Open 53: Near-Vanilla - Game over!

[Phate]

It differs from case-to-case, and on meta. If someone is lurking or active-lurking in just one game, that's cause for suspicion. If their behaviour is the same sitewide, it's not.

[neko2086]

I haven't played in any games with JDodge, so I'll probably have to do a quick meta. I was hoping the bandwagon that formed would put at least a little pressure on him to contribute in some way, but that doesn't appear to be happening.

JDodge, I'm not sure you ever explained why you think RW is scum. Did I miss it?

[Korlash]

^ main reason my vote is on him. I would at least like him to say something about why RW is a good deadline kill.

as for meta, thats complete BS. If that was the case no one would ever be allowed to lynch me for stupid logic, bad numbers, or just plain being annoying. Yet half the people on this site try it all the time. If you continually do something scummy, you better expect to continually be voted, lynched, under suspicion, etc...

[Hjallti]

retractable deadline: 26 hours 35 minutes left

This day will end not later than feb 26th, CET 11.30 am.

Official Vote Count

**

TheSweatpantsNinja

: 3 (Justin Playfair, Crub, Shanba)

MelodyMan23

: 2 (TheSweatpantsNinja, RossWilliam)

RossWilliam

: 2 (JDodge, klebian)

Jdodge

: 3 (neko2086, Korlash, killa seven)

Not voting

: 3 (skitzer, MelodyMan23, Phate)

**without further votes the lynchee for feb 26

The Night actions I will handle in the order which is common on this site: First Jailkeeper (which is roleblocker), then doc (not done if doc is jail), then NK (not done if either the scum who sent me the choice is in jail or if the target is in jail or docprotected). If you don't think you can sent them to me between next tuesday and next friday you may send them in advance.

[skitzer]

OK, my choice for deadline is melodyman. I feel as though his first vote wasn't good, and I don't believe he has been very contributive otherwise. In that case,

Vote: Melodyman23

[Hjallti]

deadline: 11 hours 50 minutes left

This day will end not later than feb 26th, CET 11.30 am.

Official Vote Count

**

TheSweatpantsNinja

: 3 (Justin Playfair, Crub, Shanba)

Jdodge

: 3 (neko2086, Korlash, killa seven)

MelodyMan23

: 3 (TheSweatpantsNinja, RossWilliam, skitzer)

RossWilliam

: 2 (JDodge, klebian)

Not voting

: 2 (MelodyMan23, Phate)

**without further votes the lynchee for feb 26

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

Unvote, vote jdodge.

I still prefer a melodyman23 lynch, and if someone else votes for him, I will change my vote back, but as I would be lynched at deadline currently. . . well, my choice is clear.

[Phate]

Vote: MelodyMan23

[JDodge]

Unvote, vote: melodyman

[Justin Playfair]

Unvote. Vote JDodge

I still don't have anything against JDodge and I don't even mind his Melodyman vote so much, because it's a reasonably good line, but Phate, how about a few words on why you would want to give TheSweatpantsNinja the vote on Melodyman he was asking for?

[Crub]

Unvote. Vote JDodge

I still don't have anything against JDodge and I don't even mind his Melodyman vote so much, because it's a reasonably good line, but Phate, how about a few words on why you would want to give TheSweatpantsNinja the vote on Melodyman he was asking for?

If you don't have anything on him wtf are you voting him?

unvote; vote: MelodyMan

[Justin Playfair]

Oh, Crub,

I just wanted to see if it would get someone whose only posts on MelodyMan were to defend him to join Phate, who hasn't said a word about him, on his wagon.

MelodyMan had just tied JDodge. I untied it to see what would happen.

We've lost the chance to get a serious, content-based lynch today. If I'm counting correctly we're at 5-5 right now.

It will be interesting to see what happens next.

[Crub]

At this point JDodge's head is in the noose.

Personally I think both JDodge and MM are both probably town, but at this point I'd prefer to lose MM than JDodge even if he is playing the Asshat to perfection.

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

Unvote, vote melodyman.

[Justin Playfair]

It's a dilemma. I trust the way the wagon arose on JDodge less than I do the one on MelodyMan, but the people I suspect the most are on the MelodyMan wagon.

On one hand, JDodge is actually lurking, while MelodyMan has probably just sung his tuneless way out of all of our lives, so lynching MelodyMan would at least spare us the bother of replacing him.

On the other, JDodge is actually lurking. I understand this is his MO, but we should all be working to push this game along. He's not just hitching a ride, he's stealing from us the opportunity to judge his play. So it probably does us the most practical good to lynch him.

Not happy that this has devolved to one of these two, but of the two I guess I'll take JDodge.

[Justin Playfair]

Though now the votes are:

MelodyMan: 6
JDodge: 4

[Korlash]

I still like JD over MM. If it wasn't sucha close race I would throw my vote back on phate though... I'm watching you buddy!

[klebian]

Hmm I'm looking at the case on melody man and I realize that he's made about 3 posts. The first was a vote on rw because out of rw and tsn, rw had more votes.
The second post is to explain his suspicions of rw: mainly rw's panickiness and his 'all of a sudden' change to calmness/coolness. He backtracks now and says that another reason he voted rw over tsn was because his only suspicion against tsn was 'feelings'.
The third post states that he realizes the votes on rw were just a wagon, so he unvotes (not revoting tsn)

Now looking at jd's posts: Nothing at all. A lot of nonsense, a lot of votehopping, and his 'suspicion' of rw seems to just have been based on a vote he had made, which also had no backing.

I don't really care about meta that much here. If he's not only gonna lurk but not even post anything when he's posting, I don't like it. Unfortunately mm's lurking doesn't help.

Basically, I could go with either lynch. I slightly prefer a jd lynch so I'm going to

vote: jdodge

. I am hoping that mm will return from business and start posting, because he hasn't made substantial posts in any topic, while jd has.

[Crub]

Why aren't we lynching klebian?

obv scum.

[killa seven]

klebian forgot to unvote then vote.

[klebian]

Why aren't we lynching klebian?

obv scum.

can't tell if this is sarcasm or seriousness
care to elaborate?

(If the unvote is needed,

unvote, vote: jdodge

[Crub]

Why aren't we lynching klebian?

obv scum.

can't tell if this is sarcasm or seriousness
care to elaborate?

(If the unvote is needed,

unvote, vote: jdodge

Accusation based mainly on the fact that you're scum.

[Hjallti]

deadline: 1 hours 48 minutes left

This day will end not later than feb 26th, CET 11.30 am.

Official Vote Count

TheSweatpantsNinja: 1 (Shanba)
Jdodge: 5 (neko2086, Korlash, killa seven, Justin Playfair, klebian)
**MelodyMan23: 6 (RossWilliam, skitzer, Phate, JDodge, Crub, TheSweatpantsNinja)


Not voting: 1 (MelodyMan23)

**without further votes the lynchee for feb 26

[Hjallti]

After a long debate and forced by the falling of the night the Alcatross official lyncher called Alba Tross enters and asks town who should be hanged. Discussions are suddenly fierce and three names fall, but Alba says he can only lynch one player:

In the end you decide to lynched MelodyMan23. Night falls...

...MelodyMan23, a vanilla townie, is hanged...

Sun sets...

and will raise again in the morning.... 70 hours after this post.

[Hjallti]

Goodmorning Alcatross,

When you gather to breakfast together Phate is missing:

When you go to his place you find keys.... of the jail

Phate,

jailkeeper

is no longer alive

With 11 it takes 6 to lynch and you get 35 days to reach a decision:

fixed deadline: This day wil end no later than friday April 4th