Hi!
Thanks for that insanely fast lynch yesterday. Looks like Uncle Sam got sat down by big bad Bilbo Baggins. Good work!
Gorrad wrote:it's unlikely (although not out of the question) for a one-shot lynch protection to be scum.
Might I ask why? Oman had a similar protection in
BM's Mystery Mafia. Granted, it didnt' work exactly the same way, but it followed the same concept of overriding a lynch vote.
Guardian wrote:anyways, i tried to kill erg0 last night. he is 100% scum.
I believe Guardian tried to kill Erg0. I see no reason for him to lie about this.
However, I do not believe Erg0 is sealed as scum based on this solely. There is a very strong chance we're dealing with roleblockers/protectors of some sort, and that cannot be ruled out. However, this is the sort of thing you need not forget for later on in the game.
OK, I just reread the rules :
MrStoofer wrote:In other words, for a scum cross-kill to occur, a bad guy must be targeted twice by the same scum group. If a kill fails for that reason,
the targeting scum group will be told that that was why their kill failed
.
That changes things a bit. We know that the "Goblins" either chose not to kill or had their kill blocked. We also know by the rules that they know that their kill was blocked due to hitting scum. What we do not know is whether or not Guardian lied to us. We do know he screwed us with Thok, however.
I guess one other thing we don't know is whether or not a doctorish protection would nullify the notification that they targeted scum, but Guardian insisted that he was certain of Erg0 being scum. So to me, we're relying on whether or not Guardian lied. The other thing is that if Guardian did lie to us, he did not really drop any dead certainties of anyone else being scum besides Thok(if I recall correctly), which seems unreasonable since their kill obviously did not go through that night.
Guardian wrote:we have 2 members (me + one other) so plz try not to find him/her, we were pretty disadvantaged from the start and then I effed up.
I don't necessarily buy this.
Vote : Erg0