In post 772, rkvothe wrote:We can only do that if we can ensure that 3dice dies tonight. Let's don't forget about that.
The thing is, making suboptimal plays isn't necessarily going against win condition. I'd rather we just lynch 3dice today... I guess I just don't want to leave anything up to chance. shrug
Then we should weigh the risk of lynching 3dice against lynching someone else.
If we lynch 3dice, who we gonna lose tonight? This can be prevented with a couple of protective roles like myself.
If we lynch someone else, how do we ensure 3dice death? How it could be prevented? scum/neutral killing being dicks?
If we actually end up lynching someone else and flips scum, what are the odds that they'll prevent the 3dice death just to fuck with us? Scum can get no benefit whatsoever, but neutral killing could.
Can we trust scum/neutral killing not to fuck with us?
Maybe lynching 3dice is the safest thing we can do.
I should say something about my day 1 here. I was V/LA on a trip that I wasn't expecting. Was phone posting and fucked up most of my sentences, I can't concentrate as well as on my pc.
I didn't want to announce I was V/LA because I didn't want you to think I was copping out of the arguement I had with AA.
Town Government : Wisdom (mason leader) , Sensei (government)
Town Investigative or Protective X2: Axle (protective) , Random (protective) , rkvothe (buss driver)
Town Killing or Power : FA (vigilant)
Town Killing or Power : Ranger (Spy)
Town Random X3 : AI (vig) , AA (jailor) , Erra (killing)
Neutral Evil : 3dice (cultist)
Neutral Benign X2: Yakko (amnesiac) , Aronis (Survivor)
In post 772, rkvothe wrote:We can only do that if we can ensure that 3dice dies tonight. Let's don't forget about that.
The thing is, making suboptimal plays isn't necessarily going against win condition. I'd rather we just lynch 3dice today... I guess I just don't want to leave anything up to chance. shrug
I agree with scum Errant.
"You've been furthering the win condition of the Mafia even better than the Mafia." - Dierfire
Say the 3 of us who claimed protective protect wisdom, what would happen? I'd redirect the other protective roles to the other target as well? Would that leave wisdom open for death if someone else chooses to kill the target?