Let's look at what has happened.
BM has false dilemma'd (amongst many other things, such as counterclaiming himself) by saying that IF He is town, I am scum, because we have claimed different mechanics for the bad behavior notes.
(Side note: It is proven that both me and him have bad behavior notes; since neither of us have lied, it is now very likely that we both are probably our claimed roles)
Tarhalindur has claimed a " Cheerleader" Mason-Cop with an innocent on Battle Mage when he (and battle mage) was under no significant pressure. Slight false dilemma regarding several other players (Jordan and Aimee are who I remember).
(Another side note, Tarhalindur seemed to be sided with Battle Mage day one (as per TSS's long review post shortly before he died). Curious why he investigated BM if he thought BM was mroe town than the people arguing against BM.)
The Fonz began questioning if Tar could detect any type of scum or just mafia (breadcrumbing his future sk-cop role)
Quite a few players have suggested that we are both townies, others have pushed me or Battlemage to start launching food at the other.
Battlemage is pushing that he is cleared by tarhalindur, and that I am therefore town, although nothing about Tarhalindur's claim can be confirmed (At this time).
The Fonz pushes that I am not the sk several times, even directly, to counter other player's assertions that the Lunchlady (who serves food) is the "Cook" (The role-name I Am assigning to the presumed SK who 'boiled' JDodge last night ((Side note to BM: JDodge was not served, I don't know where you got that idea. Nobody has died, just been eliminated from the game.)))
The Fonz has claimed that he is "Fat Kid" - the equivalent of an FBI agent, which seems to infer (if he is telling the truth) that the theory that the 'cook' is an SK, is a good one. (Via flavor-matching and evidence of 'cooking'). He's claimed an innocent on me, seeming to say I'm not the SK. The only way I can imagine The Fonz would want to fake claim an SK cop with an innocent on someone, if he wasn't the SK cop, was if he was the SK, or if he knew there was no SK.
ABS then counterclaimed The Fonz saying that he was the fat kid. AS someone else mentioned, , lactose intolerance (drinking milk and then farting out a post restriction on someone) is not indicative of being fat, and, as well, ABS has not exactly counterclaimed The Fonz 'gourmand taste tester' flavor as for the reasoning behidn his role, or the action of actually investigating another player. Can ABS investigate anotehr player? If so, can he only investigate if he's been splashed with milk? Dairy items include cheese, yogurt, and milk, I have none of those things in my inventory.
Even more intriguing is that ABS is sayign that he knows The Fonz is scum, that he KNEW he was scum. However, The Fonz apparently (somehow) claimed ABS's 'role' before ABS did, and ABS's talking afterwards is suggesting that he may have fake claimed his role to put pressure on The Fonz? I'm not sure how to interpret this.
For me to be the "SK", The Fonz needs to be Mafia, which makes ABS the real SK-cop (if that is what he is claiming to be) or another scum, which would be really nice if it were true. (Three scum in a row, shebang). I will point out that PlaysWithSquirrels last post stated that he wanted to see a case on someone that wasn't based on Flavor, which is (slightly) counter intuitive to The Fonz claimed role. It would make sense for The Fonz (as SK-cop who knows the flavor behind the SK) to investigate someone who claims to have worked in the kitchen.
The alternative "Skruffs=scum" situation is that I am mafia, which hasn't been disproven yet. I will note that, with bad behavior notes confirmed to be in the game, that the mod seemed disappointed with the lack of them being used. IT is possible tht mafia DO have bad behavior notes, as well - there's no way to confirm someone being town just by them having notes. This doesn't do ME any favors, of course, saying that, but it should be said.
Regarding TSS, I really do not think he was a doctor. I believe that he was a 'vote eraser', that's what his flavor describes. I think it would help to look at this game as having three tiers of eilminations. The public tier which has Everyone tossing food (And the 'value' of food has gone up since yesterday, I believe gummy bears are now all worth at least one point, I have no idea if the Peas have any effect yet, though). This 'tier' ends each day with someone being lynched as a rsult of food thrown about by each player, and is reset at the beginning fo the next day.
There is a "Selective" tier which consist of bad behavior notes; if a player gets so many notes, they are eliminated from the game. Apparently, only a selective group of players have these notes, and the notes do NOT reset at the beginning of a day, which is why TSS was in the game. TSS deleted those notes from 'the permanent record'. I think it's very likely that he probably removed one or more of the notes I gave BM yesterday.
The third tier is that of the night kills, which are private and ultra selective, as only the people who are actually making the night kills decide how they eliminate players.
So there are three mechanics that are around, one of which is definitely useable by the town, and another (the second tier) is at least Partially usable by the town.
Claimed Roles:
----
BM - Librariany - Finite Bad Behavior Notes
Skruffs - Lunchlady - Finite Bad Behavior Notes Per Day
----
Tarhalindur - Cheerleader - Mason, Cop, with innocent on Battle Mage
The Fonz - Fat Kid - SK-Cop, with innocent on Skruffs
ABS - "Fat Kid" - Lactose Intolerant(?), if hit with milk can give another player a porting restriction, also Sk cop??
-----
Gorrad - Allergic to Something
----
mneme - Japanese
YosiP - French
foolinc - Spanish
I think there's another ethnicity but I forget what it is now
I suppose my questions now are:
Albert:
Please clarify what you have claimed. Are you multiroled?
Tarhalindur:
Please clarify why you targetted BM and if you thought he was town day one, and also, now that you know the reasoning behind The Fonz's asking if you can detect SKs, are you still suspicious of him? And can you detect SKs? If so, that would at least partially refute the fonz's claim.
Alpha Strikers/Counternukers/Etc
: What is the point behind 'sudden death' tactics?
[c]cicero[/b]: You read the entire game and your sole conclusion was that I was likely the SK who 'got caught', and that The Fonz is scum. Does this mean that you believe Albert's counterclaim? Why do you think The Fonz would (as mafia) go out on a limb by false claiming a role to save someone who is likely the SK? IF you think I am the SK than I can't be on The Fonz's 'mafia' team, so please explain why this would have happened?
JDodge was useless but TheSilentSpeaker was not. His big post towarsd the end was actually a very useful summary. Has anyone else read it or have comments on it?
I don't like this at all. More argument between BM and skruffs.
