An L-2 vote like the one he put on you isn't a bad play with this game's setup. Yes, both of the mafia could have joined the bandwagon and lynched you, but then the rest of us would then have a clear idea of who to lynch the next two days.Battousai wrote:Well, from what I know, what Russo did was a bad play. Reason being is that if he wasn't scum and neither was knight, then scum could have pilled on vote 3 and 4 and I'm out on the first page.
I read through everything, and I thought things over, and I'd have to disagree. Townies aren't very likely to hammer, see, so if Ross and PWIRL are the mafia, and they L-1 each other, they're actually quite safe from lynching, seeing as no one will hammer them.Because it doesn't seem like much of a strategy for the scum to each put the other at L-1, I doubt that Rosso and PWIRL are both scum. That said, they are each individually suspicious.
I think that's exactly what you're doing Ross, distancing yourself from your scumbuddy.unvote, vote wizard
seriously this time, he needs to be lynched before his scum buddy can have ample bussing and distancing time.
C9 101:Battousai wrote:Well, from what I know, what Russo did was a bad play. Reason being is that if he wasn't scum and neither was knight, then scum could have pilled on vote 3 and 4 and I'm out on the first page.
But then Sir Tornado did the same thing, and I give him the same reasoning and him and Russo are both ICs and they should know better hopefully.
Then PWIRL placed a THIRD vote on Russo. Extremely scummy, but since he's new and this might be his first game, that also leans on the opposited as Extremely newbish move.
Then the wheel spins back to Russo who placed a THIRD vote on PWIRL, and asks for him to be lynched, LYNCHED on PAGE 1! I give him the same paragraph as PWIRL, but minus the newbish move, since he's IRL.
What we need to do is to stop putting people at L-1 and instead lets use IGMEOY, FOS, SFOS, and HOS.
Right now, I upgrade my IGMOY toSFOS: Russo
But having a 3rd vote this early is extremely bad for the town, and putting on that 3rd vote is the most horrible thing a townie could have done, and its just stupid. No townie would do is, and the only other option is wizard is scum.
*changed day 3 to 2, I believe that is what you meantThat way its 2vs1 on day 2 and the town has very little to go on. Then its a simple 3 person lylo situation where the town has no information beyond that of a cop.
Perhaps they will be safe in the immediate short term, but any L-1 vote is certain to draw a lot of attention. Given that the early game is usually just (semi-)random voting, it seems pretty silly for the scum to bring everyone's attention upon themselves right off the bat.ting =) wrote:I read through everything, and I thought things over, and I'd have to disagree. Townies aren't very likely to hammer, see, so if Ross and PWIRL are the mafia, and they L-1 each other, they're actually quite safe from lynching, seeing as no one will hammer them.Because it doesn't seem like much of a strategy for the scum to each put the other at L-1, I doubt that Rosso and PWIRL are both scum. That said, they are each individually suspicious.
Sure the game is about suspicion. Is there any reason we shouldn't suspect you? Try to come up with a defense (or at least suggest reasons that others might be more suspicious than you).Powerful Wizard IRL wrote:UNVOTE
I might have made a newb move and made myself look bad. I doubt I can win anyone over, seeing how this game is all about suspicion.
No, it's 2 town vs 1 mafia on day three:Battousai wrote:*changed day 3 to 2, I believe that is what you meantThat way its 2vs1 on day 2 and the town has very little to go on. Then its a simple 3 person lylo situation where the town has no information beyond that of a cop.
Code: Select all
Day 1: 5 vs 2, after a foolish early L-1 vote, one of the mafia hammers a townie for a quick lynch
Night 1: 4 vs 2, the mafia NK a townie
Day 2: 3 vs 2, LYLO, town lynches the hammerer from Day 1, probably with the other mafia member joining in to throw his partner under a bus
Night 2: 3 vs 1, another townie is NKed
Day 3: 2 vs 1, LYLO
Well, my vote on Russo wasn't a serious vote in anyway, as you can guess from the ":p" at the end of it. I am not liking PWIRL's vote on Russo, mainly because it was a third vote.BlckKnght wrote: Sir Tornado, as the other IC, what do you think of the early votes?
I know that. My reason for voting you was as serious as you asking for the claim.Russo Crane wrote: so THAT is why putting a 2nd vote on is fine. I wasnt being serious asking for a claim, as i wouldnt ask for a claim either way, not in an open setup like this. But having a 2nd vote is no problem.
You were on L-1 for a grand total of less than an hour.Russo Crane wrote: In fact, if wizard somehow wasnt scum, then the scum lost their best opportunity in not quicklynching me.
Er, I think that takes him to L-1, which is a bit farther than I want to go just yet.ting =) wrote:Hey mod, could we have avote count?
I'm in class now, so this is going to be short, but anyway, I think the scummiest person so far is Ross. His actions and his words are far too contradictory.
unvote. vote:Rosso Carne
YESBattousai wrote:That is what I was trying to point out and get a response from rosso. He places a third vote on someone on page 1 for putting a third vote on someone on page 1.
