Open 57 - Quack Mafia (Game Over) before 545

[shaft.ed]

A three vote quicklynch is not neccessarily and easy thing to pull off. I wouldn't assume it would have to happen. But you do raise a good point.

[farside22]

I don't know if everyone has posted and I think more talk about the two with the votes would do us good.

[Crub]

Vote Count:

Phate (1) :

Oman

Oman (1) :

Phate

Not Voting (5) : shaft.ed, TylerJ, Tarhalindur, kuribo, farside22

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

[shaft.ed]

Oman your lack of posting here is disturbing me. You're very active on site. We're currently in LyLo. You vote without an explanation and then disappear.

[TylerJ]

Nothing new to mention, still throwing around the phate and oman idea.

[Oman]

Sorry shaft.ed. Quack Mafia lost my interest a bit. Re-reading.

[Phate]

I'd like to note that if a townie votes the wrong player in Pool 1 (Oman/Me), then the other two scum will jump on and win.

[Crub]

To all Quacks, Doctors, Scum : Please Post More! Prod's going out tomorrow

[Oman]

I'm here.

Happy with my vote.

[kuribo]

Maybe I'm missing something, but why CAN'T both be scum?

[farside22]

Maybe I'm missing something, but why CAN'T both be scum?

Maybe they are. I'm just leaning more towards Oman then Phate. Do you think one is scummie or have a thoughts on the two who voted against each other?

[shaft.ed]

Oman, Phate and Tar all scored NK's N1. Thus at most only one can be scum.

I take it that noone is interested in my numbers. That makes me sad . If it's down to Phate or Oman I'll do a reread and see what I can come up with. But I would like more input. Tar & Tyler, can you please get up the strength to post something we need to get this one right.

[TylerJ]

doing that right now

[kuribo]

Maybe I'm missing something, but why CAN'T both be scum?

Maybe they are. I'm just leaning more towards Oman then Phate. Do you think one is scummie or have a thoughts on the two who voted against each other?

I've thought Phate fairly scummy for a bit now... but Oman's behavior of late is disturbing...

Oman stated that "scum rarely vote first in lylo..." and then... voted in lylo? Is Oman trying to draw attention away from his attempt at a quicklynch? He accused farside of having a "horrible reason" for voting in lylo... and gave a non-reason for voting Phate.

[farside22]

Maybe I'm missing something, but why CAN'T both be scum?

Maybe they are. I'm just leaning more towards Oman then Phate. Do you think one is scummie or have a thoughts on the two who voted against each other?

I've thought Phate fairly scummy for a bit now... but Oman's behavior of late is disturbing...

Oman stated that "scum rarely vote first in lylo..." and then... voted in lylo? Is Oman trying to draw attention away from his attempt at a quicklynch? He accused farside of having a "horrible reason" for voting in lylo... and gave a non-reason for voting Phate.

I love hypocrites. They are so scummie.
Seriously though I saw that too. It just made me think he was more scummie for not only the comment but the behavoir. I wonder if Phate is lying low so most of the thoughts are on Oman.

[TylerJ]

So I did some research on Oman and Phate.

Oman went along with the no lynch and then went after MoS for coming up with that and another strategy. he goes along with the first plan even despite the fact that he saw a flaw. If he is scum, perhaps he was eager to along with the plan because he knew that it wouldn't work that well for town. Antoher side of me says that if he is scum, then why would he want to mention the hole in the strategy?

Again, if oman is scum you would expect that mafia didn't make any kill day one, as oman saw that it would benefit them. Unfortunately there is no way of knowing.

Phates post about if he should use his night ability to find scum was puzzling. If he was scum, I can't see him asking the question, because he could care less about the towns opinion on it. He would just want to kill. So the only reason I can see him as scum doing that is if he was indirectly assuring us that he was quack. But if he was quack then it makes perfect sense, despite the fact that it wasn't an intelligent idea.

those are my thoughts so far, I haven't read through the whole game yet.

Here is another thing, if we get to a point in the game that we have no chance of finding all of the scum fast enough (misslynching in lylo), then I can see- as a last resort- a quack or two using there ability with discretion. But in no other circumstances is it profitable.

[shaft.ed]

Again, if oman is scum you would expect that mafia didn't make any kill day one, as oman saw that it would benefit them. Unfortunately there is no way of knowing.

If Oman was scum Oman killed the person above him N1. Please pay attention folks.

[TylerJ]

Again, if oman is scum you would expect that mafia didn't make any kill day one, as oman saw that it would benefit them. Unfortunately there is no way of knowing.

If Oman was scum Oman killed the person above him N1. Please pay attention folks.

Just because I miss something doesn't mean you should get on my case. On the contrary that's why we have a town, not just a townie; so that others can bring up and mention details that we failed to look at. Unfortunately, MoS was lynched because of not thinking things through and town not doing the same.

[Phate]

kuribo, if you think I'm scummy then make a case against me.

[shaft.ed]

Not liking kuribo or Oman at the moment. Would like Tar to post but I've noticed he's down as VLA.

[farside22]

Not liking kuribo or Oman at the moment. Would like Tar to post but I've noticed he's down as VLA.

What was your problem with what Kuribo said? Is it as Phate pointed out that he didn't have a case on Phate? Kuribo is right insofar as Oman being a bit of a hypocrite in his vote and poor case. Yesterday you felt Tar and Phate had come across scummie now you are not as sure?

[shaft.ed]

I never once said Phate was scummy. I said Tar was scummy and MoS may be scum. Further I didn't like kuribo or Tyler for non-contributions. Kuribo just came in and regurgitated a point I made two pages ago so as to look like he's doing something. That's what I don't like about him. He's continuously rode on other people's play as if too look like he's doing something. He did the same with the MoS lynch yesterday and yet he gets no recognition for it. Me thinks his plan may be working.

[TylerJ]

^^^hmmm, I'm going to have to look at kuribo closer. Unfortunately, I have class coming up and I don't have enough time to actually have any in depth analysis.

[Oman]

Oman stated that "scum rarely vote first in lylo..." and then... voted in lylo?

Of course, sometimes they do, but I know when I'm scum I prefer to wait for a quicklynch to swoop down on.

Is Oman trying to draw attention away from his attempt at a quicklynch?

This is not an attempt at quicklynch, this is so far from it. This makes me believe you're phate's buddy.

He accused farside of having a "horrible reason" for voting in lylo... and gave a non-reason for voting Phate.

Farside did have a horrible reason to vote when he could have lost the game. However, I've thought phate scummy for a while now and I was right. Farside's problem was it was pretty much "The dead townie said you were scumz, therefore you're scumz."

I love hypocrites.

Hey, I'm voteing because I found scum. You were voting because a dead townie told you to.

Antoher side of me says that if he is scum, then why would he want to mention the hole in the strategy?

I saw a different flaw to the one that acutally came out, but basically I wanted to mention it because I wanted people to not put much faith in it. I personal voted for the strat, but mos' second plan was just terrible.

I'll look at kuribo after we lynch phate. Unless you lynch me, in which case...we'll there are enough docs around.

Did any doctor protect phate last night? What about quacks?

[Tarhalindur]

Instead of getting hasty about lynching someone, I want a mass target claim for N2. It might be revealing.

Let's do it in random order, ok?

Original Roll String: 1d7

1 7-Sided Dice: (1) = 1

Original Roll String: 1d6

1 6-Sided Dice: (4) = 4

Original Roll String: 1d5

1 5-Sided Dice: (4) = 4

Original Roll String: 1d4

1 4-Sided Dice: (4) = 4

Original Roll String: 1d3

1 3-Sided Dice: (2) = 2

Original Roll String: 1d2

1 2-Sided Dice: (2) = 2