In post 341, Ginngie wrote:I think Lapsa is trying to dig out scum reads out of me but that is just a waste of time for me until like day 7 of Day 1, sorry not sorry but personal philosophy
@Vifam - strongest scumread is Crush but I need to reevaluate. Gonna reread soon.
@Ginn - you're missing the point. Lots of people have personal philosophies. They shouldn't have a place in mafia. Your approach in particular makes winning (as town) much more difficult than it needs to be.
lynching transcend seems dumb for what was essentially a joke.
egg gives me townfeels at this point but idk theres not that much info yet
PMysterious seemed too literal when the game started, obviously pisskop has been scum before but does that lie matter or was it a joke that was blown out of proportion. but then later i think PM did some pretty good analysis on gamma so idk
I like WM explanation of transcend's meme vote (232). that makes sense to me, even though i think it was a dumb joke in the first place.
I think overall the lazer focus/L-4 on gamma is a bit fast, too fast for a wagon imo. my top scum reads are crush for avoiding voting and gin for being weird about scum reads but its still v early
In post 356, Lore wrote:lynching transcend seems dumb for what was essentially a joke.
egg gives me townfeels at this point but idk theres not that much info yet
PMysterious seemed too literal when the game started, obviously pisskop has been scum before but does that lie matter or was it a joke that was blown out of proportion. but then later i think PM did some pretty good analysis on gamma so idk
I like WM explanation of transcend's meme vote (232). that makes sense to me, even though i think it was a dumb joke in the first place.
I think overall the lazer focus/L-4 on gamma is a bit fast, too fast for a wagon imo. my top scum reads are crush for avoiding voting and gin for being weird about scum reads but its still v early
I don't agree with everything in this post, but I like it for a town post. Not afraid to take solid stances. My one question is about the gamma wagon. You said it's fast, but I can't quite tell what your opinions on that are. Are you townreading gamma? Are you scumreading anyone for their vote on him?
im not really scum reading anyone for voting on him, i think he has posted some scummy things but im not convinced on him yet and i think its possible scum is urging along the wagon because its easy. idk, i need to observe more to decide how i think about him, i dont townread gamma, he is like null scum to me. could be a neutral....
In post 356, Lore wrote:lynching transcend seems dumb for what was essentially a joke.
egg gives me townfeels at this point but idk theres not that much info yet
PMysterious seemed too literal when the game started, obviously pisskop has been scum before but does that lie matter or was it a joke that was blown out of proportion. but then later i think PM did some pretty good analysis on gamma so idk
I like WM explanation of transcend's meme vote (232). that makes sense to me, even though i think it was a dumb joke in the first place.
I think overall the lazer focus/L-4 on gamma is a bit fast, too fast for a wagon imo. my top scum reads are crush for avoiding voting and gin for being weird about scum reads but its still v early
I don't agree with everything in this post, but I like it for a town post. Not afraid to take solid stances.
I had the opposite reaction. Positions aren't strong. Reads on Egg and PM are qualified with "idk." And mostly regurgitates safe positions that others have articulated.
In post 356, Lore wrote:lynching transcend seems dumb for what was essentially a joke.
egg gives me townfeels at this point but idk theres not that much info yet
PMysterious seemed too literal when the game started, obviously pisskop has been scum before but does that lie matter or was it a joke that was blown out of proportion. but then later i think PM did some pretty good analysis on gamma so idk
I like WM explanation of transcend's meme vote (232). that makes sense to me, even though i think it was a dumb joke in the first place.
I think overall the lazer focus/L-4 on gamma is a bit fast, too fast for a wagon imo. my top scum reads are crush for avoiding voting and gin for being weird about scum reads but its still v early
I don't agree with everything in this post, but I like it for a town post. Not afraid to take solid stances.
I had the opposite reaction. Positions aren't strong. Reads on Egg and PM are qualified with "idk." And mostly regurgitates safe positions that others have articulated.
what can i say, im indescive first day. i like to examine things before i come to firmer positions but i figured i should at least get some of my ideas out there before the thread gets away from me.
y'all post fast....
pedit: i still dont like mutton and i still think his posts are annoying but he hasnt done much to give me stuff to go on yet. he has nice rhymes, i couldnt do that with my reads for sure, but other than that idk. he ahsnt been as annoying as his first two posts were since then so thats good.
i agree with a lot of what crush has posted especially with it being a dumb way to lynch someone without more information. Their posts feel town to me right now.
Theta is nothing to me at this point, they've hardly posted at all.
i dont know if crush's posts feel town cause i agree with them so i tried to ignore that and see what that did for me but overall their posts seem pretty logical and like they are in towns best interests so thats where ill stay right now
Lore, see that's what I don't get. Usually having an issue with the speed of a wagon means you think scum are pushing it. But if you aren't scumreading anyone on the wagon, why point out how fast it is?
Fourtrouble, I was reading those both as being town reads. Maybe lore didn't seem confident, but that's ok. Lack of confidence can mean uncertainty which imples a lack of knowledge about alignments which is town. I also don't see it as just being safe reads like you say. A town read of pmyst is borderline between safe and not. Ginngie seems like the type of player who may push back on a scum read. And even the transcend stance (while yes it's been said by a select few) is mostly against the grain. Lore also gave two scum reads and neither is the two lead wagons so she's not afraid to be different. I really liked the post.
lore wrote:my top scum reads are crush for avoiding voting
lore wrote:i agree with a lot of what crush has posted especially with it being a dumb way to lynch someone without more information. Their posts feel town to me right now.
i am not necessarily scum reading anyone YET but i do have my eye on the people on the wagon already. I think the latter half of the votes get progressively more suspicious just because its so fast and i haven't seen anything that makes me think the evidence is THAT strong yet. That being said, i dont yet have strong enough reads to be able to say so-and-so is SCUM because they voted GAMMA. its just a thing im keeping an eye on right now.
pedit: no you are right sorry i am an idiot: i think crush not voting is scummy, but rereading their posts i guess i do agree with what they saying. i think withholding their vote is weird tho at this point in the day when they have clearly been active.
read my previous post... im just an idiot and this is the largest game ive ever played with relative strangers. it is odd to me that you asked me about crush right after i had posted opinions on them but thats the explanation. i think i agree with the posts they have made but find their lack of vote relatively scummy. i dont have super strong reads on anyone at this point