The Hobbit Mafia - GAME OVER

[the silent speaker]

MOL, why are you quadruple posting the letter K?

[MMCL]

My bad, you are correct Yaw.

Unvote

as I am going to bed and there has been no counter claim yet.

[PeaceBringer]

well I want to leave my vote where it is for the moment-

in particular given the lack of moves.

[CoolBot]

And your evidence is the lie you posted above?

Where did I lie? Did you not vote jedi early, unvote late, and revote when it was clear no one else was being lynched? These are the facts my interpetation is based on; I'm not lying about them. Why are you so eager to paint my words in the worst possible light.

Peace, lack of moves? What do you mean by that?

[Yaw]

I already pointed out where your revisionist history was off. The details of what happened do not support your version of the events. I voted jedi early, then unvoted and revoted

well after

it was clear nobody else was being lynched. I unvoted well after he made that ridiculous role claim. I only unvoted because some people had yet to post, and others seemed lynch happy enough to want to end the day before they could. In order to get your interpretation of events, you have to shift the timeline of what actually happened. That is, what you are insinuating is that I unvoted when the bandwagon got up to around 3-5 votes, when in fact I unvoted when the bandwagon was at 11 votes, there had already been a roleclaim, and it had been abundantly clear for days that jediknight was being lynched. So yes, what you posted was false. I'm concerned that you're clinging to the false information, instead of admitting you misremembered or were misinformed.

[MMCL]

"Stuck in the middle with you..."

FOS: Yaw and Coolbot

- whether for show, of because it is genuine, this fued needs settling. I'm gonna vote one or the other today but I haven't decided which.

[CoolBot]

Yaw, waiting at the point you unvoted was pointless. Any lurker coming out would've just pointed out how scummy jedi was. Any scum posting would've just pointed out how scummy jedi was. The only possible result to drawing out the day was to allow jedi a better chance at talking his way out of the bandwagon.

[meaning of life 42]

ok, i'm gonna jump in here now. i think both of you might be mafia. This whole big argument could be a diversion to lead us off the trail that u 2 might be maifa. by fighting, your trying to show you hate eachother, when really you 2 are probably mafia family. hmmm..............i wounder if that could be true...............i also

FOS: Yaw and CoolBot

nice call MMCL 8)

[Yaw]

Sheesh. It took 8 days to complete day 1, which was plagued with lurkers and inactives. At least getting people here and posting means they're contributing, which means there's posts to analyze. Besides which, jediknight wasn't going to talk himself out of that bandwagon. Even when I unvoted, I never stated otherwise than that jediknight was scum, and was the right person to lynch that day.

Also, you're continually avoiding my question. When exactly

were

you planning to go after the lurkers? Were you planning to go after them at all, or did you prefer to just let them ride the game out?

FOS: meaning of life 42

, for not having an original thought this entire game, despite spamming. He's now my most suspicious among active players.

Mod, where are the replacements already?

[meaning of life 42]

Ok, i know i am kinda againest Yaw right now, but i do agree with him, where are the replacements? I mean, i just joined, and i really want to see this game move at a little bit of a faster past, even if that means we have to lynch lurkers, i'm fine with that. ohh, and i won't be on over the weekend, so don't lynch me or think i'm a lurker.

[Internet Stranger]

I still say we weed off the lurkers.

[mikehart]

Murk and id replaced

[Uraj45]

Vote: MOL42

. You're anxiousness to agree with everyone is just too much. Seems like you're trying to stick with the side with the most momentum.
I think Coolbot is pretty much cleared at this point, except for the fact that we haven't heard from the replacements.

[PeaceBringer]

And your evidence is the lie you posted above?

Where did I lie? Did you not vote jedi early, unvote late, and revote when it was clear no one else was being lynched? These are the facts my interpetation is based on; I'm not lying about them. Why are you so eager to paint my words in the worst possible light.

Peace, lack of moves? What do you mean by that?

meaing that nothing has happened- no movement-

[Jaylen]

I still say we weed off the lurkers.

I'm starting to think this way as well, despite my vote on MOL42. I agree that the reason that there were no deaths last night must mean that the Mafia are idle/not reading the thread.

I simply cannot believe any other explanation for it... The chances of so many Doctors (if that many exist) protecting all the correct targets are astronomically small.

The thing is, which (ex) lurker to go for? It is not as if there have not been only a few of them, we are spoiled for choice.

I'll

unvote: Meaning of Life 42

despite him seeming scummy to me, while I take a re-read.

[Yaw]

The thing is, which (ex) lurker to go for?

May as well go up the list in terms of how bad they were lurking. Since Djinn was the worst, we'll get a defense/claim from lulu, and if that works out we can move on to Murk/Argoti. I'd need a reread myself to determine who is worst after that -- probably Gaspode, but he's also up for replacement at the moment. Hopefully we'll hit something before we get that far.

[Argoti]

Well, I just got back home so, I got my role. I did read through a bit, and I'm gonna go through again to make sure I got everything. I'll post again this evening.

[Jaylen]

Vote: lulu muumuu

- Let the (ex) lurker explain what has been going on.

[Uraj45]

. . .That's absurd. What do you want her to say: "Well, let me try to explain what the person I'm replacing was doing".
The best we can get from any of the replacements is analysis of other people's behaviours and judge based on that.

[lulu muumuu]

hi y'all, replacement checking in....
give me a chance to read through and hopefully i can find something interesting

[Jaylen]

. . .That's absurd. What do you want her to say: "Well, let me try to explain what the person I'm replacing was doing".
The best we can get from any of the replacements is analysis of other people's behaviours and judge based on that.

It will not be absurd if we push her to a role-claim - then we as a collective can take a long hard look at the claim, and take it from there.

I'll admit I could have phrased it better, however.

Either way, have you any better ideas as to what to do? I think Yaw and Coolbot are worth keeping an eye on, and maybe an investigation, but I agree with IS (and others) when stating that going after the lurkers seem the best tactic to use.

After all, have you (or anyone else) got a better explanation as to the lack of kills last night, apart from the fact that the mafia are lurking/not reading the thread?

If so, please say so - but as I see it, putting pressure on lurkers is the best way to go from here.

[Internet Stranger]

I just want this day to end.

[Yaw]

We're at 9 votes of 11. I agree with Jaylen -- a defense for lurking isn't going to do any good in this situation, because we have evidence that scum have been lurking. We really need a role claim.

[Argoti]

I believe that I'm up to the block, since I replaced ID...

I'm the Chief of the Wood Elf Guards.
It says I capture anyone who enters Mirkwood at night and hold them in the prison until daybreak. Essentially, I'm a roleblocker.

I have yet to block anyone since ID has been gone all game long.

[Yaw]

No. According to the front page, you're replacing Murk, Argoti. Lulu muumuu is replacing IndenturedDjinn.