Yeah, I mean if you were such an excellent player that you regularly got night killed by scum right off the bat it would be an excellent choice for SK. It'd also be an excellent choice for town good enough to get night killed right off the bat too.
If you were kinda jerkass lurker town who tends to end up in LyLos because they're just good enough to not be the slowest person in the room when the lynch comes about, but lynchbait enough the scumteam didn't try and kill them ever, you'd have a dilemma. You'd want more kills to accelerate the game so the lynch couldn't get around to you, but you'd want some way to dodge the dayvigs too. Hey, could there be something that does both?
Untrod Tripod, who was a Mafia roleblocker, has survived the endgame.
Untrod Tripod, who was Card Guard, Eight of Hearts, and Town Compulsive Bodyguard, has survived to Endgame!
Untrod Tripod - Killed Night 4 - Town Even-night Rolestopper
Untrod Tripod, Mafia Rolecop, survived
Untrod Tripod has commited suicide Night One! He was A Sanskrit Kitten, Town Regal Conditional Tracker.
Untrod Tripod, shot Night Two, was Sebastian Montes, the Town Constable.
Untrod Tripod, Clue Mafia, Miss Scarlet (Town) - Killed in Endgame
Untrod Tripod, Coover Bennett, Mafia Goon, survives and wins with the mafia.
I mean like seriously, here's how it works. Either you have a strong town power role, or you survive to endgame. You survived to endgame as a compulsive bodyguard. You're some strange species of weed that isn't useful for anything but can't be killed.
Now tell me what you found compelling about LLD's arguements.