Mini 419: Farkle Mafia (Game Over)

[Nai]

Bertrand is modding a game I'm in, and... Well, it's night there. I don't know what's going on with him.

I'll prod Jordan, but... Might take forever and a day to get the replacement.

[JordanA24]

I'm here,

A Mass Claim doesn't sound bad, I'll be willing to go with it.

[Thesp]

Bertrand is modding a game I'm in, and... Well, it's night there. I don't know what's going on with him.

I'll prod Jordan, but... Might take forever and a day to get the replacement.

Thanks, I appreciate any effort put towards this game.

JordanA24, what method do you think would be ideal to claim in? What do you think of my claim? What do you think of ThAdmiral's question?

[Thesp]

I'm here, looking for 4 people to play with.

[JordanA24]

I think we should claim popcorn style, with Bertrand going first.

Though I'm intrigued as to why you aren't revealing your investigation until we've all massclaimed. Why are you doing that?

[Dagger]

1 of said 4 players is here.

I say just let Thesp pick who should be the first to claim and we'll roll from there.

[Thesp]

Though I'm intrigued as to why you aren't revealing your investigation until we've all massclaimed. Why are you doing that?

Can you give me a compelling reason I

shouldn't

?

[Dagger]

*nudge*

We need to get a move on.

[Thesp]

*nudge*

We need to get a move on.

Okay. Claim or die.

[Dagger]

*nudge*

We need to get a move on.

Okay. Claim or die.

I am a simple townie.

Nooo! Don't kill me!

[Dagger]

EBWODP: I am interested in Admiral next.

[ThAdmiral]

EBWODP: I am interested in Admiral next.

I am the doctor.
I protected:
Night 0 - Coron
Night 1 - Nocmen
Night 2 - Thesp
Night 3 - Kilmenator (so I am very confused as to why he was still killed, especially with a roleblocker dead)

Your turn...Jordan

[bertrand]

I'm vanilla. Not even any flavor...

(though technically, vanilla is a flavor)

mmmm...

Never done anything..

Note: I'm not sure I believe Dagger, but I'm in a bad position to point that out... whoops? I just did? Oh well..

[Dagger]

Note: I'm not sure I believe Dagger, but I'm in a bad position to point that out... whoops? I just did? Oh well..

I could say the same of ya, but let's reserve judgment until this whole thing is over, shall we?

[Thesp]

JordanA24, that leaves you.

[bertrand]

Note: I'm not sure I believe Dagger, but I'm in a bad position to point that out... whoops? I just did? Oh well..

I could say the same of ya, but let's reserve judgment until this whole thing is over, shall we?

That's why I said I was in a bad position to do so

has Jordan picked up his prod?

[Nai]

Jordan had posted.

[Thesp]

Mod:

Please prod all players who haven't posted in the last 72 hours, especially JordanA24. Thanks!

[ThAdmiral]

No prod needed. I'm here, I'm just waiting.

[JordanA24]

I'm a plain Vanilla Townie.

[JordanA24]

I'm willing to believe Thesp and ThAdmiral. So that leaves Bertrand or Dagger. I'm rereading to see who's scummier.

[JordanA24]

Bertrand

As Adele:

I agree with Adele’s points about Random Voting on Page 3, particularly this point:

But there is a chance of a wagon starting and wagons are the seed of... almost all scum-huntingnesses.

And this post looks protown to me as well:

How's about an agreeance among ourselves that dice-tag posts will also contain some game-related content? Otherwise it's too easy that this could turn into a game of Farkle, which would belong in TWSOGMM.

If he wants to pass there's no reason for us to stop him. That is unless you're scum with him.

There's no reason not to remind him either. That is unless you are scum and you know he is town.

If his score is low you're more likely to win. You know that you are (whatever alignment you are) and will help you out. The only reason to want others to do well is if you think that they are of similar alignment for some reason or another.

Any given person's more likely to be town than scum.

Unless of course, you happen to be scum and know the other scum.

Sorry, been busy over Easter.

Would be up for Coronlynch (standing policy and all that)

God, when did you get so po-faced?

To answer your question, see EmpTyger's title.

I'm ok with lynching you

this game

because you're scummy. And you know it.

Was she still joking when she said about lynching Coron this game? If not, this is poor, onsidering she doesn’t back it up with anything, and she doesn’t vote Coron either, despite saying this.

...Seol's here? Hmm. He usually gets me murderfried. Jerk-ass.

Distancing? This was part of her first post since Seol arrived.

As Bertrand:

Read.

We don't have a really good case on anyone. Though CES is probably our beat lead, I'n not nearly ready for a lynch. We need to find more things to discuss..

CES's behavior seemed more like silly/strange than scummy. The fact that he's using a gimmick to make himself harder to read doesn't look good to me either. I just don't think it's a strong enough case for a lynch, yet.

I'd like to hear more from a34maniac and Seol.

His opening post was worrying vague and indecisive IMO. The only player he said he was definatly suspicious of was the guy who happened to be the bandwagon of the moment (who also happened to be a claimed town power role). And even there he said that he found his play silly rather than scummy. He said the case isn’t strong enough for a lynch, yet. I get the feeling he might be trying to drive the bandwagon on a town power role from the back seat. Another part of his post that really gets me is "We need to find more things to discuss", why not do this yourself. I get the feeling this backs up my theory he’s trying to drive from the back seat.

Who do you think is scum, even if it's only a gut feeling or whatever.

CES is my best guess but it's not a very good one. After that I'd put the two lurkers.

And maybe Dagger, but there's really not much reason behind that. I don't like how he started the Nocmen wagon on day 1 out of nothing.

Still seems to be pushing the CES wagon from the back seat. But to be fair to him, he does mention other targets, including Dagger, who if Bertrand isn’t scum, is by far our best bet.

If it doesn't offend thesp too much I would like to suggest lynching ces and vigging kilmenator. That should make everyone happy (with the exception of those two).
Or to go one step further lynching ces and if he turns up mafia

not vigging

kilmenator as I doubt they are both scum.

I don't like this post one bit..

I quite like this post, despite the lack of explaination. I never like it when people try directing power roles. Because if everyone did that, then there would be quite a lot of scum influence on who power roles target, while if nobody did this, then there is one protown player deciding it. And they got the role, so it should be up to them how they use it.

Alright.

Lynch ces and then vig me if he's not scum.

Thought I might as well mention this now I’ve seen it.

If you are the doctor, this is a horrible horrible post. What was this about Admiral?

Are you that convinced he's scum?

Because if we do this and you're wrong, we're screwed. I don't like this plan either.

Why do you seem to assume that ThAdmiral isn’t scum just here?

Both Thesp and kilmenator have used the "does not make sense" to avoid responding to arguments.. I don't likw that...

Thesp is making sense but all of that seems like a stretch and is based on guesses resting upon assumptions.. I don't buy it.

I still think CES is the best candidate for now.. I'm still hoping we find better though. [which means, either a better case on ces or on someone else]

Eh? Saying something doesn’t make sense is a valid argument. Also, presuming Thesp is town, you seem to be fencesitting between two arguing townies.

Though I think he’s got a fair point about Thesp basing his suspicions on assumptions and saying “Scum ususally do this”.

Third point, he seems to have moved more towards the front seat in terms of driving the CES bandwagon, and he seems like he’s genuinly scumhunting and hoping for a better wagon than CES as well as CES looking scummier.

I would be perfectly happy with a push in Kilm's direction.

y

[why?]

Pushing people to explain their suspicions=protown IMO.

I get a protown feel from his next few posts as well.

After that, he went silent for a while, and then had no access for a week. And then went missing for the rest of Day 2, even missing his turn, before FINALLY coming back near the end of Day 3, saying the Death_Omen wagon looked good, but not voting him, in fact, he even suggested an alternative target, ThAdmiral

I also think ThAdmiral was a good candidate - he was setting up chain lynches, directing the vig, and all on townies..

All of which is scummy.

Note: I'm not sure I believe Dagger, but I'm in a bad position to point that out... whoops? I just did? Oh well..

y?

Summary:

Mokina looked kinda scummy, particularly the what seemed like distancing from Seol. Bertrand looked town at first, but has recently looked really scummy, especially suggested ThAdmiral when Death_Omen was on the brink of being lynched.

Scum Rating

: 7/10

I'll do an analysis on Dagger later.

[JordanA24]

EBWOP: That "All of which is scummy" near the end of the post is supposed to go above the quote (which is Bertrand's, not ThAdmiral's)

And in the summary, "especially suggested ThAdmiral..." is supposed to be "especially suggest

ing

ThAdmiral...".

[Dagger]

@Jordan: I will be awaiting one from you then.

@Thesp: Result would be nice right now.

[bertrand]

I don't get how being indecisive is a scummy trait. It's something that mgiht benefit scum, but it's completely normal for any player.

Also, saying something doesn't make sense is only a valid response to nonsense

Otherwise, don't have much to say.

So, Dagger, Jordan and I have claimed vanilla, Thesp has some sort of investigation, and Admiral says doc..