Open 41-Quicklynch Nightless GAME OVER!, before 492

[Sir Tornado]

Ok, I am getting increasingly concerned about Paradox's behaviour. He has already hammered two townies, and has now cast, what I think is an unreasonable second vote on Groinhammer. I am, as of now tending to side with Groinhammer. In my mind, IH looks much scummier than Groinhammer. His vote on Groinhammer in 180 baffles me, and I can't see it as anything other than OMGUS.

May be it's just me, but this appears to be a very lynch happy town. 3 lynches in the first 7 pages? We should slow down a bit.

I am also not liking Estes right now. He's too wishy washy for me. He is not taking any concrete stands. He is hinting at scumminess (he attacked Gator and Groinhammer, and then said he did not actually call them scummy) of people, but not exactly calling them out for it.

FOS Paradox

HOS Estes

Not sure if IH is scummy enough to FOS... I'll just

NOS IH

(Nail of suspicion) for now.

[DeathSauce]

Analysis Pt. II

paradoxombie

: This guy has been all over the place. He makes a few valid points, but veers wildly into OMGUS. He doesn't mind hammering in a game where hammering someone has been a kiss of instant death. He places a vote that isn't a hammer vote, but it turns out to be one, and he says he thought he was hammering anyway! It's so hard to get a solid read on him that I am going to declare him suspicious just so I don't have to think about him anymore.

SirTornado

: Solid town play. Made an excellent catch in noticing that AdamTheAmazing was seemingly instructing fellow scummers in how to advance. Asks a lot of questions, and follows up on them. Doesn't vote without articulating the reason. These are all things that I like townies to do, and therefore I am inclined to believe he is town.

Streeflo

(replacing AdamTheAmazing): Another case where the predecessor is going to slightly influence me. As someone that replaces often I know that doesn't seem fair, but it's the way it is. So far has been targeting paradox. One odd thing that stands out is when he says to JDodge , referring to a possible Khel lynch, "Why doesn't someone

vote

khelvaster then?" I'm not sure what he meant by that and would like an explanation. On the surface it seems like it might be another bit of direction to fellow scummers, like his predecessor seemed to be guilty of. I classify Streeflo as a FoS.

I think that is everyone that is still alive.

[DeathSauce]

EBWOP:

Paradox's weirdo vote on groinhammer doesn't help his cause. I think groinhammer has explained at least 3 times his suspicion of IH. Elevate paradox's suspicion level in the post above.

[Paradoxombie]

EBWOP:

Paradox's weirdo vote on groinhammer doesn't help his cause. I think groinhammer has explained at least 3 times his suspicion of IH. Elevate paradox's suspicion level in the post above.

I hadn't noticed.

Unvote

[Streeflo]

One odd thing that stands out is when he says to JDodge , referring to a possible Khel lynch, "Why doesn't someone

vote

khelvaster then?" I'm not sure what he meant by that and would like an explanation. On the surface it seems like it might be another bit of direction to fellow scummers, like his predecessor seemed to be guilty of. I classify Streeflo as a FoS.

A lot of people were expressing their suspicion on Khel, but nobody was doing any voting or action. I didn't find Khel too suspicious, so I didn't do anything.

paradoxombie

: This guy has been all over the place. He makes a few valid points, but veers wildly into OMGUS. He doesn't mind hammering in a game where hammering someone has been a kiss of instant death. He places a vote that isn't a hammer vote, but it turns out to be one, and he says he thought he was hammering anyway! It's so hard to get a solid read on him that I am going to declare him suspicious just so I don't have to think about him anymore.

When I put 1 vote on paradoxombie, he got extremely defensive and went on about the death warrant of one vote.

The way he twists my words and attacks me is very scum-like. I also don't like how he votes me so freely. I see votes in this game as being total approval for a lynch considering that you are essentially signing their death warrant if they're town. Is it possible he doesn't realize that this isn't a normal game? Or maybe that is simply his fallback excuse?

[Paradoxombie]

When I put 1 vote on paradoxombie, he got extremely defensive and went on about the death warrant of one vote.

And yet you agreed that it was a death warrant.

[Sir Tornado]

Can the people voting Khelvaster please carefully lay out the reasons for their vote? I don't necessarily suspect them, but if he ends up being a mislynch we're back to nothing to scumhunt but a bandwagon with no reasoning.

While I see the possibility that they are partners, I don't see why you'd choose to vote IH over Khelv. Khelv seems significantly more scummy to me.

Did you, or did you not suspect Khelvaster? Your post 107 looks very ambiguous to me.

[ryan]

"Nothing settled" Vote Count

(1) Paradoxombie (Streeflo)
(1) IH (groinhammer)
(1) groinhammer (IH)


Not Voting: Gatorguy91, Paradoxombie, Sir Tornado, Estes, Jdodge, DeathSauce

With 9 Alive it's 4 to Lynch

[MCHammer]

I think at this point, & in the interests of gaining information, I’d like to

unvote, vote: paradoxombie

– the thing is, I’m not even going to explain my reasons for voting you as I see the reasons for being suspicious of you as too obvious to even bother typing out.

I’d like to also state that my suspicions of IH have by no means decreased one iota; it’s more that I only have one vote to cast & I’d like to place it where I think it’ll do the most good for town. I see xmbie as the player most likely to react the most to me doing this…and it’s not as though there are is a lack of reasons to be suspicious of you…& the way that I see this is that even if xombie doesn’t respond, then that’s still info for the town.

I recognise that this action may be misconstrued, but I’d also like to say that I agree with tornado over the pace of this game – we really shouldn’t be in a huge rush for the next lynch.

[Paradoxombie]

Can the people voting Khelvaster please carefully lay out the reasons for their vote? I don't necessarily suspect them, but if he ends up being a mislynch we're back to nothing to scumhunt but a bandwagon with no reasoning.

While I see the possibility that they are partners, I don't see why you'd choose to vote IH over Khelv. Khelv seems significantly more scummy to me.

Did you, or did you not suspect Khelvaster? Your post 107 looks very ambiguous to me.

107 probably seems ambiguous because I wasn't trying to state anything. And why would anyone ever admit to NOT suspecting the player they voted? Sorry, pointless questions like that bother me.

[Streeflo]

107 probably seems ambiguous because

I wasn't trying to state anything.

And why would anyone ever admit to NOT suspecting the player they voted? Sorry, pointless questions like that bother me.

Then why did you bother posting?

[Paradoxombie]

107 probably seems ambiguous because

I wasn't trying to state anything.

And why would anyone ever admit to NOT suspecting the player they voted? Sorry, pointless questions like that bother me.

Then why did you bother posting?

To ask a question and thereby recieve an answer. Much as you did.

[DeathSauce]

Wow, things have ground to a halt here.

Since IH still leads my scum list, and to hopefully spark some activity,

vote:IH

Maybe some other players in this game could share their analysis of the game so far? I feel like that was a lot of wasted effort on my part at this point

[ryan]

"Who's it gonna be?" Vote Count

(2) Paradoxombie (Streeflo, groinhammer)
(1) IH (Deathsauce)
(1) groinhammer (IH)


Not Voting: Gatorguy91, Paradoxombie, Sir Tornado, Estes, Jdodge,

With 9 Alive it's 4 to Lynch

[Estes]

Vote: Gatorguy91

Just trying to see if we can get some discussion going.

[ryan]

I don't want to place a deadline in a quicklynch game. Let's get to discussing here folks

[Sir Tornado]

Vote Estes

[Estes]

I just knew you would do that. List a reason so we can have something to discuss.

[ryan]

"Keeping up the discussion" Vote Count

(2) Paradoxombie (Streeflo, groinhammer)
(1) IH (Deathsauce)
(1) groinhammer (IH)
(1) Estes (Sir Tornado)
(1) Gatorguy91 (Estes)


Not Voting: Gatorguy91, Paradoxombie, Jdodge

With 9 Alive it's 4 to Lynch

[MCHammer]

Apologies for being sporadic over the last week, was in danger of getting swamped by work [erk] - will post my analysis tonight/early tomorrow.

[Gatorguy91]

Sorry. I could not find the thread.

MOD: In the bottom left corner you can hit the "Start Watching Topic" and never lose it

[Streeflo]

I don't think anything will convince me to remove my vote from Paradoxombie.

[IH]

gah, I keep forgetting I'm in two nightless games. Bleh.

I also fail at reading, and rescind my accusations of groin hammer.

unvote

I will go over the rest in a bit, but I think this day should EVENTUALLY end in a Para lynch. Note the word right there. EVENTUALLY.

[DeathSauce]

IH, that post rings of nothing other than scum trying to get the town to do his dirty work. And possibly an attempt at distancing.

You are the one that has been advocating the death of all players who speedlynch. Do you think paradox's hammer votes were too speedy? If so then you should be voting him based on your own statements. Seems like another case of inconsistency between your words and your actions.

[ryan]

"Discussing is GOOD" Vote Count

(2) Paradoxombie (Streeflo, groinhammer)
(1) IH (Deathsauce)
(1) Estes (Sir Tornado)
(1) Gatorguy91 (Estes)


Not Voting: Gatorguy91, IH, Paradoxombie, Jdodge

With 9 Alive it's 4 to Lynch