Mini 496 - Wild West Mafia. Mod Abandoned

[ryan]

Panicky? I had two votes on me (before he unvoted) how the heck is that a panic?

[Twomz]

The reaction you had is disproportionate to the action that caused the reaction, therefore some would see it as "panicking."

[kabenon007]

The accusations aren't really all that huge, he unvoted you, and you seem to be defensive whenever anyone addresses you. Your responses are short and as has been pointed out, panicked, as if something hit home.

[ryan]

Oh christ people. Ask me some freaking questions and I'll give you some answers, if you don't have any questions than don't freak on me for not answering.

[pdcakes]

ryan people are pointing out how you seem to get get touchy when pressured and how one post seemed like an overreaction...not that you arent answering questions.

[SirWario]

I'm back, attempting re-read.

[kabenon007]

we really don't have to ask questions. We can just deduce what we will from your responses to our accusations of panic. And ask questions!

[ryan]

I'm not going to defend my reactions. When you don't give somebody something to respond to you aren't going to get the "Best answers" And yes you DO have to ask questions in this game, it's how you get answers and build cases against players.

[Thin_Man]

#1: As I pointed out before, metagaming doesn't really work in this situation because this play is such a large deviation from both normal town and scum. If anything, it's a step in the townie direction, simply because I believe he'd be less inclined to change his playstyle as scum first.

#2: Didn't strike me as especially panicky.

#3: I

do

think that his attitude of acting like people are completely talking out of their asses unless they post a case is fairly scummy. In answer to your earlier question, the main thing thats scummy about you isn't present in your participation because there is so little of your participation. You're doing very little, and your scumlist was sufficiently bizarre as to convince me, at least, that you're just not involving yourself in this game and making bad decisions because of that. Or, of course, you could be scum. That's the decision.

@Everyone who hasn't posted a list yet: Get moving.

[curiouskarmadog]

crap, thought I had...have more reread and reading to do....

[ryan]

Thin_Man: What is bizare about my scumlist?

[GodOfWine]

My scumlist:
(This list is not in order)
1. pdcakes
2. ryan
3. Thin_Man

1. leftover suspicion from our first interchange. he has been relatively inactive since then. does this heighten my suspicion? i cant decide
2. no matter what anyone says, he panicked, and panicking leads to playing like albert b rampage, which no one enjoys.
3. overly dismissive of nearly everything.

[ryan]

IF you are going to say somebody did something, back it up with evidence. Show me how I panicked, how I changed my story, how I freaked out. I'd like to see it.

[Paradoxombie]

I don't see anything comment worthy in the ryan/ckd interchange.

[ryan]

Adele: Any reason you still have your random vote on? Over 12 pages in and you haven't found anything to talk about since last Wednesday? I'm the one that seems to be getting ripped for not contributing yet a few of you seem to have missed this.

[Simenon]

I'll post in this over the weekend- I really only have time right now to post in games that I'm modding.

[Twomz]

Hai guys, posting this in all my games.

This morning my lappy would not turn on, I went to get it checked out and either the video card ($300 to fix) or the motherboard ($600) are broken. I do not have that kind of money, therefore I will be using college compies to access games in my extra time. My playing may be sporatic and I may not have time to make long meaningful posts for a while. I am working on the situation and will inform y'all whenever I have fixed the problem.

-Twomz

[SirWario]

Most suspicious:
Thin man/ sir wario:
After reading all the posts the thing that stood out the most to me was thin mans vote of wario in post 57. There is no explanation of this at all. And when prompted by Aimee in post 71 to explain thin man says he wont. But after that his vote on wario was not mentioned again. by Anyone. It really bothers me how no one commented on it especially wario. I know if someone voted me then i would want to know why.

The reason I never addressed Thin man was because I simply assumed that his vote was random. He gave no explanation so I didn't think much of it.

Anyway, my top suspect is Paradox. He Fos's Twomz for the no lynch propsal, then later upgrades to Hos when no wagon builds on him. This lack of vote leaves him open to say that he scolded Twomz, but never joined a wagon. It also, freed him up to hop on any growing wagon if supicion did augment towards Twomz.

Unvote,Vote:Paradoxombie

I really don't mind him not participating in the suspicion list. I'm having a hard time picking out two other supects myself.

[pdcakes]

sorry i havent posted in a few days. I had a nasty biochem exam that ive been studying for all week. Ill do a re-read and then post

[Aimee]

I'm going to have limited access for a while. Sorry for not getting my scum-list done - I've been sooo busy!

I'll get it done when I get back!

[curiouskarmadog]

I have reread and I cant really say I can make a strong case against anyone...

that being said I felt that ryan DID overreact to my suggestion that I would read is scummy game (that he provided)..so there might be something there...I do think metagaming can help, but to make a case out of a metagame is hard to do (given the amount of different factors)..

so I think I will do that (a little more), just to see what there is to see.

[ryan]

I provided the game, why would I overreact to you reading it? Come on now seriously.

[curiouskarmadog]

I provided the game, why would I overreact to you reading it? Come on now seriously.

that is why I said it wasnt a strong case..

[Paradoxombie]

Vote: Twomz

[ryan]

Vote: Twomz

Reasoning?