Food Fight Mafia - WHO OWNS THE SCHOOL???

[DrippingGoofball]

mneme replaces SirTornado, who seems to have overdosed on Pizza Pockets.

Welcome mneme!

[Battle Mage]

lol im enjoying reading Vollkan's analysis. I'm guessing you are making this analysis AS YOU READ amirite?
A bit of advice might be to provide a little less rewriting of the thread, and a little more of your own opinions on whats happened.

BM

[Flameaxe]

lol im enjoying reading Vollkan's analysis. I'm guessing you are making this analysis AS YOU READ amirite?
A bit of advice might be to provide a little less rewriting of the thread, and a little more of your own opinions on whats happened.

BM

I'm assuming (from prior play with Vollkan) that he will go through the thread much like he is, and opinions on people come at the end.

[VitaminR]

Still here. Need to read.

[vollkan]

I'm assuming (from prior play with Vollkan) that he will go through the thread much like he is, and opinions on people come at the end.

Correct.

It's impossible for me to go through and analyse things without a proper picture. I prefer to post sort of "rough notes" with some interjection of opinion and then to go into proper analysis.

My next ten pages will be coming soon.

[Skruffs]

Interesting that BM criticizes Vollkan's rehashing of stuff without commenting on the stuff itself. *shrugs*

*flick french fry at battle mage*

[cicero]

I'm also still here and reading the recent developments intently. Havent had time to do anything of Vollkan-esque proportions yet. Actively reading though.

[The Fonz]

Hey mneme, long time no see.

A few things- I think, regrettably, mod actions suggest sirT/mneme as likely town. I doubt scum would happen to guess that some townies hadn't received win conditions, so DGB's subsequent 'if you haven't received one, you're town' message looks almost like a confirmation that ST was telling the truth.

Secondly, the Skruffs 'wagon' is ludicrous. It seems to initially have sprung up because Skruffs pointed out BM's ridiculous logic regarding the Jester scenario, and been continued because BM is, well, BM, and therefore has gotten into his chracteristic 'that guy is scum' charge, and certain people have, for inexplicable reasons, followed him. Especially, THERE IS NO WAY Skruffs is the SK. 'Cause, like, when I'm SK, I claim the town-sounding role most likely to be in the area where the body is found

all the time.

RLY.

My basic point is this: Why hasn't more stuff been thrown at ckillor? Blatant rolefisher.

Hurl pastrami on rye at ckillor

[Skruffs]

obviously my alignment is 'protown' then...

I see... so, your PM mentions you are pro town?

This is all too interesting, because my role PM actually doesn't mention any alignment. Nor does it mention any win condition. Just my name, my lunch box and my post restriction.

err no it doesnt. But it isnt difficult to infer from my role that i am protown. ROFL.
On the other hand, my role pm DOES have a win condition, and DOESN'T have a post restriction.

Throw Potato Chips at Sir T

hmmmm

[Battle Mage]

Interesting that BM criticizes Vollkan's rehashing of stuff without commenting on the stuff itself. *shrugs*

*flick french fry at battle mage*

i dont understand this post atall. Please can you paraphrase it or something, because i cant see any sense coming out of it, in its current form.

@Fonz-your comments regarding the Skruffs wagon and his play are ludicrous. I mean, please get your facts straight for a start. Skruffs claimed Dinnerlady, BEFORE finding out that the Dinnerlady worked in place where people were being killed. Weak defence much?

I actually cant believe that Skruffs isnt dead yet. IS NOBODY LISTENING TO THE FACT THAT HIS CLAIM OF THE MECHANICS OF HIS ROLE MAKE NO SENSE, AND HAVE BEEN COUNTERED BY MYSELF, THUS ONE OF US HAS TO BE SCUM, AND I'M COP CONFIRMED INNOCENT?


BM

[mneme]

Konichiwa, Fonz-san, and the rest of the town. I am very happy to be here.

I'm afraid I have not yet finished my read-through, but I am confident that I will be able to do so soon. I did receive an alignment (students/town), but it's possible that this was a correction that previous holder of my role did not recieve.

I am afraid that I cannot comment on the BM/Scruffs fight right now; I need to catch up first. But until then, I'll fling some

fake

food around, just to get in the spirit of the game.

tosses Natto at Scruffs
spreads Ume on some bread and beams it at BM
strawgun's a piece of Pocky at Fonz

[Battle Mage]

a piece of Pooky? rofl

[Flameaxe]

A piece of POCKY, retard.

*shoots a copy of

Reading for Dummies

at BM*

[Skruffs]

In order of self-percieved likeliness:

A) bm could be mafia and tarhalindur is insane

B) bm could be godfather and either tar Really investigated him and then put himself at risk for no reason by 'clearing him', or tar is claiming cop knowing that if bm does die it still looks good for him (more likely)

C) bm is a jester that shows up as pro-town on investigations but is still trying to get himself lynched, creating a false dichotomy so that if I do get lynched and show up town, he gets lynched the next day

D) both me and bm could be townies, but bm has no clue what he's talking about in regards to alignment, role, abilities, behavior notes, and win conditions.

E) perhaps since the caeteria is 'my turf', I have more bad behvavior notes than bm, who is 'visiting'.

Note: bm, instead of talking about current topics, continually falls back on 'he's scum'. Much like how certain politicians use certain events to avoid having to answer questions at a press conference, bm has onesole thing in mind.



Bm, make a promise to me: if you sucessfully get me lynched and it turnsout I wasn't lying, you will voluntarily help lynch yourself tomorrow because ifyou're not scum, I am, in your own words, and I want to push yor flawed, stupid, idiotic reasoning to the next step and make you eat your own words. If I am town, you are scum, agreed?



Note: I would never do this to anyone in any game but if bm's acting this way intentionally - and he hasn't denied this - then I want him to be held to it. Town will do better with a dead bm, regardless of his alignment.

[Yamahako]

D) both me and bm could be townies, but bm has no clue what he's talking about in regards to alignment, role, abilities, behavior notes, and win conditions.

I'm inclined to believe this one.

BM, I have a request. Pretend Skruffs isn't in the game, and give support *any* support to another lynch candidate. There isn't just one scum in this game - and even if Skruffs is (which I believe he isn't) there are more avenues to research.

This argument between Skruffs and BM has been seriously dangerous for the town. It's allowed other people to act scummy without recrimination. It's created a huge distraction to ACTUAL scum hunting. It's led to the claiming of the cop unreasonably early. It's completely stopped the throwing of food (bad, IMO). It's gotten us dangerously close to deadline TWICE, with no actual lynch we decided upon under a real town consensus the first time.

We have 10 days. With no cop counterclaim, no one is going to actually kill BM. With no reasonable argument against him, no one is going to actually kill Skruffs. Let's look for other good candidates - like ABR for example.

Skruffs- you forgot options F: You both are scum and are making a master plan to create dissention to avoid lynches while keeping the town disorganized.

[The Fonz]

Tar- what is the flavour justification for your investigations? Can you detect any antitown forces, or just a specific scumgroup?

[The Fonz]

@Fonz-your comments regarding the Skruffs wagon and his play are ludicrous. I mean, please get your facts straight for a start. Skruffs claimed Dinnerlady, BEFORE finding out that the Dinnerlady worked in place where people were being killed. Weak defence much?



BM

BM, one question, are you really this stupid? IF HE WERE THE FREAKING SK, HE'D KNOW WHAT THE SK'S KILL METHOD LOOKED LIKE, WOULDN'T HE?

[ckillor]

Hey mneme, long time no see.

A few things- I think, regrettably, mod actions suggest sirT/mneme as likely town. I doubt scum would happen to guess that some townies hadn't received win conditions, so DGB's subsequent 'if you haven't received one, you're town' message looks almost like a confirmation that ST was telling the truth.

Secondly, the Skruffs 'wagon' is ludicrous. It seems to initially have sprung up because Skruffs pointed out BM's ridiculous logic regarding the Jester scenario, and been continued because BM is, well, BM, and therefore has gotten into his chracteristic 'that guy is scum' charge, and certain people have, for inexplicable reasons, followed him. Especially, THERE IS NO WAY Skruffs is the SK. 'Cause, like, when I'm SK, I claim the town-sounding role most likely to be in the area where the body is found

all the time.

RLY.

My basic point is this: Why hasn't more stuff been thrown at ckillor? Blatant rolefisher.

Hurl pastrami on rye at ckillor

ow. thats a bit harsh and quick to attack me, but i see where you are comnig from. what i said is rolefisher-y but it was more just a thinking out loud thing.

[Battle Mage]

A piece of POCKY, retard.

*shoots a copy of

Reading for Dummies

at BM*

lol thats ironic.

GOING, GOING, GONE.

Jordan knows what i'm talking about.

BM

[Battle Mage]

In order of self-percieved likeliness:

A) bm could be mafia and tarhalindur is insane

B) bm could be godfather and either tar Really investigated him and then put himself at risk for no reason by 'clearing him', or tar is claiming cop knowing that if bm does die it still looks good for him (more likely)

C) bm is a jester that shows up as pro-town on investigations but is still trying to get himself lynched, creating a false dichotomy so that if I do get lynched and show up town, he gets lynched the next day

D) both me and bm could be townies, but bm has no clue what he's talking about in regards to alignment, role, abilities, behavior notes, and win conditions.

E) perhaps since the caeteria is 'my turf', I have more bad behvavior notes than bm, who is 'visiting'.

Note: bm, instead of talking about current topics, continually falls back on 'he's scum'. Much like how certain politicians use certain events to avoid having to answer questions at a press conference, bm has onesole thing in mind.

Ok ok, i admit it. I definitely Lol'd at this bit.
You find the possibility of Tar lying, and actually not being a cop, to be LESS likely than him being INSANE?

As a note, i dont think E makes sense, much as you would like it to. This isnt a case of you having 'more' BB notes, you seem to have INFINITE BB notes.

Bm, make a promise to me: if you sucessfully get me lynched and it turnsout I wasn't lying, you will voluntarily help lynch yourself tomorrow because ifyou're not scum, I am, in your own words, and I want to push yor flawed, stupid, idiotic reasoning to the next step and make you eat your own words. If I am town, you are scum, agreed?

Please keep up. I suggested this about 15 pages ago.
I am certain you are scum. If you die and come up town, i wont resist my subsequent lynch.

Note: I would never do this to anyone in any game but if bm's acting this way intentionally - and he hasn't denied this - then I want him to be held to it. Town will do better with a dead bm, regardless of his alignment.

um so you are suggesting this not because you think i am scum, but because you'd like to see me die for personal reasons. Lol.

[Battle Mage]

@Fonz-your comments regarding the Skruffs wagon and his play are ludicrous. I mean, please get your facts straight for a start. Skruffs claimed Dinnerlady, BEFORE finding out that the Dinnerlady worked in place where people were being killed. Weak defence much?



BM

BM, one question, are you really this stupid? IF HE WERE THE FREAKING SK, HE'D KNOW WHAT THE SK'S KILL METHOD LOOKED LIKE, WOULDN'T HE?

um no. Name me one game where the SK has, in his role pm, recieved his own kill method implicitly.

I sure as hell havent seen that before.

BM

[Battle Mage]

D) both me and bm could be townies, but bm has no clue what he's talking about in regards to alignment, role, abilities, behavior notes, and win conditions.

I'm inclined to believe this one.

BM, I have a request. Pretend Skruffs isn't in the game, and give support *any* support to another lynch candidate. There isn't just one scum in this game - and even if Skruffs is (which I believe he isn't) there are more avenues to research.

This argument between Skruffs and BM has been seriously dangerous for the town. It's allowed other people to act scummy without recrimination. It's created a huge distraction to ACTUAL scum hunting. It's led to the claiming of the cop unreasonably early. It's completely stopped the throwing of food (bad, IMO). It's gotten us dangerously close to deadline TWICE, with no actual lynch we decided upon under a real town consensus the first time.

We have 10 days. With no cop counterclaim, no one is going to actually kill BM. With no reasonable argument against him, no one is going to actually kill Skruffs. Let's look for other good candidates - like ABR for example.

Skruffs- you forgot options F: You both are scum and are making a master plan to create dissention to avoid lynches while keeping the town disorganized.

This is frigging ridiculous. I officially hate this game atm.
I'm going to lurk for a while unless Skruffs is willing to put himself forward in the way he suggested earlier.

BM

[Flameaxe]

The game hates you too.

[Battle Mage]

The game hates you too.

evidently.

[JordanA24]

The game hates you too.

Way to kick him while he's down