NY 193 : Werewolf Mania (GAME OVER- TOWN WIN)

[Zulfy]

Keyser being da best as always but

My only concern was his reachy interpretation of BlackStar's post as a scum-slip (post 96).

+1, I'm not seeing how this is much of a concern. I feel like you put this in here just because you felt you had an obligation to criticize JarJarDrinks in some way.

Spoiler: Memo to find out where this went

@Xkfyu - please explain why "one of {Keyser, Zulfy, Ricastle}" is "probably" scum. Why are you ruling out the possibility of town challenging town, or town challenging scum?

[Almost50]

What do you think of the ABR slot? Who do you want lynched and why?

First part, I honestly don't know what to think of this slot, and especially so with the anticipated replacement of the replacement. It's becoming a pain for both this & ika's slot.

As for my lynch target; I'm still ok with PhantomCobalt's slot. He replaced in but didn't add anything at all. OnThu Jan 21, 2016 4:26 pm he says: "I'll make a post later today or tomorrow." but all he ever posted since was on Fri Jan 22, 2016 1:51 pm "I'll get a readslist with reasons tonight." which he never did either.

Elswehere I'm not too comfortable with IAI's posts, but I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt bc of 591

GR the BS come next, but if we're lynching someone I'd rather it be P-Cobalt for today.

[RadiantCowbells]

Everyone stop townreading me please.

[Zulfy]

Didn't like blacks #73 much. Could be shadowing scum.

+1, reaching

I think he's prob scum trying to out the real seer.

This feels like town WIFOM

Wait just a second there was never a need to counterclaim ika +1.
By the way now you're giving the ika slot some space? What are you doing here Nero?

Stop fighting over trivial shit and work together so that we can figure out who is scum

^scum

Explain this

you didn't ask me to explain, you asked me some nonsensical "how do I know" bullshit.

You are better than this that's not town +1

there's going to be a chorus of people that say "its empty stop trying to lynch it!"

Am I mistaken in thinking that this is your approach to the ika slot?

[Keyser Söze]

To page 22.

RC is one of the worst town players on the site. You'd do well to ignore him.

We were in a hydra together. So of course he did. Check Open 613 and see the first thing he did was vote me and seek me out. He was town.

...and what stops scum-ika from not 'voting you and seeking you out'?

I think everyone should look at snarkysnowman's ISO. He basically just parked his vote on JarJar and then vanished

SnarkySnowman's ISO was/is threadbare - but that vote was RVS. We'll keep an eye on how pro-active his later contributions are.

mod I have to replace out due to slot being compermised, I'll pm reasons tonight

@mod, I have to replace as well due to slot now being compromised. I will send you a PM.

VOTE: ika

Horrific entrance. No catch-up or thoughts, just a naked vote. How can you vote without first showing that you have read the thread? This again echoes the bias that SilverWolf entered the game with. That slot is now firmly in my uncomfortable pile.

What just happened :-: I'll make a post later today or tomorrow.

Who are you?

[Zulfy]

Rough week all, just found out my dad might have prostate cancer. So yeah my head really ain't into this right now.

I'll be thinking of you, Innocent.
No pings on this one. In fact I think I'm not gonna spend too much time paying attention to Innocent for now.

[Zulfy]

That's it for today I think. This game looks like it's gonna be interesting. I am actually excited again.

[Nero Cain]

but if we're lynching someone I'd rather it be P-Cobalt for today.

I have neither town reads on ABR or Cobalt so I'm ok there too.

Everyone stop townreading me please.

done.

Explain this

If Black is scum he'd know mine and Ika's alignment. If Ika is town there is scum motivation in diffusing a TvT fight.

[Keyser Söze]

To page 24.

Scumlean {Nero Cain, Golden Robster, Ricastle}

Can you tell me how you got here.

Also, unless you're scum with him, how could you possibly know that a scum ika has no long term strategy?

I do not "know" but based on the nature of the wagon on him I think it is bad-town play. If you roleclaim Seer this early you are then committed to that claim - I.e versus counter-claims, investigations, real Seer flip. If any of these things contradict your claim you will be lynched on the spot (I.e 'no long term strategy'.)

You don't know what roles scum have, or exactly how many there are.

I did not state that I did - I presented my read of ika's wagon. This being a werewolf set-up I do believe we should have a seer (cop) though.

How can you assume that you know someone's motivation behind their actions when you don't have all the information that they do.

I am assuming his intention based on his play/behaviour (that's the game!). No where did I state that I "know".

I find it very counter-productive to stay stuck on one subject/player and halt the game until something in particular occurs. But that's just me, of course.

I like the pro-town Almost50

[BeBopAReBop RhubarbPie]

Everyone stop townreading me please.

Ok.

VOTE: RadiantCowbells

Except that I dislike Silver's slot even more.

UNVOTE: UNVOTE:

VOTE: Silver/ABR

[TheBlueRose]

ISO'd RC.
RC votes Ricastle for saying that RC is a bad town player (See me, I'm not very impressed by Ricastle's skill myself)
RC votes Ricastle (presumably) for the stuff Ricastle says on page 19, as he had his vote parked on the laughing anime gif person before that. I see that stuff as classic Ricastle but can see how RC would do that, he is RC.

No pings on RC.

When you say it is typical Ricastle, are you saying that is is typical town Ricastle or scum Ricastle?

RC is most likely town I think.

What are you going off of that gives you this idea?

[TheBlueRose]

I think we absolutely should wait out anyone coming back. The mod is doing their best to fill those positions and when they are we will get another look at that slot and see how the new person interacts with it. Until then there is no reason why we shouldn't continue the game and peruse other leads.

What do you think we would benifit from not doing anything until the slots are filled? The only one I can see is to waist time to get closer to the deadline.

[BlackStar]

VOTE: thebluerose This is based off of a gut feeling. I can't really explain it yet

[TheBlueRose]

VOTE: thebluerose This is based off of a gut feeling. I can't really explain it yet

Then I'd suggest you sit there and think of what that gut feeling might be and then we'lI see.

[RadiantCowbells]

Hey, I think BlueRose is town.

*cough*

VOTE: BlueRose

ok?

[Nero Cain]

And ABR counter wagon found

[BlackStar]

And ABR counter wagon found

Except that's not what's happening at all.

[Nero Cain]

and what would you say is happening?

[BlackStar]

I voted for bluerose because something about him feels off. And then RC voted for him because he's RC. I don't know about him, but I don't have any ulterior motives.

[Nero Cain]

something feels off.

That's not an entirely vague statement at all.

[BlackStar]

*Shrugs* So what? I'll look into him some more and figure out what it is

[TheBlueRose]

How about this, if you'd had to put your finger on something what would that "off" thing possible be?

[BlackStar]

I guess the best way to describe it is that you posts give off the feeling that you're trying to appear town instead of you actually being town. Like earlier when we were on like the second page and you asked someone what they thought about everyone. i don't know why, but your post 636 felt manufactured just like that other post that I mentioned which I why I voted for you.And Nero Cain, it's pretty funny that you think this is a counter wagon seeing as how I was saying that Ika and Silverwolf might be scum together. Why would I call silverwolf/ABR scum if I was on his side?

[TheBlueRose]

Good some substance from you now at least. I like that. Now going back to my posts while it was an odd question don't you think it helped in regards to getting us out of RVS?

Also @Nero what do you see behind a counter wagon starting up?

@RadiantCowbells what is your input on this so far?

[BlackStar]

Good some substance from you now at least.

I like that. Now going back to my posts while it was an odd question don't you think it helped in regards to getting us out of RVS?

Also @Nero what do you see behind a counter wagon starting up?

@RadiantCowbells what is your input on this so far?

Have you even read your own posts? You've only made one good point so far in this game