The War to End All Freaktowns: GAME OVER

[ibaesha]

I am trying to figure out how you see this applying more towards Kinetic's actions than say ... Andy's or the other 10ish people who aren't voting for anyone at all. As I already said, your statement that Kinetic is voting without reason is false.

[farside22]

I am trying to figure out how you see this applying more towards Kinetic's actions than say ... Andy's or the other 10ish people who aren't voting for anyone at all. As I already said, your statement that Kinetic is voting without reason is false.

QFT.
We have until the 14th for the deadline. I was hoping their would be more discussion about scum then there has been. Kintic making his vote against taut is not a bad thing. The guy hasn't even come in to defend himself.
If the mod doesn't extend the deadline I'm sure more votes will come your way if it makes you feel better BM.

[Battle Mage]

I am trying to figure out how you see this applying more towards Kinetic's actions than say ... Andy's or the other 10ish people who aren't voting for anyone at all. As I already said, your statement that Kinetic is voting without reason is false.

true, and i did consider voting Andy. But, i seem to recall Kinetic looking scummy earlier here. Read my posts, and you should find out why.

BM

[Kinetic]

BM is still illogically mad at me for calling him out on his hypocrisies day one. His vote of me is not a surprise since I'm part of his "Axis of Evil" from day one, but his unreasonable arguments are just as ludicrous today as it was yesterday.

Although it is true that his inevitability of being a possible lynch did factor into my not voting him, I figure that Taut has a slightly higher likelihood of being scum, assuming MOS and Kilroy are town. Also, since my vote places Taut at 4 votes, to BM's 8, it makes him the only other possible lynch target besides BM before deadline.

I don't understand how BM could say that makes me look scummy, but it sounds like he is saying I'm fixing toward the

too townie

fallacy. But this assumes that he

will

be lynched, will be proven town, and that makes me scummy for trying to push a lynched against his only competitor to be lynched. Sounds like a leap to me, but, this is BM logic we're talking about.

I really don't know if BM is town or scum, but I'm leaning toward him being more likely irrational town then idiotic scum. Although I could be wrong.

[soupfly]

I don't believe BM is necessarily scum but rather an easy target because he's BM. I view those pushing hard for his lynch with great suspicion.

vote: ibaesha

--> call it a gut feeling

[ibaesha]

Oh that's interesting, you are suspicious of people pushing for his lynch, but vote me (someone not voting him at all) based on a 'gut feeling'. Not to mention, your own participation in this game has been far less than stellar.

[Battle Mage]

Oh that's interesting, you are suspicious of people pushing for his lynch, but vote me (someone not voting him at all) based on a 'gut feeling'. Not to mention, your own participation in this game has been far less than stellar.

valid point.

[Battle Mage]

BM is still illogically mad at me for calling him out on his hypocrisies day one. His vote of me is not a surprise since I'm part of his "Axis of Evil" from day one, but his unreasonable arguments are just as ludicrous today as it was yesterday.

Although it is true that his inevitability of being a possible lynch did factor into my not voting him, I figure that Taut has a slightly higher likelihood of being scum, assuming MOS and Kilroy are town. Also, since my vote places Taut at 4 votes, to BM's 8, it makes him the only other possible lynch target besides BM before deadline.

I don't understand how BM could say that makes me look scummy, but it sounds like he is saying I'm fixing toward the

too townie

fallacy. But this assumes that he

will

be lynched, will be proven town, and that makes me scummy for trying to push a lynched against his only competitor to be lynched. Sounds like a leap to me, but, this is BM logic we're talking about.

I really don't know if BM is town or scum, but I'm leaning toward him being more likely irrational town then idiotic scum. Although I could be wrong.

Do you play CN?
Anyway, u voting for the second highest target means nothing, seeing as it puts Taut nowhere near contention.

Finally, your final paragraph is totally scummy. You manage to make it seem like you come to a conclusion, when in actuality, you continue to sit on the fence, in order to afford you opportunity to hop on a BM wagon later. Nope, im not buying it.

BM

[Kinetic]

BM, the logical fallacy you are using now is "Poisoning the Well". You see me as scummy, thus no matter what I say, you will find it scummy.

[Battle Mage]

nope, in case you hadnt realised, im probs gonna die today. As such, id like to at least be able to have the moral highground at endgame by saying, i had scum pegged. And yeh, ur last paragraph was totally scummy. You cant use the old 'Oh my God BM Sucks' argument to ignore the points against you.

BM

[soupfly]

Oh that's interesting, you are suspicious of people pushing for his lynch, but vote me (someone not voting him at all) based on a 'gut feeling'. Not to mention, your own participation in this game has been far less than stellar.

u got something against my gut?

[Kinetic]

nope, in case you hadnt realised, im probs gonna die today. As such, id like to at least be able to have the moral highground at endgame by saying, i had scum pegged. And yeh, ur last paragraph was totally scummy. You cant use the old 'Oh my God BM Sucks' argument to ignore the points against you.

BM

Right. Moral high ground. You don't even know what that means.

[Battle Mage]

nope, in case you hadnt realised, im probs gonna die today. As such, id like to at least be able to have the moral highground at endgame by saying, i had scum pegged. And yeh, ur last paragraph was totally scummy. You cant use the old 'Oh my God BM Sucks' argument to ignore the points against you.

BM

Right. Moral high ground. You don't even know what that means.

Back to square one eh? irrelevant insults. Good going kid.

[Kinetic]

This is you taking the moral high ground.

-.-

[farside22]

I feel like I'm listening to squabbling children.

Soupfly: You are not making any sense. You say you are voting for ibaesha for bandwangon on BM, but she is not voting for BM. Your comment and vote is more questionable then BM is making Kintetic out to be.

Oh that's interesting, you are suspicious of people pushing for his lynch, but vote me (someone not voting him at all) based on a 'gut feeling'. Not to mention, your own participation in this game has been far less than stellar.

u got something against my gut?

[soupfly]

btw, is battlemage officially the worst mafia player ever? maybe he enjoys the attention but if his intention is to get people to notice him then streaking a soccer match would probably be more interesting. i can buy into different people's play styles but BM just screams "hey, look at me".

[Battle Mage]

btw, is battlemage officially the worst mafia player ever? maybe he enjoys the attention but if his intention is to get people to notice him then streaking a soccer match would probably be more interesting. i can buy into different people's play styles but BM just screams "hey, look at me".

-.-

who are you voting for atm?

[ibaesha]

u got something against my gut

Other than it being wrong, eh.. *shrug*

The problem is that you express 'great suspicion' of people on BM's wagon, but vote someone who is -not- on that wagon. It's contradictory.

[Dark Ermac]

Fuck it. I'm not dealing with this shit anymore. It's not worth my time.

Replace me please.

lol :good posting:

am i dead yet

?
I'd best claim. I'm vanilla, with a shitload of stuff that doesnt do anything.
WOOT WOOT.

Btw, is it ok if i use this game as a meta-policy against the 'ALWAYS LYNCH BM' meta-policy?

do you want to be?

unvote jdodge
vote BM

O God not you again!

WHy? Just because I want to hear what everyone think about BM wagon? I won't vote him (yet) because I don't remember enough to vote. Besides, this game has a lot of

lurkers

not-so-active players and It's not fair to move the game without hearing their opinions.

I can agree to this, but no one will bother with saying anything about the BM bw, so this statement is completely useless.

I don't believe BM is necessarily scum but rather an easy target because he's BM. I view those pushing hard for his lynch with great suspicion.

vote: ibaesha

--> call it a gut feeling

Call it corrupted judgement.

FOS: soupfly

[soupfly]

u got something against my gut

Other than it being wrong, eh.. *shrug*

The problem is that you express 'great suspicion' of people on BM's wagon, but vote someone who is -not- on that wagon. It's contradictory.

what's wrong with that? i never said they were the only suspicious ones. and why do you care so much about one "gut" vote?

[soupfly]

I feel like I'm listening to squabbling children.

Soupfly: You are not making any sense. You say you are voting for ibaesha for bandwangon on BM, but she is not voting for BM. Your comment and vote is more questionable then BM is making Kintetic out to be.

Oh that's interesting, you are suspicious of people pushing for his lynch, but vote me (someone not voting him at all) based on a 'gut feeling'. Not to mention, your own participation in this game has been far less than stellar.

u got something against my gut?

sorry i missed this post. i never said i'm voting ibaesha for being on the BM wagon. they're two seperate things. 1) i'm suspicious of the BM wagon cause its an easy lynch. 2) my gut tells me ibaesha is scum --> note i didn't give any reasoning yet as to why i think this is so.

[Battle Mage]

then please do so.

[Holy]

2) my gut tells me ibaesha is scum --> note i didn't give any reasoning yet as to why i think this is so.

Maybe I missed the clue, so please do so.
There's too many lurkers here... Well... at least, we need Tautology posting to hear his defends.

[soupfly]

most of you been playing this game longer than i have so i'm guessing you can figure out why somebody would not want to divulge the reason for their suspicion up front...especially when its not a situation where a lynch is in the balance.

[farside22]

2) my gut tells me ibaesha is scum --> note i didn't give any reasoning yet as to why i think this is so.

Maybe I missed the clue, so please do so.
There's too many lurkers here... Well... at least, we need Tautology posting to hear his defends.

QFT.
Also I would like to know if the mod is giving us more time since some people have been AWOL for awhile.