PIRATES v. NINJAS! Game Over!

[Mr Stoofer]

Vote Count

Rogueben: 5 (Primate, cicero, Lawrencelot, Thesp, Iammars)
UltimaAvalon: 1 (Kison)

Not voting: 7 (Cogito Ergo Sum, mikeburnfire, UltimaAvalon, ooba, The Fonz, MrBuddyLee, Rogueben)

7 to lynch!

Deadline: 9am GMT Friday 14th March

As things stand, Rogueben would be lynched at deadline.

[mikeburnfire]

I'd vote Rogueben, but CES makes me nervous. I'll hold off on my vote for now.

[Thesp]

RogueBen needs to claim or die.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Agreed.

Also, mike is town. (Just fyi.)

[mikeburnfire]

This is true.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

What's kind of sad (for me, at least) is that I really have been reading, but I can't seem to find scum. Mike's townness is still useful info, but I don't really have much to go on, currently. And noone is making a case against anyone(apart from the lame "rogueben isn't contributing") either.

[The Fonz]

It's occurred to me that I could probably only name five other players in this game. Time to go back and re-read the rest, methinks.

[cicero]

What's kind of sad (for me, at least) is that I really have been reading, but I can't seem to find scum. Mike's townness is still useful info, but I don't really have much to go on, currently. And noone is making a case against anyone(apart from the lame "rogueben isn't contributing") either.

That wasn't my case on Rogueben and still isnt. People voting Rogueben for not contributing are ignoring both his meta and his limited internet access and should unvote. People who want to go back and read what I wrote are free to do so.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

That raises an interesting question. Is it still a strawman if the real position is even dumber?

[cicero]

If you have a better one against someone, I'm all ears. It's the best I see at the moment. Other than that feel free to go at Ooba for the Fonz stuff, I guess.

[Rogueben]

Hey guys.

I'm really sorry I haven't posted in a while. I currently only have access at uni (posting from a friends place atm) as my access has been cut off at home due to a banned IP address.

I'm talking to JEEP about fixing this, I'll try and catch up tomorrow.

[Thesp]

CLAIM. NOW. You can worry about catching up later.

[Kison]

.
.
.
.
.
!.......!

Hi!

Kison had a response written up last night and can no longer find it. This is bad news. But not too bad, since it was short.

I'm no fan of folks who continually say they'll post something and never do. Rogueben, what the hell, man! You're on the chopping block. Throw a penny or five.

Oobalooba, I'm not really sure what the frak you saw in your Fonz suspicion, but even in my possessed state of mind, I do not see it. Mind rephrasing that one for me?

I still hold grudges against UA for not supporting the Thesp testage. Also, where is Primate? He get shipped back to the animal shelter?

[Lawrencelot]

Rogueben's latest post is something he posted in all his game if I'm correct. We may not like it, but I guess it will take some time before we hear his claim. So we can: a) pile up votes on him so that he will claim when he comes back. b) switch to another wagon in the meantime, and don't forget that he needs to claim.

Unvote Rogueben; Vote: Mikeburnfire

[The Fonz]

That's a really bad vote, given recent developments. What's your rationale?

[Rogueben]

I'm a little confused as to why mike is town? Can someone explain that please?

I'm really sorry for the lack of posting, but without access at home I have very limited time to post.

I am Art Garfunkel - Mason with Paul Simon.

I know that my partner is town, but I'm not going to say who it is.

[Thesp]

I think this is worth confirming at this point and outing his partner, while I think I know who his partner is (if he's not lying). What do you all think?

[UltimaAvalon]

I still hold grudges against UA for not supporting the Thesp testage.

I didn't mind testing Thesp, it was the manner in which we tested it that I opposed.

I think this is worth confirming at this point and outing his partner. What do you all think?

Not really. I don't even find him as scummy as you guys seem to. Getting him to claim is one thing, outing his Mason Partner just seems a bit too aggressive

[Iammars]

I think this is worth confirming at this point and outing his partner. What do you all think?

Not really. I don't even find him as scummy as you guys seem to. Getting him to claim is one thing, outing his Mason Partner just seems a bit too aggressive

The whole point of masons is that their claims are testable. What's the whole point if we don't test them?

[cicero]

Yeah. Once you reached this point you pretty much have to test it. It's also interesting that there's a second mason pair in the game. I thought that was unusual in games, but I suppose there's no rule against it.

It sucks when masons get outed before endgame but when you end up up near lynch that's what has to happen.

But it isnt up to Rogueben to out his partner, imho. It's up to his partner to claim if he wants to save Rogueben.

At least I think this is how these things are traditionally handled. Am I wrong?

[The Fonz]

Note that Scope claimed a mason-like role, and was not tested, and subsequently found to be lying.

[ooba]

Oobalooba, I'm not really sure what the frak you saw in your Fonz suspicion, but even in my possessed state of mind, I do not see it. Mind rephrasing that one for me?

It had to do with Fonz's behavior in Twilight day 2 after guardian scum outed erg0 scum. All that 'Feed fish,lets not believe Guardian - Look at the scum talking' - seemed to be Erg0 defending to me

If you notice , i did not push for Fonz's lynch today since i went back and re-read those parts.

I would like Rougeben's mason partner to reveal themselves..

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

I have some trouble buying a Garfunkel-claim. I doubt Stoofer is so creatively impaired he couldn't come up with a better mason pair than Simon and Garfunkel. They're kind of old and forgotten.

Partner confirmation is necessary here.

[Lawrencelot]

I agree that Rogueben's partner should confirm. If it really is a 2-man group like hasdfgas and Gorrad, then we could lose a mason and a townie in a way of speaking, instead of 1 mason and keeping a townie. But there's a good chance that he's lying.

Note that Scope claimed a mason-like role, and was not tested, and subsequently found to be lying.

And that's also a good point.

That's a really bad vote, given recent developments. What's your rationale?

I wanted to see CESs, MBFs and other's reactions. I did not think MBF was town like CES said. But now Rogueben's claim came earlier than I expected:

Unvote

.

[Thesp]

Note that Scope claimed a mason-like role, and was not tested, and subsequently found to be lying.

There was a substantially different reason with Kaleidoscope for not testing his.