Mini 532: Yaw's Split Open Mafia: (Game over)

[Skruffs]

Actually, I *did* refute your points. I was wrong, but I did refute them.
I didn't think mafia would be stupid enough to kill a mason partner while switching the other one out, or to claim guilties on their own scum doctor so that the doctor would get killed the following night, or that they would block the cop and kill.. what, a townie? instead of killing the cop and blocking someone else who might have been the SK.

So yes I thought that the SK killed his own partner and was surprise-switched into the roleblocking role. I wouldn't say YOU refuted it as much as the evidence refuted it.

[bird1111]

Vote Count:
SensFan (2): Drunken Piper, Holy
Holy (2): Skruffs, SensFan

Not voting (1): mikeburnfire

With 5 alive it is 3 to lynch.

[Skruffs]

I...err.... um...
Are they voting or not voting..
Holy and Sensfan are Schroedinger's cousins...

Fixed.

[mikeburnfire]

You thought the SK had a partner?

[Skruffs]

I Thought the SK was the mason that killed the other mason.
This has been disproven.

[Drunken Piper]

Bump
this lump

[mikeburnfire]

vote: Holy

[bird1111]

You string up Holy, and check her house. You find it plain, just like Off the Mark's and Korlash's, and realized that she was another Unpowered Town.

Night 4 begins, choices due Tuesday@6:30 PM EST

[bird1111]

The one/two remaining night choice(s) is/are in. So therefore starting day.

You wake up to find that only 3 of you are still here. You look around to see who is missing. You realize it is Drunken Piper. You check his house, and find it plain, making you realize he was Unpowered Town. This means that the battle for control of your town is in its last stage. Either the two remaining townies will find the SK and lynch him, or the SK will trick the townies into lynching one of their own and win.

Drunken Piper, Unpowered Town, killed Night 4.

Day 5 begins, with 3 alive it is 2 to lynch.

[Skruffs]

Only 3 of us are alive there bird1111.

[SensFan]

Darn, I was sure that if was DP or Holy.

I need to go back and look over the 2 of your posts.

[Skruffs]

Okay.
Initial thoughts:
Mike's hammer came without reasoning, though he had explained his opinions in earlier posts..

Sensfan apparently reopened "Role Switcher" last night, or else that hasn't been fixed.

I'm a bit more suspicious of Sensfan and less suspicious of MBF today:
Why?
Because I stated pretty thoroughly yesterday that I was pretty sure that Sensfan was town. If MB was the SK, he would have wanted to NOT be in a situation where Sensfan is likely to be believed over him, which would make me a better choice than drunkenpiper for last night's kill. Also, I was more suspicious of MB than DP was; DP was rather ambivalent towards the end.

Lastly, MBF was as suspicious of me as I was of him, which would lead sensfan into a relatively safe position by letting us attack each other.

Not voting yet, obv, but that's how I see it right now.

[SensFan]

I did not open any roles last night. I didn't see the point.

A lot of what you wrote for me being more suspicious comes down to WIFOM.

[Skruffs]

How is it wifom?

And what else am I supposed to go on, other than speculation?

[SensFan]

MBF or yourself could very well have purposely left the other one alive with the hopes of using that exact logic to get me lynched. Another reason to leave me alive would be that I have admitted than I haven't followed the game as much as I would like.

I don't like that yesterday MBF was a higher suspect of yours than I was, but today you say that you think I'm the SK.

[Skruffs]

What does leaving you alive benefit MBF? You are suggesting he would know i'd be suspicious of you being alive?
You were -1 yesterday, remember? I was the only person who wasn't willing to vote you.

Why don't you like it? Whoever decided to kill DP obviously considered him more of a threat than me, right? Your last post

[SensFan]

Whichever of you or MBF are scum may very well have left me alive, planning to use the EXACT logic you used, that it must be SensFan playing Skruffs and MBF against each other.

On a side note, I think you may have forgot to finish your last sentence.

[Skruffs]

In the reread, which I found a little tough,
I have come to the conclusion that me doubts our SK is scruffs.

My suspicion of Holy, is going to and fro.
I see her words, but her actions today I would rather know.
I would like to see what she does today.
Which is why me thinks, her lynch should be waylaid.

MBF, is aggressive and has proven to be actively on the scum hunt.
But so would the SK and he could be putting on a front.
I say that he does have a townish look,
But I can not yet put him in my town book.

Sensfan I have thought was scum for some time.
I disagree with Skruffs, when last he chimed
in that he thought Sens was not the SK.
Why do you think this every day?

Most likely my vote will find it’s way to Sens,
Before this day comes to a close, my town friends.

sensfan, wifom aside:
DP was most suspicious of you, and least suspicious of me.

I was least suspicious of you, and most suspicious of MBF.

MBF was pretty neutral towards both of us.

And you? I forget what you were.

[SensFan]

Yesterday? Holy-DP-MBF-Skruffs
Today? Skruffs-MBF (so far)

[Skruffs]

Why is the role-switcher reopened, then?
I thought for sure that was fixed yesterday.

[SensFan]

I opened a role 2 nights ago.

But of course, you're not actually doubting my claim, are you?

[mikeburnfire]

Well, I really don't know what to do now. I'm leaning towards Skruffs being the SK, but I am definitely not going to place my vote yet. It may take a few days, but I'm going to go back and analyze both of your plays.

[Skruffs]

No, just confused about when things happen.

MBF : Explain why, please? Just saying it, at end game, is scummy, especially when Sensfan is already 'leaning' towards me?

[Holy]

;_;

Well, townies! Please win.

[bird1111]

Don't make me deadline you this early in the day...