curiouskarmadog wrote:I guess he does have a point, cult or scum, who was trying to set up BM, would know once BM turned up Miller (or not cult) that his lie would be exposed, the next day he would surely hang. Now I can see this as an end game play, but I doubt we are at end game. This could a lyncher gambit (been fooled by lynchers twice now), again, it is a sad one....RC is just useless in general right now, but does he deserve to hang? This could also be a scum gambit between RC and BM...but that too seems far fetched especially with its execution...I need to think about this somemore and reread....it is not just RC's BM claim that bothers me..it is whole claim in general that seems made up as he went along that bugs the shit out of me....
Well tomorrow he has the "well he was a miller... I didn't know he'd turn up guilty for everything" thing.
And yes, it does seem as though he made it up as he went along. And people that just make claims and night actions up as they go along are rarely town.
TSPN" wrote:But again, I ask you: if he's scum, why claim that? BM's response is a "shrug, who cares," who can do better?
As scum he'd have a chance at a free lynch with a lot of room for excuses afterwards... Then he can "confirm" people as "not cult" afterwards and it is likely that at worst there is 1 culted player running around, so RC could survive for some time with this claim despite the mislynch.
But as town, why claim that? Rosso would have to be:
#1: Either not paying attention or certain that a miller wouldn't mess up his investigation.
#2: Damn forgetful to completely forget he made an investigation N0. Or that he could even make one.
#3: Alphabetically challenged.
Now if you believe Rosso could play that badly as town, I don't see how you think his play as scum
must
be logical or even good.
------------------
Animorpherv1 welcome to the game, please give an opinion or say something other than "Vote RC".
[url=http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?p=414662#414662]Damnit, Nemesis.[/url]
