Mini 496 - Wild West Mafia. Mod Abandoned

[ryan]

Simenon: I've played in a few games with Aimee and she's usually more vocal (hence why I said she was quiet earlier) Nothing to jump on is odd? What's the difference of saying that or "I've got nothing to say" aren't they the same? I disagree on your metagaming, ask anyone's who's played with me before the only difference I have in this game with my normal playstyle is how the game began (with the note) and since it seems to be a free pass to Day 2 (I haven't seen alot of pressure votes to get Adam talking after the note came out) my suspect list is very minimal. I'm just waiting for something to get into detail about. The only thing I've seen is pdcakes throwing my name as suspcious because I haven't said anything (in his words) seems like a possible scum way to bring up somebody (me) who hasn't had any suspicion on me (rightfully so) the entire game.

Mod: We also need a vote count.

[Twomz]

FoS: Simenon

for saying that I am an "unFoSer"...

? But seriously... I did not know that was a scum tell, everything makes sense to me now!!!

[Thin_Man]

More later.

Also a vote of Adele, I assume. It was sorely missing in your last post.

In addition, my meta on Ryan tells me he likes to jump around and attract attention to himself as town. He's doing the opposite this game: he's posting somewhat infrequently, isn't pursuing any scums very doggedly and his vote seems to be unmoving

Thing is that get me is that the style you ascribe to him as town is also how he acts as scum. This game's nothing like either,

The only thing I've seen is pdcakes throwing my name as suspcious because I haven't said anything (in his words) seems like a possible scum way to bring up somebody (me) who hasn't had any suspicion on me (rightfully so) the entire game.

Well no, not really. You genuinely haven't said anything, and you're fairly scummy.

[ryan]

Good deal, now we have narrow minded accusations with no base, I'll enjoy this. PLEASE state where I've been scummy Thin_Man IF I haven't said anything?

[curiouskarmadog]

What would you like me to contribute? I posted my top three (as asked) and my bottom three. Either of the top three I posted I'd be happy to see lynched.

Good deal, now we have narrow minded accusations with no base, I'll enjoy this. PLEASE state where I've been scummy Thin_Man IF I haven't said anything?

where have you helped this town, when you havent said anything?

vote ryan

you might have provided a list, but you had to be pushed to do so..now, people are wanting you to contribute more (like provide reasons for your scum list), instead of contributing you are attacking those who are asking you to contribute..

Why?

[ryan]

No, I'm stating that saying I've said scummy things WHEN he also said I didn't contribute is a contradiction. Are you saying it's not?

[ryan]

pdcakes: His early opinions on Adam/Simenon seem to be forced a little bit. I feel like he’s trying to lead the town down the wrong road and I’m not liking it.

Adam the Amazing/Simenon: Obviously the “note” leads me to believe something is up and his defense on it for a few pages and than POOF he disappears. Guilty until proven innocent in my eyes. Simenon stating that more pressure should be on him (his predecessor) is pretty funny actually. The game tried pressure, Adam didn’t really respond and than it was dropped………. Maybe I’ll pick it back up again.

Aimee: The last game I played with her when she attempted to lead a town with “most suspicious lists” she turned out to be scum. I haven’t seen enough from her to say she’s innocent, so in my mafia world you are guilty until proven innocent.


I’m also not feeling ckd at the moment. I was never PUSHED to provide a list. I posted one and than got jumped for it. You are awfully quick to throw suspicion on other’s lists when it’s exactly what you asked people to do. Make up your mind son.


For now Simenon I'm gonna take your advice and apply more pressure to you

Unvote/Vote: Simenon

[Aimee]

Aimee: The last game I played with her when she attempted to lead a town with “most suspicious lists” she turned out to be scum. I haven’t seen enough from her to say she’s innocent, so in my mafia world you are guilty until proven innocent.

???

What game was that?

Also, last time I played with you (as town), there was much more "OMG attack lurkers!" going on. Obviously I can't make an effective meta without comparing it to a game you were scum in. Do you have a recently completed game where you were scum, ryan?

Also, I'll get my suspicion list up tomorrow. Sorry for the delay.

[pdcakes]

ryan: the last game i played with aimee and she had us do suspicion lists she was town. So i think she likes suspicion lists now matter what role she is

and ryan if you had a problem with my opinon on adam why didnt you state it near the time when i said it or when it was the main topic of discussion? you seem to have started to accuse me and suspect me as soon as i begin to suspect you....

[theopor_COD]

Belated Votecount

pdcakes (2) - GodofWine, Kabenon007
Ryan (2) - Adele, Curiouskarmadog
Simenon (1) - Ryan
Sir Wario (1) - Thin_Man
Paradoxombie (1) - Twomz
Curiouskarmadog (1) - Sir Wario

Deadline still retractable is set to hit in 8 days time

[pdcakes]

wait. did paradox vote for me and I missed it?

No your dead right. I used the last vote-count which was down to BM. He's to blame. Paradox unvoted before that last vote count

[curiouskarmadog]

I’m also not feeling ckd at the moment. I was never PUSHED to provide a list. I posted one and than got jumped for it. You are awfully quick to throw suspicion on other’s lists when it’s exactly what you asked people to do. Make up your mind son.

you were pressured to post one...when people asked you to elaborate, you jumped all over them...all I want you to do is go into more detail.

[ryan]

I am withdrawing Aimee from my list for the reason I posted earlier, I checked back and the game I was talking about she was actually town. Not to say I'm not still watching her but my reasoning above is not correct.

viewtopic.php?t=5558&postdays=0&postorder=asc&&start=0

[curiouskarmadog]

I am withdrawing Aimee from my list for the reason I posted earlier, I checked back and the game I was talking about she was actually town. Not to say I'm not still watching her but my reasoning above is not correct.

viewtopic.php?t=5558&postdays=0&postorder=asc&&start=0

interesing you posted this game..gave it a look over, you were quite active from the start...

much different here

[ryan]

Your point is what?

[curiouskarmadog]

Your point is what?

the same point I have had the entire time..

in that game and the game you and I played...you were very active..trying to find scum..

this game, you have been reserved..I want to know why the change in game style.

[ryan]

Because the last few games when I've been active and aggressive I got lynched, so I'm taking the "Don't overthink characteristics on posters" approach.

[ryan]

Do you have a recently completed game where you were scum, ryan?

It's not completed BUT since I was already lynched I see no problem posting the URL

viewtopic.php?t=5675

[curiouskarmadog]

Because the last few games when I've been active and aggressive I got lynched, so I'm taking the "Don't overthink characteristics on posters" approach.

but even though you have been lynched (and I can verify that he is correct) wasnt your contributions helping in the big picture and ultimately leading the town (and you) to a win?

[ryan]

Yet I was still looked upon as scummy enough to be lynched, so obviously I'm not playing townie enough and people are going after me for anything and everything. So I'm taking everything into account when I vote people, look at their playstyles and decide if they are scummy enough to be lynched. It's cautious but I'm still active.

[curiouskarmadog]

fair enough for now.

unvote

going to look over your (scum) game a bit

[ryan]

fair enough for now.

unvote

going to look over your (scum) game a bit

What else do you want CKD? You're ripping me apart for my lack of contribution yet I can name at least 3 others who haven't done squat in this game. (where's your pressure on them?) I gave my list, I explained my suspicions, I talked about my lack of activity (in your eyes) WHAT else do I need to do to explain myself in this setup? I've placed a vote on Simenon so we can find out if the note means anything and you still persist.

[curiouskarmadog]

fair enough for now.

unvote

going to look over your (scum) game a bit

What else do you want CKD? You're ripping me apart for my lack of contribution yet I can name at least 3 others who haven't done squat in this game. (where's your pressure on them?) I gave my list, I explained my suspicions, I talked about my lack of activity (in your eyes) WHAT else do I need to do to explain myself in this setup? I've placed a vote on Simenon so we can find out if the note means anything and you still persist.

ummm, this seems a bit like an over reaction (considering that I just unvoted you)...I am not "ripping" you apart...it is called pressure...I applied it...did me saying that I was going to review the link YOU provided upset you?

[ryan]

Metagame away, doesn't bother me one bit

[Aimee]

I don't particularly like ryan's overreaction to CKD's pressure. He seems panicky.