Blitz 24: Great Idea Mafia

[Persivul]

My town winrate is over 50% these days thanks to me slaughtering in games as town in the new year.
I will continue that trend when I lynch you.

Feb 4 isn't much of a sample size.

What was your town win rate in 2015?

[lilith2013]

So you're sheeping Ranger but you don't think I'm scum?

Like either you're being dumb by voting someone you think is town just to sheep Ranger

Or you somehow think that I'm scummy enough to sheep someone onto.

Which is it?

[RadiantCowbells]

And please, don't pretend you replacing out of 1678 was some grand gesture.
You were beaten and you knew it. Only reason you replaced out.

At least you told the truth for once.

Annie is not adorable.

...fuck.

Feb 4 isn't much of a sample size.

What was your town win rate in 2015?

So not in the mood to have this argument with you.
We have yet to play a game as town together where my reads haven't been far better than yours.
And it was barely below 50%. That's how I got my OVERALL TWR up above 50%.
And that's someone who mostly plays normals, which are statistically much more scumsided than Theme games.

[Persivul]

So you're sheeping Ranger but you don't think I'm scum?

Like either you're being dumb by voting someone you think is town just to sheep Ranger

Or you somehow think that I'm scummy enough to sheep someone onto.

Which is it?

Do you not understand what sheeping is? That's a rhetorical question, because you obviously don't.

[lilith2013]

Why are you voting me if you think RC is so scummy? Like here is my issue. You present all these arguments for scum!RC. Yet your vote remains on me, a player that you sheeped somebody onto. So either you are being obtuse by keeping your vote on me while you think RC is scummier than me, or you have a reason to keep voting me rather than voting RC.

[Persivul]

And it was barely below 50%.

When I checked it I excluded newbies and replacements and got 29% in a sample size of 17 games.

I'm probably no better. But, you were 100% in your 3 scum games. If you recall I've said that your playstyle favors scum games at the expense of town, and the numbers support that. I'm not saying you do it purposely, but it does work out that way.

[lilith2013]

Either put your vote where your mouth is, or come up with a reason that you're choosing to keep your vote on me over your scumread.

[RadiantCowbells]

No, as it happens Persivul switched votes to me.
He's still scum though.
Lilith, why are you reluctant to vote him?

I'm probably no better. But, you were 100% in your 3 scum games. If you recall I've said that your playstyle favors scum games at the expense of town, and the numbers support that. I'm not saying you do it purposely, but it does work out that way.

No. That's really not the case.
Read the 1678 mafia thread. We did 8 pages of the two of us over one game day.
I'm good at scum because I'm

good at scum

.

[RadiantCowbells]

Lilith, wtf?

Why have you not voted Persivul yet?

[lilith2013]

You know what, I completely missed Pers's vote on RC.

I feel p dumb, just ignore most of what I said

[Persivul]

Why are you voting me if you think RC is so scummy? Like here is my issue. You present all these arguments for scum!RC. Yet your vote remains on me, a player that you sheeped somebody onto. So either you are being obtuse by keeping your vote on me while you think RC is scummier than me, or you have a reason to keep voting me rather than voting RC.

Either put your vote where your mouth is, or come up with a reason that you're choosing to keep your vote on me over your scumread.

I'm not voting you. I changed to RC two pages ago.

[RadiantCowbells]

I don't understand why Lilith's so obsessed with the vote on her or why she's not voting Persivul when she's talking like she's scumreading him.

[lilith2013]

Let me think.

[Persivul]

No. That's really not the case.

I checked the games, and yes, it really is the case.

[RadiantCowbells]

Let me think.

Why are you so interested in Persivul's vote on you if you don't think it's scum opportunism?
If you think it's scum opportunism, why aren't you voting him?

It sort of feels like you're more interested in the vote than his alignment atm.

[RadiantCowbells]

No. That's really not the case.

I checked the games, and yes, it really is the case.

I'm not 100% in 3 mafia games, I'm 100% in like 15.

Stahp.

[lilith2013]

I don't understand why Lilith's so obsessed with the vote on her or why she's not voting Persivul when she's talking like she's scumreading him.

Sometimes I get irrationally angry and start attacking everyone who's attacking me

[RadiantCowbells]

I don't understand why Lilith's so obsessed with the vote on her or why she's not voting Persivul when she's talking like she's scumreading him.

Sometimes I get irrationally angry and start attacking everyone who's attacking me

Okay, that's fine.

What's your read on Persivul and why?

[Persivul]

I'm not 100% in 3 mafia games, I'm 100% in like 15.

Like I said, I excluded newbies and replacements, and stahped at 20 games, which I believe was sometime in November, so it was most of the year.

Playstyles that favor the scum game are a pet peeve of mine because, well, you draw town a lot more than scum, so those players are a hindrance.

[Persivul]

Sometimes I get irrationally angry and start attacking everyone who's attacking me

You should try getting rationally angry with people who are trying to manipulate and control you.

[RadiantCowbells]

What aspects of my play do you feel like I'm doing to make it easier to hide when I roll scum?

[lilith2013]

I never said I was good at this game

[lilith2013]

I don't understand why Lilith's so obsessed with the vote on her or why she's not voting Persivul when she's talking like she's scumreading him.

Sometimes I get irrationally angry and start attacking everyone who's attacking me

Okay, that's fine.

What's your read on Persivul and why?

Not ignoring you, looking at his ISO.

[Persivul]

What aspects of my play do you feel like I'm doing to make it easier to hide when I roll scum?

As I said, I don't know that you're doing so intentionally. I thought that because you like to mention your scum win rate, but you denied it, and I of course don't know your internal thoughts, so I take your word for it.

[Lucky2u]

Vote Count 2.2

RadiantCowbells (L-3)- Persivul
Some Random Mafia Player (L-4)-
lilith2013 (L-3)- Ranger
Ranger (L-4)-
Persivul (L-3)- RadiantCowbells
Guiltylion (L-4)-
Xtoxm (L-4)-

Not Voting: Some Random Mafia Player Guiltylion Xtoxm lilith2013

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch!

Deadline in (expired on 2016-02-05 22:00:00)