Regarding Ythill/Incognito: I think Incognito is being earnest here; and I am less certain that Ythill is. Yet, it's true what Ythill said about his (too early) claim being provable; and as Justin mentioned, the town has
a lot
to gain in the case that his claim really is true. However, if we do collectively decide to let their argument be handled in the night time phase, as I think we should, then we still have the immediate concern of who to lynch day one, before the holy wrath of the mod deadlines us.To that end, I really don't trust Disciple Slayer. He is lurking; but more than that, he is purposefully lurking. It seems to suit him well. He promises more content at a later date, only to let it pass and continue to slide by. It's quite frankly textbook in my opinion. His arguments seem disconnected from reality and don't jive with those of at least a significant minority of the town. For example:
Both Apyadg and Ho1den immediately disagreed with this in the following two posts. It should be pointed out that Apyadg was the one that DS was attacking, just for the record. I also sided against DS although only later, once I had replaced into the thread, since this post predates my joining the game.Disciple Slayer wrote: There was no way MafiaSSK's initial vote could have been a serious one. Come on, who finds someone suspicious at the beginning of the random voting stage? That was obviously a joke vote.
I remain suspicious of Apyadg to a certain degree, but not nearly as much as DS. DS's only votes in the game have been for Apyadg (possible distancing, possibly not) and then he followed Ythill's case and voted for me. Since then he's committed two more errors. First, the player listing that wasn't informative in any way, as it only contained any information at all about one player, myself. And much more importantly, an out-of-the-blue attempt to get a mass roleclaim on day one. This has to be one of the worst tells I've ever seen. I have only played in a handful of games, and I am almost always wrong day 1 lynches. The only time I was actually right on a day 1 lynch was in the just-recently-abandoned open 50. Sammich did a player by player analysis, and said he thought I was a doctor. I called him on the role fishing and went after him for it. Though the game never completed, the post game discussion revealed he was actually scum. DS has attempted to get the same power role reveal here, and I intend to see him hang for it.
I'm already voting for him, so there's no new vote casting down here. I encourage others to do the same.
