In post 1169, BlackStar wrote:On day 1 I thought you were town because you called out Wednesday on his weird behavior. So I expected the scum to try and kill you. I didn't really trust RC so I gambled that he was scum and thought that I could redirect the kill from you onto him.
"You are the Joker of mafia players" - Oversoul
"last time I was scum with Firebringer
his first post in the scum PT was "yes I rolled scum!"
I decided to post "haha just don't post that in the main thread", but to get up to date on the main thread first.
His first post in the main thread was "yes I rolled scum!" -popsofctown
In post 1171, Almost50 wrote:@Persy: I'd appreciate your input as well. ASSUMING BlackStar's statements all to be true, how would TWO BusDrivers targeting the same person resolve?
That's a question for mod.
BUT, note that it's not necessarily the case that two redirectors targeted me. It could mean that a second redirector targeted RC and droog. So, the kill went from me, to RC, to droog.
Or it could be that Blackstar is mistaken, or lying.
These kinds of things are why I suggested a massclaim earlier.
In post 1169, BlackStar wrote:On day 1 I thought you were town because you called out Wednesday on his weird behavior. So I expected the scum to try and kill you. I didn't really trust RC so I gambled that he was scum and thought that I could redirect the kill from you onto him.
What was your alignment card?
Town
I mean the actual card, like vanilla townie or tracker.
"You are the Joker of mafia players" - Oversoul
"last time I was scum with Firebringer
his first post in the scum PT was "yes I rolled scum!"
I decided to post "haha just don't post that in the main thread", but to get up to date on the main thread first.
His first post in the main thread was "yes I rolled scum!" -popsofctown
In post 1169, BlackStar wrote:On day 1 I thought you were town because you called out Wednesday on his weird behavior. So I expected the scum to try and kill you. I didn't really trust RC so I gambled that he was scum and thought that I could redirect the kill from you onto him.
What was your alignment card?
Town
I mean the actual card, like vanilla townie or tracker.
At this time I do believe a massclaim should help:
I'm a Town BusDriver with DOUBLE-DOWN Modifier. My 1st switch was Persy for Starbuck (which is why I believe Smithereens claim, obviously). My second switch was myself for BlackStar.
Spoiler: Reasons
Reason for 1st switch: I wasn't sure of Persy's alignment (still am not) but thought I'd protect him IF he was town. It didn't seem logical to protect him over someone more likely to be town, and as I had no problem of losing Starbuck anyway it seemed like the best move. A nightkill targeted at Persy would serve to rid us of a totally unknown, but -more importantly- would prove he is not <insert alignment here> depending on the method of the NK. Unfortunately; Town Vig never occurred to me.
Reason for 2nd switch: I didn't want to get NK'd myself. I picked someone who was being more quiet than not, so they probably would not have been targeted by any killer anyway, so I was safe. I also thought BS was less likely to be scum than -say- Starbuck or Jackal so I picked him over them both (in case I was investigated myself. I would not want to escape a NK only to find myself lynched based on evidence I personally faked on me). It was close between him and dave, but I saw BS to be a little bit more townier than dave.
Now let's see .. this has become VERY messy. I can't even decide whom to protect, whom to believe, and whom to suspect. My head is spinning faster than a Ferrari engine.
@Persivul: You see now why I needed someone in the know to explain? I DID switch you for Starbuck directly, and Smither said she targeted you but StarBuck died instead. HOLY "SHIP"! How DID she know it was StarBuck and NOT lane?????? Unless -of course- FA is spot on and Smither knew who the faction kill was targeted at!!!!
In post 1185, Persivul wrote:You got clairvoyant in both the first deal and the second?
oh. I didnt understnad your question. I got claiyvoyant and then the second time I chose busdriver
You still don't understand. The second time you had cop and bus driver. What was the third card?
Now both of us are confused haha.
This is what i originally got in the first draw
Town Clairvoyant
Town Tracker
Mafia Goon
I chose clairvoyant.
this is what i had in the second draw
Town Cop
Neighborizer
Town Bus Driver
I chose bus driver and got the role pm confirming that. But then I got another pm from the mod saying that he made a mistake. The combinations i chose wouldn't give me the role that I wanted, town bus driver. He had to change the neighborizer card to vanilla townie and discard the cop role.
@Almost - Actually no, I'm gonna need to work through this more thoroughly later. Hopefully FA or someone will compile the whole list of claims and actions to make it easier. Although roles don't indicate alignment in this setup, actions and reasons for those actions can be weighed.
In post 801, Smithereens wrote:nah it's a redirector. I tried to vig Persival because I thought he was scum, but someone else died. I figure I shot the werewolf seeing as they probably wouldn't shoot themselves.
"You are the Joker of mafia players" - Oversoul
"last time I was scum with Firebringer
his first post in the scum PT was "yes I rolled scum!"
I decided to post "haha just don't post that in the main thread", but to get up to date on the main thread first.
His first post in the main thread was "yes I rolled scum!" -popsofctown
I chose bus driver and got the role pm confirming that. But then I got another pm from the mod saying that he made a mistake. The combinations i chose wouldn't give me the role that I wanted, town bus driver. He had to change the neighborizer card to vanilla townie and discard the cop role.
I'm not asking about the combinations, I'm asking about the three underlying cards. In your PM for the second draw, assuming it's like mine, you got three unnumbered cards. Below that, you got three numbered combinations.
