Mini #537 Happy Tree Friends Mafia - Game Over

[KaleiÐoscøpe]

Good morning everyone!

Yes, everyone!

Everyone is alive!

Yay!

It is now Day 3. With 8 players living, it is 5 to lynch.

[JDodge]

vote: Roffman

[kuribo]

vote: Roffman

That's odd... I'm not quite sure why you would vote for someone that's been dead for 2 days now... hmmm.

[Phate]

Vote: pacone

[ZONEACE]

Vote Phate

your defense of Sens yesterday was so pathetic. you failed at concealing your scum nature. You should have given up and bussed, it may have kept you from dying today.

[JDodge]

vote: Roffman

That's odd... I'm not quite sure why you would vote for someone that's been dead for 2 days now... hmmm.

can't we kill him again

unvote, vote: Phate

[competentpsycho]

Vote Phate

your defense of Sens yesterday was so pathetic. you failed at concealing your scum nature. You should have given up and bussed, it may have kept you from dying today.

My suspicion of Phate has been obvious but this case makes very little sense. Sens was a mafia spy - the mafia didn't know who he was and would have to find him, but with only N1 available for them to do that, it is unlikely that they did. Besides that, I don't see Phate being that stupid. On the other hand if the mafia didn't know he was a mafia spy, they may have tried to support him in an obvious lynch situation like that since they thought he was town, pointing at it later as proof of being pro-town. That is kind of WIFOM, but if I were scum and that was the situation that is the way I would have played it. I'm gonna hold my vote for now because the only argument that would make sense for Phate's actions to be scum is a little WIFOM.

[JDodge]

Vote Phate

your defense of Sens yesterday was so pathetic. you failed at concealing your scum nature. You should have given up and bussed, it may have kept you from dying today.

My suspicion of Phate has been obvious but this case makes very little sense. Sens was a mafia spy - the mafia didn't know who he was and would have to find him, but with only N1 available for them to do that, it is unlikely that they did. Besides that, I don't see Phate being that stupid. On the other hand if the mafia didn't know he was a mafia spy, they may have tried to support him in an obvious lynch situation like that since they thought he was town, pointing at it later as proof of being pro-town. That is kind of WIFOM, but if I were scum and that was the situation that is the way I would have played it. I'm gonna hold my vote for now because the only argument that would make sense for Phate's actions to be scum is a little WIFOM.

Methinks you know too much.

Unvote, vote: competentpsycho

[ZONEACE]

JD, Ryan was an Idiot, NOT scum. Can't we just lynch phate or pac and get rid of another scum?

[Phate]

ZONEACE, where exactly did I defend SensFan again? I recall saying that the case didn't make much sense, then someone pointed out JDodge's breadcrumb, and I disagreed with its validity, pointing out the possibility of a NK. Then JDodge noted that "Hid in wrong house" was

not

indicative of a NK, so I conceded the point and voted for him.

[ZONEACE]

you tried to discredit JDs breadcrump prrof a couple of times despite it being IRON CLAD. I was suspicious of you before that, that just made me sure you're scum. As a side note I'm slightly less suspicious of Pacone than i was, but something has to be done about him. He's definitely paying attention to the game is his refusal to participate is not good. especially if he is town.

[Phate]

you tried to discredit JDs breadcrump prrof a couple of times despite it being IRON CLAD. I was suspicious of you before that, that just made me sure you're scum.

I don't think I have to explain to anyone else how much these 'reasons' fail.

I wish you were scum, but I think you're just retarded.

[competentpsycho]

Vote Phate

your defense of Sens yesterday was so pathetic. you failed at concealing your scum nature. You should have given up and bussed, it may have kept you from dying today.

My suspicion of Phate has been obvious but this case makes very little sense. Sens was a mafia spy - the mafia didn't know who he was and would have to find him, but with only N1 available for them to do that, it is unlikely that they did. Besides that, I don't see Phate being that stupid. On the other hand if the mafia didn't know he was a mafia spy, they may have tried to support him in an obvious lynch situation like that since they thought he was town, pointing at it later as proof of being pro-town. That is kind of WIFOM, but if I were scum and that was the situation that is the way I would have played it. I'm gonna hold my vote for now because the only argument that would make sense for Phate's actions to be scum is a little WIFOM.

Methinks you know too much.

Unvote, vote: competentpsycho

You mean MBF knows too much: http://mikeburnfire.sitesled.com/mscumB.swf

Actually, looking back at this I think I mixed this up a little. When I first read it it seemed like the mafia would have to "find" the spy, but now that I reread it it seems like they just tell the mod when they want to recruit him. I think the recruit part made me mix it up with mason a little. The argument still holds since the spy would become a normal mafia member if recruited, but still flipped Mafia spy. Also, scum would want to recruit later so that there is a better chance of the spy having been investigated before being recruited, and thus the cop thinking he was town. Sorry about the mixup but the argument is still valid, scum shouldn't have known that Sens was the mafia spy and instead thought he was town. I am leaning toward the thought that Phate was just not reading thoroughly, but that doesn't clear him by any means.

[ZONEACE]

you tried to discredit JDs breadcrump prrof a couple of times despite it being IRON CLAD. I was suspicious of you before that, that just made me sure you're scum.

I don't think I have to explain to anyone else how much these 'reasons' fail.

I wish you were scum, but I think you're just retarded.

thats cute, but it doesn't make you any less scum

[Phate]

Zone, go look up the role "Mafia Spy". By definition, it is a member of the Mafia, but the catch is: the other mafia members don't know who it is. In light of that, explain to me why your argument still makes sense.

And when you can't, apologise.

For your existence.

[ZONEACE]

you're still scum, regardless.

[competentpsycho]

you're still scum, regardless.

Proof? Or are you just emulating JDodge?

[ZONEACE]

Ive thought he was scum for a long time i stated i was suspicious of him when i joined the game and his actions yesterday just firmed it up for me.

[competentpsycho]

Also, I would like to hear from Holy Rigel and Pacone. Where did you guys go?

[Phate]

Well, in that case, would you care to tell me why you're suspicious of me?

Also, psycho, his playstyle is hardly "emulating JDodge". Perhaps BattleMage.

[ZONEACE]

Also, I would like to hear from Holy Rigel and Pacone. Where did you guys go?

where did pacone go? HE WAS NEVER HERE. his posting has been pathetic.

[ZONEACE]

edwop

and its not him ignoring the game, or fogetting, he's clearly paying attention, day and night.

[Phate]

Well, in that case, would you care to tell me why you're suspicious of me?

What makes you say that he's "clearly paying attention, day and night"?

[competentpsycho]

Well I was just bringing attention to the fact that none of them have posted day 3 at all. I'm not saying any of them participated all that much so far, but pacone is definitely suspicious because he said he would participate after day 1 since there would be more that happened - well shit has happened - time to post something.

[ZONEACE]

Well, in that case, would you care to tell me why you're suspicious of me?

What makes you say that he's "clearly paying attention, day and night"?

ill tell you later.