In post 5333, Nero Cain wrote:
So? Changing one's mind isn't necessarily scummy. My g/f changes her mind like every 30 seconds, is she scum?
yeah probably. lynch her and see if she flips red.
The thing is that when it was an issue earlier you insisted it was one way and now when it would benefit 4!scum to have the town thinking they can mislynch freely (aka, believing there's 3!scum), you're saying "oh no it's totally probably Not the way I insisted. I insist I was wrong."
it's not the worst thing in the world but like,
c'mon.
In post 5333, Nero Cain wrote:
IaI, both you and Whiskers keep pointing out the similarities between this and a newbie game-me question is-you are using the 3.5:1 ration for newbies but why is that a better indicator of the setup than the 4.6:1 in a large 17 player normal?
erm, did I say something about a newbie game? I probably did.
iirc i compared the ratio of town:scum and compared the power level of the town PRs.
two ICs are a nice fat bonus to town. JK with no chance to block a townrole is a Doc+, it's even stronger than a usual JK.
Like mostly I'm looking at the JK as the big power role in the room. It's not a cop but why would you even allow a cop and a doc in the same setup together?
In post 5336, I Am Innocent wrote:Whiskers not ignoring you either. Need to get back to my notes to see your early posts which I didn’t like. I do remember not liking your back and forth with Joey, and especially hated your newbie defense of nauci when they first entered the thread, esp after ur earlier newbie <> town hypocritical comment. Also felt there were many associative tells between you, beeboy, and nauci, tho I have to see if those still hold water for you and beeboy now that nauci flipped town.
Gonna remind you that the "newbie hypocritical" stuff was UC defending himself going "I'm noob! I'm noob! No shoot!" and then me defending Nauci by going "She's kinda noob, no shoot yet."
It's like trying to clear
yourself
by
self-
meta vs someone
else
clearing you with your meta.
Plus, for the record, we still haven't lynched UC.
In post 5336, I Am Innocent wrote:And yes, I think there is merit when so many people scum read a player yet they are impossible to lynch. See the speed of naucis wagon as a counter example
(psst, that's scum waiting for town to drive the inevitable wagon on a universally scum-read townie.)
And frankly, as I said, I wouldn't be impossible to lynch if you or anybody would make a case on me.
....Maybe not
anybody
, Axel kind of did already.