Mini 496 - Wild West Mafia. Mod Abandoned

[SirWario]

Nope. I'm just a townie with the ability to leave an accusatory note.

[ryan]

So what is your rolename?

[Thin_Man]

A townie with a note ability? I have NEVER heard of something like that before. Anything else on the role you can elaborate on?

It's not that uncommon at all, so I guess what you have and haven't heard of isn't the greatest barometer of liklihood.

[Thin_Man]

though I must admit, I wouldn't mind some clarification on what the ability is.

It's random who gets the note?

It's random what the note says?

[SirWario]

No, I get to choose what the note says and who it is about.

[ryan]

A townie with a note ability? I have NEVER heard of something like that before. Anything else on the role you can elaborate on?

It's not that uncommon at all, so I guess what you have and haven't heard of isn't the greatest barometer of liklihood.

Why are you taking this game personal all of a sudden? Take a step back for a second and remember, IT'S A GAME.

[SirWario]

So what is your rolename?

I don't really have one. It just says I'm a cowboy.

[ryan]

So what is your rolename?

I don't really have one. It just says I'm a cowboy.

Fair enough. So one note per day and it's totally random what you write?

[Gorgon]

SirWario, ckd wasn't under that much pressure, really. And do you think vig is a safe claim to make at this point? I believe it's not. Not at all.

Also, what basis did you have for suspecting him when you posted the note about him?

[ryan]

Looking back through the posts SirWario hasn't really made a large deal about the notes, he's talked about them but not used them to try and lynch somebody. He could be telling the truth and it could be proven very easily with us telling him what to write for Day 3. The vig claim still makes me nervous as CKD wasn't really under alot of pressure at the time of his claim and it seemed silly to claim this early.

[pdcakes]

OK.

Wario: Why did you say "be wary" of ckd instead of ckd is scum like you did with adam?

And I want to hear what ckd thinks now that wario has claimed

[curiouskarmadog]

Jesus, you guys really got with the posting while I was gone. I really don't want to claim, but at this point I feel I have to. I'm a townie with a note ability. I have no inside information so my notes were only intended to spark some discussion. This is why Simenon shouldn't be lynched over the note because they are simply random. Though my remark about CKD was because I got a bad vibe from his posts on day 1.

Now I really don't like CKD's claim. I think his claim is only meant to relieve pressure off himself. I doubt that I was so lucky as to phrase my note "be wary" and it fits perfectly with his role as vigilante.

HOS:CKD

Sweet bastard...what a stupid role, you said “be wary” because I didn’t jump on the damn aimee wagon? What didn’t you like about my play Day 1?…and since there is no counter claim. Sir Wario, I am sure you wouldn’t mind confirming your role tomorrow…Tomorrow can you send another note about me? I don’t care what it is, but as long as I am the subject of the letter.

Why would a “cowboy” get to write a note? At any rate, I mostly believe Sir Wario, because I too got a role name (like “cowboy”) then an explanation of the role. But I still want him to confirm his claim. Also, not sure what his alignment is. A “note maker” doesn’t seem like it is there to help the town. At any rate…

I am leaving my vote, I said note asides Simenon play was scummy, the note just solidified it...no has a better case.

I didn’t claim because of the pressure, I claimed because I was mad at pdcakes. You can push a case as much as you like, but why do the work for the mafia for them? The true test of my role will come tonight…there is no point to have the mafia leave me around, I am too dangerous…that really is the bottom line. MY claim has killed me tonight.

[curiouskarmadog]

"…and since there is no counter claim", it must be true.

(rest of the sentence)

[Paradoxombie]

Ckd's claim is so completely unlike the others.

Vote:Ckd

[Thin_Man]

Ckd's claim is so completely unlike the others.

Vote:Ckd

What possible reason is there not to, at the very least, not give him another night to confirm he has a killing ability?

But I still want him to confirm his claim.

How?

Why are you taking this game personal all of a sudden? Take a step back for a second and remember, IT'S A GAME.

Correcting some BS that you're spewing is hardly a personal attack. If I was insulting you, I'd be actually insulting

you

, like I was with aimee, not your ideas.

Townie

Simenon
SirWario
pdcakes
curiouskarmadog

Neutral

Paradoxombie
Gorgon
GodOfWine

Scummy

kabenon007
ryan

Is, at present, how I feel.

[curiouskarmadog]

Ckd's claim is so completely unlike the others.

Vote:Ckd

what other claims?

and why do you want to do the mafia's work for them?

[curiouskarmadog]

thinman,

if wario makes another note tomorrow in regards to me (even if I die) that will prove the role (not the alignment, but the role)

[Paradoxombie]

Ckd's claim is so completely unlike the others.

Vote:Ckd

What possible reason is there not to, at the very least, not give him another night to confirm he has a killing ability?

That will allow another kill, probably a townie, if he's SK.

[Simenon]

My first thought of reading ThinMan to be honest was "what a jerk". I should have known who it was immediately. :p

What I find odd about the notes is that SirWario wrote them with such formality. It's also interesting to note the how he lowered the severity. "Be wary of X" is not "OMG confirmed scum."

I want to know how any of those who thought the note could be credible thought about the balance of such a role.

I'm fairly certain that Gorgon, ckd, pdcakes, and Thin_man are town. The last one is based on an out of game reference.

[Thin_Man]

Ckd's claim is so completely unlike the others.

Vote:Ckd

What possible reason is there not to, at the very least, not give him another night to confirm he has a killing ability?

That will allow another kill, probably a townie, if he's SK.

So you believe that an SK would risk counterclaim by the third most likely role in the game with only one other person alive at that point? How is that not an utterly colossal risk for someone who needs to live the entire game?

[GodOfWine]

Sorry for the delay. It seems my suspicion of CKD's reaction to the note has snowballed a bit since I've been gone. Anyway, I just read thru the 4-5 pages I have been missed and my vote stands on CKD. Para thinks his nameclaim sets him apart which is somewhat true. But I will not be adding that to my reasons for voting CKD, just to be clear. I don't buy his roleclaim after the unusual way he handled himself.

[Paradoxombie]

Ckd's claim is so completely unlike the others.

Vote:Ckd

What possible reason is there not to, at the very least, not give him another night to confirm he has a killing ability?

That will allow another kill, probably a townie, if he's SK.

So you believe that an SK would risk counterclaim by the third most likely role in the game

with only one other person alive at that point

? How is that not an utterly colossal risk for someone who needs to live the entire game?

Could you clarify on the italiced part?

[Thin_Man]

claimed, sorry. Not alive, claimed.

[Simenon]

freud lolz

[Paradoxombie]

It doesn't seem that unlikely considering the powers are the same and therefore verifiable, and it's the closest protown role to fit the warning of "Be Wary"