doctor then if you want to base my trustworthiness on that.

[Luna Fox]

Luna, you've become quite the critic. See if you get someone to counterclaim doctor then if you want to base my trustworthiness on that.

I will criticize everything that doesn't make sense in my head, i like your explanation so far so i wont indulge further.

[ChannelDelibird]

VOTE: FAQ2

Two-shot Bulletproof Doctor would be an

amazing

claim for scum in this scenario but I think that it's much more likely that Aj is just town. Still not voting Performer, mind.

[I Am Innocent]

I received nothing last night either.

What are the chances scum fake claimed a role I've never played with, only to have a town player with that role?

Luna you thinking bus driver or something? Wouldn't that affect targets (AJ) instead of who it came from tho (TheWorst vs sky bird)***

I'm going to wait to hear from those two before I cast a vote.

*** Titus you mentioned D1 that you can have up to 2 non normal roles in a normal game. I was not familiar with that rule, where can I verify that?

mod feel free to clarify if you are aware of this rule too

[ashtonbrady45]

Confirmed

[I Am Innocent]

Confirmed

vote ashtonbrady

[Salamence20]

Hi

[Titus]

VOTE: AJ

Two shot bp doctor is the most broken role ever in existence. Why AJ isn't turbo lynched, I have no idea. I would be tempted to fake cc but I am vla most of the day.

Combine that with a friendly neighbor, then scum can afford only one lynch or crosskill to win. That's absurd.

If mafia have a strongman, then the bp may be useless but in that case why include it?

[Titus]

@IAI, Check the large normal wiki unless they took it out with the latest revision, it's still there.

[ChannelDelibird]

But who

makes up

a two-shot bulletproof doctor? Who decides that that's their plausible fakeclaim?

[Titus]

Any scum who wants to survive going for a too scummy to scum defense.