Mini 532: Yaw's Split Open Mafia: (Game over)

[Korlash]

Insert:

Oh, and another thing: I'm not putting any heat on Thanatos, actually. All his posts for the last page or so have been trying to get me to unvote him, and (more-or-less) all mine have been reactions to his.

At the top of my last post.. please and thank you...

[bird1111]

Vote Count:
Thantos (2): Phate, Off the Mark
Drunken Piper (1): Thanatos
QuickBen (1): Jex
Jex (1): Drunken Piper
SensFan (1): Zhao

Not Voting (5): Holy, Korlash, Korran, kabenon007, QuickBen, SensFan

With 12 alive it is 7 to lynch.

[Holy]

Look if no one said anything then the mafia would do as I said, and kill the vanilla. While the doc would protect it. Thus making he plan completely awesome!!! Now that it has been said... it has all gone down the crapper.. so to speak...

Nahhh, knowing a vanilla won't automatically make them murder the vanilla, knowing a vanilla means a bigger chance finding and murder a power role (that's a smart mafia would do), hard job for the doc to guess the right rescue.
But, after that vanilla gain power from the dead (known power because it was from the dead player) and for an example coincidentally it was a dead cop would make that former-vanilla the scum choice to murder at night 2.

Oh, and note: My plan doesn't have "flaws." My plan has a "tradeoff" that is "beneficial" for "town."

If the role-switcher is murdered at night 1, your plan froze.

[Off the Mark]

unvote:

After reading the last page, Thanatos no longer seems scummy to me.

However, this:

[quote=kabenon]But I think Phate's plan could work, but it would take luck, extenuating circumstances, but I don't like the town running full blown into a plan that could cripple us as well. [/quote]

STILL reads as quite noncommittal to me. Just because he said Thanatos comes out on top doesn't mean he has a real opinion on the debate. He is still ready to lean either way.

I still think the plan is a good one, btw. It is true that some power roles will be exposed upon reassignment, but that's much better than losing the power roles altogether.

vote: kabenon

[Korlash]

Nahhh, knowing a vanilla won't automatically make them murder the vanilla, knowing a vanilla means a bigger chance finding and murder a power role (that's a smart mafia would do), hard job for the doc to guess the right rescue.
But, after that vanilla gain power from the dead (known power because it was from the dead player) and for an example coincidentally it was a dead cop would make that former-vanilla the scum choice to murder at night 2.

True... But if say.. the vanilla would become the Doc for example. the mafia would want to off him/her before that happened... They may even fear the RB (Should we choose to bring that one back) and they will definitely fear the cop should the Doc still be alive. I don't think a smart mafia would let the cop/doc survive into the next night.

[Drunken Piper]

A day late and a dollar short.
Reading to see what there is to report.

Oh an easy wagon this early on page two.
Because a guy rhymes it must be a scum clue?

Hmm, after a 2nd thought, not really, but you must be have 'some role', didn't know a good one or a bad one. I'll

Unvote

, still unsure which one for now.

I don’t have a role, that I be claiming.
Just how I do things, the way I be gaming.

Mass claiming at this point I am against.
In this particular set up, it only helps mafia, or am I being dense?

Huh? Where? Zhao, you phail...

Don't worry, because of my "goon" status, he's willing to let me off the hook for suggesting him and Sensfan are in chahoots.

Zhao has entered being very aggressive.
Think it could be good for the game, and not yet excessive.
Of course the past couple pages he has been mute.
maybe he got insulted and decided to take a different route.

I think Phate’s plan, will work if we are lucky at night.
I couple unlucky NKs, and the plan will be full of blight.
The merits of it, will have to be noted on Day two.

Too much discussion about it today, will only help the scum crew.

Also can we please stop directing the doc.
More helpful information, for the scum flock.

I think today we NOW need to focus on lynching scum,
or victim to a scum win, we will succumb.

Vote Count:
Drunken Piper (2): Thanatos, SensFan

MOD

again you have missed something in the thread.
Sensfan unvoted, his random vote he shed.

Fixed

i closed my eyes and pointed to the screen

vote Korran

, for this is all you have added to this game.
Your participation is low and lame.
Please do comment on current events,
or maybe just provide your two cents.

[bird1111]

Korran seems to have dissapeared from the site. Looking for one now. Will check with someone who offered to replace after the original batch was found before posting in the replacement quene.

[kabenon007]

Um... how much more commitment do you want from me, OffTheMark? I'm not going to vote for Phate for his defense of his plan, because his playstyle is like this all the time, and no matter how annoying it can be, I made the mistake of voting for him once, and I won't do it again. If it escalates to something further than just his playstyle, then I will vote. Your vote comes from one sentence of a post in which I do commit... nice edit job.

[Drunken Piper]

Korran seems to have dissapeared from the site. Looking for one now. Will check with someone who offered to replace after the original batch was found before posting in the replacement quene.

this the mod wrote
this, I must

unvote.

[SensFan]

Vote: Drunken Piper

A little witty banter in the random stage is one thing, but now it looks like he is trying to detract conversation and/or try to avoid having to put any real information in his posts.

[Phate]

More importantly, he still isn't posting in iambic pentameter. TEN SYLLABLES PER LINE!

But seriously, I don't think DP is scum.

[Thanatos]

Sens, He does this in games regardless of his Alignment, and I understood it perfectly. I'm not having this exact same conversation a second time.

[Korlash]

Man... I almost choked on my taco when i read that...

FoS: Drunken Piper

for trying to kill me!

[Drunken Piper]

Vote: Drunken Piper

A little witty banter in the random stage is one thing, but now it looks like he is trying to detract conversation and/or try to avoid having to put any real information in his posts.

again, i have provided much more content than many others.
your vote is sad much like Sally Struthers.

Is that the only reason you can come up with to place that vote,
or is there something else possibly you could note?

[Korlash]

again, i have provided much more content than many others.
your vote is sad much like Sally Struthers.

Okay now you are just reaching for Rhymes,
Wasting mine and other's much needed time.
Pick your words out a lot more carefully
Or a few more votes you are sure to see.

>.>
<.<

Take that iambic pentameter!

[Zhao]

Haiku ftw!


This plan will not work;
too many holes to exploit.
Phate is suspicious.

[Phate]

There once was a marvelous plan
Phate saw it, and with it he ran
It's been detracted by some
How many desp'rate scum
And how many're just stupid? Damn.

[Thanatos]

There once was a marvelous plan
Phate saw it, and with it he ran
It's been detracted by some
How many desp'rate scum
And how many're just stupid? Damn.

Perhaps there is only one. You ever consider that.

You know, when I present a plan and town, and it gets attacked by people, I don't write those people off as stupid or scum.

[Thanatos]

plan as town* EBWOP

[Korlash]

Yeah I really don't see the need for you to be calling me stupid... Your plan needs someone to be lynched to throw it all into effect... care to volunteer?

[Phate]

Ok, I'm being at least mildly facetious here. Obviously, my plan has flaws. Everything has flaws. But I

do

think it's a good plan, and I also think that disagreeing with a plan that hurts scum can be scummy, especially if you don't provide reasons or you echo other people's reasons.

[Phate]

also, someone mentioned that we should use my plan as a backup plan and stick to scumhunting. I say do both. They're not mutually exclusive. I fully intend for the lynchee at the end of the day that we start the plan with to be scum.

[PJ.]

Hi guys, I believe I'm going to be replacing Korran. Imma start reading about now. I'll be done by december =P

[Korlash]

man I keep expecting to see an avy of Bit Cloud or something but nooo... it's a cute pink cat...

anyways.. thanks and stuff...

[PJ.]

*I'm Pausing at top of Page 5 so I can play Risk*

Vote: Korlash

until he starts posting theories that can be disproven by Occam's Razor. Followed by a cinquian(nope, couldn't resist).