Open 53: Near-Vanilla - Game over!

[Korlash]

Korlash, are you suggesting your vote is only on JDodge until he speaks up? And are you willing to lynch him if he doesn't?

*shrugs* If i talk about it it won't come true! shhhhh... >.> <.<

[RossWilliam]

killa seven, if your not fully committed to your vote, don't make it. And you say you're voting JDodge instead of TSN because TSN defends himself more often. not even better, more often. How does this make TSN less potentially scummy than JDodge?

[neko2086]

I feel a bandwagon on him is justified. He's made no real contribution to this game. There are other lurkers that trouble me, but JDodge worries me the most at the moment. Again, I'd ask you, do you have any reason to believe he is town? If somebody can answer this, I'll reconsider.

That said, it's always interesting to see who will join a wagon. To be honest, I was a bit surprised when Korlash and k7 joined so quickly.

[Justin Playfair]

Neko2086,

No reason at all. But not much to think he's scum, either. Still, I'm pretty comfortable with all three of your answers, at this point.

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

I generally support lurker lynches, I'm not particularly opposed to a jdodge lynch, and obviously I find it infinitely preferable to a me lynch. . . but the way this bandwagon is starting up is a little unusual.

[Crub]

I generally support lurker lynches, I'm not particularly opposed to a jdodge lynch, and obviously I find it infinitely preferable to a me lynch. . . but the way this bandwagon is starting up is a little unusual.

Supporting Lurker Lynches is not pro-town, just in case you were under that impression.

[Korlash]

I'm always against Lurker Lynches myself. I prefer a good replacement to a stupid lynch anyday. JD just frightens me! *hides under bed*

[RossWilliam]

Then why are you voting for the lurker lynch, Korlash?

[Shanba]

see if you can engage him an argument. That's usually the best way to get a read on a lurker, I find.

[Korlash]

Then why are you voting for the lurker lynch, Korlash?

I'm not voting for the lurker lynch, I'm bandwagoning a player I think needs a bandwagon, adding to that I myself trust Neko and personally *always* find JD in someway worth a vote, means that come deadline TA DA! found my vote. You better get your facts straight before you start implying crap like who I'm voting for and why.

see if you can engage him an argument. That's usually the best way to get a read on a lurker, I find.

Doubt it will work with JD... You have fun though if you feel like it.

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

Supporting Lurker Lynches is not pro-town, just in case you were under that impression.

I disagree.

[RossWilliam]

elaborate, TSN? and Korlash, I was just calling it as it appeared to me. Take all the offense you want, but it still looks like a lurker lynch. Maybe cause that's what it is.

[JDodge]

so why haven't we lynched rosswilliam yet

he's so damn obviously scum it's not even funny

[Phate]

klebian, why are you voting RossWilliam?

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

Pressuring lurkers is good, but pressuring lurkers will only work if you are clearly willing to lynch them.

Also, I don't mean lurkers as in players who are completely absent, but rather players who aren't contributing, which pretty well defines jdodge's play.

And why don't you ask crub to elaborate?

[Korlash]

so why haven't we lynched rosswilliam yet

he's so damn obviously scum it's not even funny

That's funny! i would say the same thing about you! =D silly scumz, votes are for town! /slap

[killa seven]

im comfortable with my vote now, j dodge made a joke after the 1st vote on him like he dont care " dun dun dun" doesnt even ask why ay of the votes are on him or defends himself.. i mean i exspected him to ask me a question or something.

[Korlash]

No JD doesn't give a crap about games until like day 2+ or something. So his reactions are expected. Doesn't change the fact he is scumz!!!!! yarg!

[RossWilliam]

And why don't you ask crub to elaborate?

I agree with Crub's sentiment. I didn't agree with yours. Asking you to elaborate is just me seeing if you have a valid point of disagreement which I'm just not seeing.
I'm not gonna bend over backwards to defend JDodge, because I'm totally split down the middle on him. I will need to see more concise reasoning as to why he's the best candidate for a lynch before I vote him myself.

[Hjallti]

retractable deadline: 3 days left (70 hours)

This day will end not later than feb 26th, CET 11.30 am.

Official Vote Count

**

TheSweatpantsNinja

: 3 (Justin Playfair, Crub, Shanba)

MelodyMan23

: 2 (TheSweatpantsNinja, RossWilliam)

RossWilliam

: 2 (JDodge, klebian)

Jdodge

: 3 (neko2086, Korlash, killa seven)

Not voting

: 3 (skitzer, MelodyMan23, Phate)

**without further votes the lynchee for feb 26

The Night actions I will handle in the order which is common on this site: First Jailkeeper (which is roleblocker), then doc (not done if doc is jail), then NK (not done if either the scum who sent me the choice is in jail or if the target is in jail or docprotected). If you don't think you can sent them to me between next tuesday and next friday you may send them in advance.

[klebian]

Apologies. I have neglected this game. Long weekend so I will be posting tomorrow or Monday, and I will definitely have a vote placed when deadline hits.

[killa seven]

the 3 who havent voted need to vote and stop stalling

[Crub]

And why don't you ask crub to elaborate?

Do you not agree that it's easy for scum to push a Lurker lynch while knowing the alignment of the lurker?

What information do you think you can get out of lynching someone who isn't posting?

Lurking makes it hard for the town, but the correct course of action is to get the player replaced, not lynching them.

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

How do you handle players who are posting without being helpful?

[RossWilliam]

ignore them? Though they are not helping the town, they're not hurting it either. They should be investigated, of course, but I don't think that was entirely done with JDodge