Mafia 71: The Corsican Syndicate - Game over!

[cicero]

Confirm Vote: Saint Freak

[curiouskarmadog]

for now I feel good with

vote 50 lbs of bread

by far one of the scummiest in this game..

what was the case against St. Freak?

[cicero]

for now I feel good with

vote 50 lbs of bread

by far one of the scummiest in this game..

what was the case against St. Freak?

Read his posts. He's an unhelpful flippant lurkmeister.

[Porochaz]

Before this game died I made a post responding to this.

I suggest we usher in a new style of playing; no thinking or by-the-book antics. Just pure guesswork and gut-feelings. This game will be our first experiment.

unvote: Albert B Whomever
vote:Tarhalindur

Now cause I dont know how to multiquote I cant post my response but suffice to say I found it scummy. I voted Garn purely to try and revitalise this thread. I am now going back to my vote beforehand

vote Saint Freak

for acting scummy at various points all the way through with the last point being this post. Anyone who wants me to find the other points where he was acting scummy just say. However, I'll only do it if someone asks.

[Porochaz]

Actually for anyone who asks me to check, I just searched for just his posts, the only time he has posted more than 2 lines is the letter he wrote to all of us. He hasn't contributed greatly to the game. CKD, I suggest you search for his posts, about 90% of his posts sound like hes joking and not actually hunting scum properly.

[mcpaltp]

A votecount woud be rad right about now.

[Porochaz]

Unoffical Vote Count to keep the game going, check if you want...

Tarhalindur (5) - KilGrey, Peers, WomensRights, garbagetree, Saint Freak
Saint Freak (5) - mcpaltp, Porochaz, cicero, Windshipper, Garnasha
50 lbs of bread (3) - Aimee, ChronX, CKD
Garnasha (2) - 50poundsofbread, Albert R. Rampage
R. Rampage (1) - Lemming1607
Aimee (1) - Battle Mage
Windshipper (1) - Tarhalindur

Not Voting: skitzer, other person who according to Skruffs last vote count hadnt voted

This may have a mistake or two in it, please feel free to check.

[Porochaz]

Hope you dont mind skruffs, it was just to keep a check of whats been going on...

[cicero]

Thanks 'chaz.

[50 pounds of bread]

If saint freak doesn't kick up his game, you guys might be right, he could be pulling the stoic commie gambit, which is don't help anyone and hope they don't lynch you because they think you are a stupid townie.

Alternatively, I think the scum are trying to flop off of a correct bandwagon, onto a town one.

I still think garnasha is the best choice, followed by tarhalindur.

[Garnasha]

50lbs, I seem to have forgot while I was away, what is your case against me again? I'm going to reread your posts now, but I'd like you to restate it.

[Garnasha]

QC:

Alasdair is very non-chalant about mafia, but he isn't a jerk about it for the sake of being a jerk. Saint Freak is just being an asshole.

memo to self: if 50lbs turns out to be scum, triple check SF. And vice versa.

[Garnasha]

QC: 50 lbs posted a total of 21 posts. I don't like that.

[Garnasha]

make that 22, missed the "0" post

[Porochaz]

Whats so scummy about the no. of times hes posted?

[Garnasha]

it makes me feel bad about his participation in the game. It's no real scumtell, it's just worth noting that he doesn't post much. Hell, even I have more posts.

If in a 33page thread someone has less than a page of posts, it makes me suspect he posts just enough to fly under the lurkdar. But it's no real accusation. What is a real accusation, which I'm going to check (if I say nothing then it's not the case) is if the few posts that he does have are oneliners and/or consist purely of stuff others have already said.

[mcpaltp]

You have been posting pretty consistantly, Garnasha. You would't be the best rubric to base judgement on. Personally, I'm giving a semi-free pass untill the

mass prod

goes out.

In the mean time, I'm pretty happy with my vote that's hainging out on SF right now, so I think I'll keep it there.

[skitzer]

it makes me feel bad about his participation in the game. It's no real scumtell, it's just worth noting that he doesn't post much. Hell, even I have more posts.

If in a 33page thread someone has less than a page of posts, it makes me suspect he posts just enough to fly under the lurkdar. But it's no real accusation. What is a real accusation, which I'm going to check (if I say nothing then it's not the case) is if the few posts that he does have are oneliners and/or consist purely of stuff others have already said.

You must remember that the first sixteen or so pages of this game happened very quickly, so that strategem may not be so complacent.

[cicero]

50 is not scummy. I just re-read him. He was quite active when there was an active to be active in.

But he was fingering you, Garnasha -- which you failed to mention. OMGUS much?

[KilGrey]

It's too bad. It was a nice idea and even had deadlines so it wouldnt be too slow for the somethingawful people. Mcpaltp, when you go home, please tell them "go fuck yourself, san diego" for me, wouldja?

I'm still in and my vote isn't moving. I don't care that he's asked for a replacement Tar is the scummiest thing I've seen in awhile.

What is it about my post on him that people disagree with or what is it about it that you think that stuff doesn't make him scum?

[garbagetree]

It's too bad. It was a nice idea and even had deadlines so it wouldnt be too slow for the somethingawful people. Mcpaltp, when you go home, please tell them "go fuck yourself, san diego" for me, wouldja?

[Garnasha]

50 is not scummy. I just re-read him. He was quite active when there was an active to be active in.

But he was fingering you, Garnasha -- which you failed to mention. OMGUS much?

maybe you're right here and I'm being OMGUS

y

(not OMGUS because I didn't vote him). But my main reason of suspecting him is that I know I'm town and thus know I am honest in my posts. And I'm not believing I'm that bad at mafia that I'm looking real scummy while town. He's just too confident I'm scum imo, basing it just on the fact that I looked at the BW on CKD and didn't find the evidence that strong, thus I decided to look at the person who started the flimsy case.
After that I got a load of people against me, and since I'm not really experienced I thought I was wrong, so I asked what the probable number of scum here is, and that I would reconsider my vote after I knew that (the thought behind this was eliminating the possibility that scum was just lying to make me back off).
I guess it's my fault that in my newbieness I sometimes do stuff that scum also does, that being that I am quick to adjust my opinion based on public opinion. Maybe he's holding that against me too, but those two points are the only ones I know that could have led him to believe I'm scum. And I think that isn't enough to be this confident.
I'd be just as suspicious of him if he attacked someone else this way, except that I wouldn't be sure he is attacking a townie.

Woa, this turned out to be quite a post, while I simply stated why I didn't like 50lbs his behaviour.

cicero btw, while I did indicate I don't like 50lbs and I'm going to take a closer look at him, notice I didn't FoS him. Which means that you were a bit quick to react to something I was saying in 50 lbs his direction.

Ps. looking back at what I wrote, I think I'll put that

FoS: 50lbs

there after all(dunno if that's the right way of saying it in english).

PPs. so many people to reread... I'm a couple of days behind on schedule...

[50 pounds of bread]

Oh, you are so scum.

[garbagetree]

maybe you're right here and I'm being OMGUS

y

(not OMGUS because I didn't vote him).

I don't see how OMGUS

y

and OMGUS are different because of the difference between a vote and a FoS. You are trying to cast suspicion on person who voted for you. It's the same thing.

[Peers]

By that definition, garbagetree, all I have to do is vote for the person I think is going to be the most suspicious of me, and then I can claim all his suspicions of me are OMGUS.

He's right, there's an OMGUS quality to his statement, but simply because he's attacking the guy who voted for him doesn't make it an OMGUS (or rather, it shouldn't make it one) because he makes legit points.

On the other hand, he -is- playing the "I'm doing scumtells 'cause I'm too new to know they're scumtells" card.