Food Fight Mafia - WHO OWNS THE SCHOOL???

[Gorrad]

Very fun game, DGB! Bah, go town!

[Skruffs]

Okay.. a nurse that prevents against Burnings, which I am guessing would be the soup mafia. Which, I've also noticed, we haven't HAD any burnings since JDodge, I think.

Might as well start with the claimed doctor's results!

[Albert B. Rampage]

I think you're all scum and I'm the last town left.

[Flameaxe]

I think you're all scum and I'm the last town left.

Na, You're scum and we're all town, obvobv.

[Korlash]

bah I bet we masons dont get guilty results... *sighs*

[TheHermit]

Does anyone else find it a little odd that ckillor claimed RB and yet he turned out to be what I assume is a vanilla townie? Quite

étrange

, is it not? What reason would he have to lie about his role? I'm so confused.

[Albert B. Rampage]

He's a dumbass, plain and simple.

[Korlash]

Well he did claim a student... perhaps DGB just left out his ability in the death scene...

[Gorgon]

Does anyone else find it a little odd that ckillor claimed RB and yet he turned out to be what I assume is a vanilla townie? Quite

étrange

, is it not? What reason would he have to lie about his role? I'm so confused.

Not only that, but he gave a different name as well. Weird.

[Skruffs]

And his replacement confirmed it all, too.

[JordanA24]

Did I just miss a whole day? <.> I'm so sorry to everyone, the game dropped itself from my watchlist! I only noticed the game in the Theme Games thread just now. Doh!

Can somebody give me the gist of what happened yesterday please?

[Flameaxe]

Korlash had craplogic, I argued with him for said craplogic. Ckillor claimed RB, got replaced, hascow claimed RB. We lynched them, they were vanilla.

[Korlash]

Craplogic say what? What was that? You were wrong? ohh... burn...

[Flameaxe]

Craplogic say what? What was that? You were wrong? ohh... burn...

And this is why you should stay in school, folks.

[Korlash]

I did my time... They kicked me out after I finished the 12th grade.. the jerks! Told me to go home cause I can't be on school property anymore! Mentioned college but do you knwo how much that place costs? Like... three arms and a leg! Where am I going to find a third arm? A drifter???

Seriously though, scum shouldn't say stuff like that flame... it's hurtful... ;_;

[Skruffs]

bah I bet we masons dont get guilty results... *sighs*

So who did you get an innocent on?
As far as you know, everyone you targetted has in fact been innocent.

[cicero]

Skruffs. Words cannot express how much I want your old avatar back.

[Flameaxe]

Skruffs. Words cannot express how much I want your old avatar back.

I've already expressed my agreement with cicero via IM.

[Korlash]

I didn't want to say anything... but yeah... It's a little creepy...

And I really don't want to say who I got innocents on, as at this point there is no reason to.

[Tarhalindur]

Speaking of masons getting innocents... a-yup, I got another innocent (Yamahako, for what it's worth) last night. Given what Korlash is now saying, I'm pretty sure I'm Naive at this point.

This, in turn, means that it's time that I do a thorough reread on Skruffs and Battle Mage. At this point, I think that giving them a free pass based on investigation results is a bad idea.

I'm also interested in how none of the scum kills have targeted players in the upper half of the player list, especially since there have been no scum crosskills so far. I still suspect that there is something up with the player list, although I won't deny that ckillor coming up town is a blow to the theory. (If we do decide to lynch based on player list, Gorgon is the clear lynch today.)

[Yamahako]

Speaking of masons getting innocents... a-yup, I got another innocent (Yamahako, for what it's worth) last night. Given what Korlash is now saying, I'm pretty sure I'm Naive at this point.

Obviously I think you got the right result - but I'm wondering how many people HAVEN'T been investigated yet..

Is there a list?

[cicero]

I have a speculative guess about the masons which I think is probably obvious to some but anyway... I think you all need to work together on the same target. As you work together your percentage chance of getting a correct result will go up. Going up to 100% if all masons target the same person. I have no idea whether the death of one mason buddy would result in you never getting 100% or needing less cooperation to achieve 100% but that's my guess anyway.

Did you consider working together?

[Skruffs]

Speaking of masons getting innocents... a-yup, I got another innocent (Yamahako, for what it's worth) last night. Given what Korlash is now saying, I'm pretty sure I'm Naive at this point.

This, in turn, means that it's time that I do a thorough reread on Skruffs and Battle Mage. At this point, I think that giving them a free pass based on investigation results is a bad idea.

I'm also interested in how none of the scum kills have targeted players in the upper half of the player list, especially since there have been no scum crosskills so far. I still suspect that there is something up with the player list, although I won't deny that ckillor coming up town is a blow to the theory. (If we do decide to lynch based on player list, Gorgon is the clear lynch today.)

Gossiping has NEVER been proven to be an investigative role.

However, The fonz cleared me of being in the soup scum mafia. Trying to refute that to put attention on me is BAD. I don't believe your claim.

I think it's funny that you abandoned your own theory yesterday o go after other people, and then,a fter it works, you still try to encourage other people that there is something about it.


Isn't it *Also* interesting to note that two claimed cops haven't been targetted, long after the other claimed cop was NK'd?


Korlash: If you are naive, like you claim, then there is no reason not to prove that you actually investigated someone, even if your investigation is faulty.

I think it's possible, and this is a spur of the moment theory, that the mason 'cops' were three people, one a 'bumbling' cheerleader, and the other two maybe each part of a mafia group. The two that were scum got the third killed to 'clear' themselves, and have been, I dunno, maybe telling their own groups who to kill who not to kill?

I don't know, it's just a theory, but it's a lot more likely than Tar's suggestion that the players who do have innocent results on them, not even by Their own claimed naive investigations, but by other, confirmed, scum-specific cops, no less, start being investigated.

I don't understand why Tarhalindur would want to cannibalize his results like that. I don't see why jsut because he has all innocent results, he would assume he's naive.

That's also why Korlash should 'confirm' his innocent results, because so far it seems that nobody who's been targetted by either of them has been Nk'd, and it's probably up to four, if not five, players by now.

I think that a pair of mason cops should be trying to investigate as many people as they can as well as claiming their results. If they are naive, it will show up after time, but until they are proven naive, there's no reason to think so.


But then again, Tarhalindur thought that one out of every three 'clumpings' was scum, and he thought that the mason-cop who had targetted him was naive, so I have no reason to think that TArhalindur is telling the truth about what he's saying.

[Korlash]

Actually I highly blieve Tar is scum... I have my own reasons behind it. And I have no proof. So... Don't take it badly there Tar.

As for me I have so far investigated Fonz (Failed or more acurately "Not given") BM, and Skruffs.

Both BM and Skruffs came up innocent. Now... After everything I said yesterday I found that hard to believe so I figured I would wait to see if they were Nked or something first. But whatever... As you say we are not "proven investigations" so my innocent results on you mean nothing.

As for the Tar thing, hinges mostly on the fact he said every three must have a scum or something. And out of the three of us he is the only unknown to me. Like I said proves nothing (especially now) but combine that with the fact I have yet to have him talk to me at night makes me think he is otherwise "preoccupied" at night. So... Yeah... I don't think hes a good lynch candidate... but its somethign to think about..

[Skruffs]

This game seems to be lagging, and we need to spice it up.

Here's something to chew on: Night two, two players were bashed in the head. Are there any 'motivators' or players that would help someone do more than one night action? If so, whoever they targetted ngiht two may have been scum.