Open 43 - C9+2 GAME OVER before 499

[Andycyca]

If my maths are right, we need just one more vote for advancing to Night phase. What does everyone else think about this course of action?

[ibaesha]

Sounds like a plan.

vote: no lynch

[Setael]

thinktank if you listen to TylerJ and waste an investigation on me I'll scream. Reread yesterday and see if there's ANY possible way I was bussing Deathsauce.

Up to you who you investigate, but it'll really suck if you waste it on me just because Tyler is not so bright.

[xyzzy]

Day Three, Vote Count Number One, Four to Lynch

NL: TylerJ, andycyca, MoS, ibaesha

Not voting: ryan, thinktank, Setael

No Lynch walks up to the gallows, with a sad face.

"What did I ever do to deserve to be lynched?!? This is so mean. Screw you, town."

No Lynch was... um... yeah.

[xyzzy]

You all wake to find a dead body, with blood flowing from it. It seems that during the night MoS was killed.

What a shame, too. He was a townie.

[Andycyca]

I propose we follow MoS's plan, What do you think?

Vote: No Lynch

[Andycyca]

Also, I will have null access to Internet from 23-25 Nov (possibly 22 as well)

[thinktank]

Alright, so i got a townie. Please DON'T RUSH THE NO LYNCH it is probably the best play but i need to see who is likely scum. No im not gonna reveal my visions yet, so please don't rush the vote like last time.

[Andycyca]

UNVOTE

Ok, but What do we have to discuss?

[thinktank]

Well, i know the identity of possibly two townies. Was MoS one of visions? only in due time. In the meanwhile, since theres one more mafia who does everyone think is mafia. Based on accusations and logic i should get a good idea of whos mafia. Scum doesnt know who i know as town so it'll be interesting to see how this plays out. If we rush this then i dont get as much info out of it. thanks for the unvote.

[TylerJ]

Okay, I 'll work up a case on you know who most likely tommorow.

[ryan]

thinktank: I'm sorry but I'm gonna have to throw this out there, how can we know for absolute certain that you are a cop?

[Setael]

Remaining players:

Edion0 replaced by Mr.PiGG vampyrusddg andycyca
ryan
ChocolateAttack replaced by ibaesha
TylerJ
thinktank
Setael

Though we probably will want to No Lynch today, we should have it narrowed down pretty closely. I think it is impossible for ryan to be scum due to the fact that deathsauce's attempt to blame ryan for the JDodge wagon doesn't seem like it could be bussing. He could have easily just gone for someone else since ryan was not the only one pushing the JDodge lynch - there was not much suspicion on ryan at day's start and I don't think he'd have bussed right away like that. So I don't think it's ryan.

thinktank is cleared as cop. He would have been counterclaimed if he was cop, and if there happens to be no cop in the setup, there's just no way thinktank would have come out of the blue, claimed cop and bussed deathsauce. I was the only one who was REALLY convinced about deathsauce. He could've wiggled out of that lynch if not for the cop's results. So it's not deathsauce.

I am virtually cleared by my Deathsauce push. If Deathsauce and I were the only scums, it just makes no sense for me to gun for him the way I did right at the beginning of the day. Though the case on him seemed pretty clear cut to me, it obviously wasn't so clear to everyone else, and there was no reason for a scum buddy to bus him at the beginning of the day like that. I definitely need to reread the Deathsauce wagon to decide who I think the last scum is, but these are my initial thoughts.

So it's between andycyca, Tyler and ibby. If two of these are the people thinktank has investigated, the choice will be evident imo. Likely one of the people thinktank investigated is our doc unless thinktank did not investigate among these three which would be a surprise. If the doc is not among the two thinktank can clear, the doc can claim and that will clear another person. If we decide to lynch today, don't claim right away of course, but if thinktank hasn't already cleared you and we start a wagon on you, then claim of course. Worst comes to worst you're counterclaimed and we have scum narrowed down to 2. It's not lylo yet so that would be a town win.

It could really be any of the 3 I have it narrowed down to, so I'm hoping the cop can clear two of them. Tyler's attempt to get the cop to investigate me at the last minute was definitely not pro-town, but I can't tell if it was scummy or just not smart. This would sum up Tyler's play all game actually. I have thought vampy was scum for a lot of the game, so this would not surprise me. CA now ibby would surprise me, but it is also possible.

If thinktank can't clear 2 of andy, ibby and tyler we definitely need to no lynch today to get another investigation.

Nobody vote until we've talked about it awhile.

[ryan]

Is there any chance that the last scum comes up innocent upon investigation?

[Setael]

Doubtful.

[ryan]

Vote: TylerJ

Suspicions from earlier are becomming more and more.

[Setael]

uh, ryan... if we're going to lynch today, we're going to decide who to lynch after thinktank provides investigation results. if it's not narrowed down far enough, we'll no lynch.

Can you provide specifics as to why you think it's tyler?

[ryan]

I provided cases earlier on TylerJ and abandoned them due to other evidence on other players, I haven't changed my mind on him being scum. I don't like how cryptic thinktank is being on his results at the moment and so I'm going ahead with my vote and discussion can continue from there. Its not too difficult to give us the names of the innocent and go from there (which I'm still waiting on)

[Setael]

You really don't think it makes sense to wait to give the results until everyone states their suspicions? You don't think that thinktank's results might alter our scum lists? It's a good way to flush out scum, and I don't see why you're bitter about it.

[ryan]

Becaues if he has the results on innocents I see no reason for them not to be given out so we could look back and start comparing possible candidates. There are 6 people still alive, I'm not scum, thinktank apparently isn't and he's saying he knows the identity of two townies. So why not put those names out there and let's start figuring out between two people who the scum is and who the townie is. Seems rather easy and being held up in a game we have in our back pocket is irritating me.

[Setael]

What's your rush? It's not in the bag yet, turbo. I think it's wise to get each players' scum list before revealing the cop's investigation results. If thinktank didn't investigate 2 of my top 3 I'm certainly not going to be in a rush to pick between the 2.

Granted, town will probably win either way since it will be impossible for scum to pick off all the confirmed townies. As long as thinktank shares his results today, we should be able to win.

[ryan]

EXACTLY my point, results should be shared at this point and if TylerJ is town than I'll admit my mistake and unvote and move on

[ryan]

andycyca would be suspect #2

[TylerJ]

I see your point Setael abou tyou not being scum. As much as I hate to admit it. Ryan, it is funny that you would say that you still think I am scum, because honestly, I think the same way about you. When you and I continued to argue, you became less and less of a suspicion. But once the argument disspated, you became suspicion to me again. I'm assuming that was because of all of the pressure against me and because my mind was split with dealing with defending myself and giving my case about you.

You, Setael, and Vampy all were on my Suspect list. Vampy I just can't get a good read on, and Setael cleared her name. You haven't. I also find it interesting that you are the only one openly defying the No vote. Why is that I wonder?

[ryan]

I'm not defying a No Lynch, I'm asking for evidence that has been collected by a "Townie" to be given to the rest of the town. We have a large group that could be scum where if thinktank gave results our search could be narrowed quite a bit.