Newbie 152 - Game Over

[Flying Dutchman]

And night falls without a lynch.

It is night 3.
Choices deadline: Thursday 9 AM GMT.

(I'm setting pretty quick deadlines to keep this game moving. However, mafia, if you need more time to discuss feel free to request an extension.)

[Flying Dutchman]

The sun rises again, and you all move to the town square. All of you? No, the mafia appears to be killing again! Thok is found shot through the head in his home.

Thok, Townie, killed night 3.

It is day 3.
With 5 alive 3 is enough for a lynch.

[Thok]

Bah! Go town!

[ibaesha]

Well, I there's bad news and good news. The bad news is obvious, we're down another townie. The good news is, it's my birthday! And for my birthday I caught scum. We can celebrate by lynching him.

vote: Marbak

[Tyfo]

Well, I'm positively sure that ibaesha is townie; because -

I'll take the chance and Roleclaim: Doc. The night that no-one died, I protected her.

I'll

vote: Marbak

. The scenario we have before us is;

1. We will lynch Marbak; if he is scum then we have a pretty good chance of catching the other the next day as I'll probably end up dead in the morning, and it would be two versus one.

2. We lynch Marbak; He is townie and we lose the game.

3. We lynch other; Scum, same scenario (but nearly instant win).

4. We lynch other; Townie, lose.

[ibaesha]

Well, I only see one option appropriate for today and that's lynching Marbak. I'm positive he's scum. I'm not sure about anyone else as Thok was who I investigated night 1. I expect (hope) we'll have some discussion before someone places a final vote on Marbak though.

[Narninian]

hmm, interesting. If Ibaesha is scum, she took a pretty big gamble. She's have to hope that
a) She was protected night 2. If this is the case, obviously the no-kill plan was designed to fool us
b) Marback was not proctected night 2.

Since, scum CANT know this, I tend to believe Ibaesha. Obviously there should be more discussion before the game ends, however. Did you think about claiming at all yesterday Iba?

[ibaesha]

Yes, I considered claiming yesterday to get doc protection, but decided against it since I didn't have a guilty result. I couldn't be positive that there was a doc (mafia no kill scenario) and felt that giving information yesterday going into a no lynch would benefit the mafia more than the town.

[Tyfo]

Btw, if the mafia made a no-kill N2 and ibaesha is scum, we're pretty much doomed.

But I tend to believe ibaesha anyway;

that leaves whether Kia or Narninian are scum.

[Marbak]

Okay guys, ibaesha and Tyfo are our scum here.

How do I know? Cause Tyfos not the doctor, I am. I protected ibaesha the first night (yeah, oops on that).

So why the lack of a kill the first night then?

The way I see it they chose not to kill anyone to set up this very claim.

They were two people who were pushing for a quick No Lynch vote yesterday, evidentially so they could go ahead and kill someone, then claim today, so Tyfo could go “Whoops, I protected the wrong person tonight, but I’m doctor, really! Oh well, look, ibaesha (who I handily can corroborate because the night no one died I ‘protected’ her) found scum, lets lynch im!”

If Ibaesha is scum, she took a pretty big gamble. She's have to hope that
a) She was protected night 2. If this is the case, obviously the no-kill plan was designed to fool us
b) Marback was not proctected night 2.

This is obviously much less of a gamble if ibaesha and Tyfo are partners.

If I could vote for both of you, evidently I would.

Vote: ibaesha

[ibaesha]

You make a major mistake in your observation there, scum. (Actually more of a LIE, and we know what we do with liars, don't we?) I didn't push for a 'quick no lynch' in any way whatsoever. Refer to yesterday where I stated no lynch was the best scenario for the town. I also stated that I would like to hear from you and Kiarlea before the day ended. Also, you were the first person to actually vote no lynch, whereas I didn't even get an opportunity to post again before the day ended.

Did you even pay attention yesterday, or are you just trying to morph what happened, hoping no one will actually go back and read it? Narninian suggested no lynch as an option. Tyfo jumped on his case about it. Thok supported the no lynch scenario and so did I. Tyfo then back-pedaled and actually made a case for it himself. Following that, Kiarlea basically said 'I guess' and you... you actually place the first vote towards a no lynch.

At any rate, no lynch WAS the best case for yesterday. I am the cop and you ARE scum.

[Narninian]

I dont know if I made it clear, but I didnt really wanna talk about it, yesterday i WANTED the day to end pretty quickly. As the day grew longer scum would have a better and better chance of figuring out who the doc was. This would not have been a good thing.

[ibaesha]

I understand where you were coming from yesterday, Narninian, and in fact agree with it. The point I was trying to make in my last post is that Marbak is saying I pushed for a quick no lynch when, in fact, I did not. Even had I wanted to, it was done before I got back to post again. Anyways, I already know Marbak is scum, however, his last post is proof that he's also a liar.

[Kiarlea]

Sorry guys, I'll post in the morning, passing out here.

[Flying Dutchman]

Vote Count (3 to lynch):

Marbak: 2

(ibaesha, Tyfo)

ibaesha: 1

(Marbak)

Not voting: Narninian, Kiarlea

[Narninian]

me too (on the passing out).

[Kiarlea]

Sorry Marbak, but it make too much sense, especially with your last post. You've been awfully odd all through, rushing to say this and jumping to say that, overly aggressive and eager. Your claim sounded extremely copycatted (though if Tyfo hadn't claimed already, I suppose it might not have been as bad.)

I'm holding off voting till Narn posts, but if he's got nothing to say to turn my attention elsewhere, I'll vote Marbak.

[Narninian]

The thing that worries me is there is TWO scum..

Everybody is all for the marback wagon right now, so that means if he is scum, his parter is right there. Who might that partner be? If its Ibaesha its a very clever ploy -- gratz on that but I dont think thats the case, If its Tyfo, then the doc hasnt counter claimed which is doubtful, so that leaves Kiarlea as scum.

Vote: Marback

Obviously, tyfo you should protect Ibaesha. Ibaesha you should obviously investigate me or Kiarlea.

the 2 problems are
A) If Marback is telling the truth we lose right now, but that means both scum outed themselves as power roles which I find risky, and wouldnt do myself -- I dont think that we're gonna lose by lynching marback

B) If Ibeasha and Marback are partners, we're screwed.

[Flying Dutchman]

And with that, Marbak is lynched. Luckily for the town, he was scum,

Marbak, mafia member, lynched day 3.

It is night 4.
Choices deadline: Tuesday 1200 GMT.

(But since there won't be any scum conversations I'd like to have all choices in 24 hours from now, if possible... So we can start day earlier.)

[Flying Dutchman]

You all awake and move to the town square. Immediately you see another person is missing. It's Tyfo. You all move to his house, and you find him in his living room, lying on the couch. Half of him, that is, his other half is in small pieces in the kitchen........

Tyfo, Doc, killed night 4

It is day 4.
Only 3 people alive, so 2 is a majority. Good luck!

[ibaesha]

vote: Kiarlea

[Narninian]

could you at least say who you investigated last night?

[ibaesha]

I investigated Kiarlea. She's scum.

I'll be happy to explain more (why I investigated Marbak and Kiarlea) later. I've been vomiting my guts out for the last 6 hours or so.

[Narninian]

sorry :/

anyways - it seems pretty straight forward, but I see no reason to end the game without hearing from kiarlea first.

[Narninian]

/prod Kiarlea.