Open 189~Trouble@Warren State Mental Hosp (Over)

[JDodge]

I was surprised at this. You thought I came off badly in our exchange? I assumed you realised how difficult it is to answer those questions without looking scummy, so I thought the best strategy was to run through several layers of town thought (which would be harder for me to do as scum.)

RED FLAG RED FLAG WARNING CAUTION WARNING

Unvote, vote: Xdaamno

Lovin' this wagon right now. Keep up the good squirm, Daamno.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Welcome aboard the Xdaamno wagon, JD.

[Xdaamno]

You know this is my meta JD >: /

[Xdaamno]

Buurgh. I wish I could edit that.

[DizzyIzzyB13]

DIESCUMDIE!

[JDodge]

You know this is my meta JD >: /

I don't like self-claimed metas. Fun fact is that the only meta I use is one's personality, and you hardly seem like the type to crack under pressure.

Buurgh. I wish I could edit that.

Fascinating.

[VP Baltar]

Xdaamno, how would you compare your play here to that of Amnesiac Mafia?

Cat, tajo, Qoog, Otto, and anyone else who hasn't really commented, what do you think of the daamno wagon?

[Hyl]

/confirm

[VP Baltar]

Hi, Hyl! Nice to see you.

what do you think of the daamno wagon?

[Hyl]

Nice to see you too. And everyone.

Vote: VP Baltar

Your question-filled posts, coupled with little follow up to said questions, are scummy. Gives off a strong "trying to look helpful & active" vibe. I also noticed that you didn't give much opinion on the wagon, yet you're asking everyone to comment on it.

I see more significance in Xdaamo vs. Vi than in the wagon itself. Xdaamno's explanation in #60 is a a little off in the context of barely serious votes.

And I wish Izzy would make a thoughtful post.

[populartajo]

Not the typical way of starting the game, although I expected something like this happening with someone. The thing is that I cant tell wether some people are being serious or not. Dodge and Vi seem serious while cayke and dizzy are prob just joking around. Correct me if im wrong.

Daamo's answers are meh, not remarkably scummy or townie. Basically the case is the "town layers" which is weird but less likely to be accepted for an hypothetic scum. So, mehx2.

Hey, baltar what do

you

think of the daamo wagon?

[populartajo]

Oh, I was kinda sarnathed.

[Vi]

Not the typical way of starting the game, although I expected something like this happening with someone.

Hai!

Daamo's answers are meh, not remarkably scummy or townie.

Which leans toward scummy in itself.

I like Hyl's post/vote, and not just because it's on our favorite perennial scum candidate.

[JDodge]

Your question-filled posts, coupled with little follow up to said questions, are scummy. Gives off a strong "trying to look helpful & active" vibe. I also noticed that you didn't give much opinion on the wagon, yet you're asking everyone to comment on it.

Occam's Razor - the simplest explanation is usually the correct one. Try again.

I see more significance in Xdaamo vs. Vi than in the wagon itself. Xdaamno's explanation in #60 is a a little off in the context of barely serious votes.

explain please

And I wish Izzy would make a thoughtful post.

And the people who haven't added anything?

I like Hyl's post/vote, and not just because it's on our favorite perennial scum candidate.

Is the weed you're on good or is it just some ditch weed?

[Vi]

I like Hyl's post/vote, and not just because it's on our favorite perennial scum candidate.

Is the weed you're on good or is it just some ditch weed?

This is the poor stuff. I save the goods for special occasions.
Really though, it's like VPB is going in circles around the elephant in the room.

I will concede that right now the historians are difficult to read because there are too many of them to be scum. But that's okay, because I've already found scum *huggles vote*

[JDodge]

I like Hyl's post/vote, and not just because it's on our favorite perennial scum candidate.

Is the weed you're on good or is it just some ditch weed?

This is the poor stuff. I save the goods for special occasions.
Really though, it's like VPB is going in circles around the elephant in the room.

But the elephant in the room isn't here, nor is the pig

I will concede that right now the historians are difficult to read because there are too many of them to be scum. But that's okay, because I've already found scum *huggles vote*

You used to be better at this, what happened?

[Qooq]

Cat, tajo, Qoog, Otto, and anyone else who hasn't really commented, what do you think of the daamno wagon?

I’ll be completely honest, this game has been pretty hard to follow because I am not sure how much is serious and how much isn’t. I’m not used this sort of pace. Correct me if I’m wrong but the Xdaamno wagon started with this:

/checks in

We're lynching you. Discuss.

I guess it’s hard for me to understand that you can you can get a really accurate read off someone by starting a discussion like this. It seems to me like an abstract question is going to get an abstract answer (that is the way I read Vi’s remark, an abstract way to try and scumhunt). I guess I just don’t see the logic in attaching a lot of meaning to the response. Of course you can try to catch someone in their words and make them squirm later on, but where did the line of questioning begin?

Right now I’d like to reserve judgment on Xdaamno. Post 60 obviously concerns me because I agree with Vi's logic about it (post 68), but I’m not convinced he’s scummy yet. I’m reading Vi town right now though, if it means anything.

Your question-filled posts, coupled with little follow up to said questions, are scummy. Gives off a strong "trying to look helpful & active" vibe. I also noticed that you didn't give much opinion on the wagon, yet you're asking everyone to comment on it.

Occam's Razor - the simplest explanation is usually the correct one. Try again.

JDodge, why did you feel the need to respond to a statement directed at VP Baltar?

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Nice to see you too. And everyone.

Vote: VP Baltar

Your question-filled posts, coupled with little follow up to said questions, are scummy. Gives off a strong "trying to look helpful & active" vibe. I also noticed that you didn't give much opinion on the wagon, yet you're asking everyone to comment on it.

I see more significance in Xdaamo vs. Vi than in the wagon itself. Xdaamno's explanation in #60 is a a little off in the context of barely serious votes.

And I wish Izzy would make a thoughtful post.

There's no such thing as a thoughtless post. Why aren't you voting fo Xdaamnoscum?

[DizzyIzzyB13]

Nice to see you too. And everyone.

Vote: VP Baltar

Your question-filled posts, coupled with little follow up to said questions, are scummy. Gives off a strong "trying to look helpful & active" vibe. I also noticed that you didn't give much opinion on the wagon, yet you're asking everyone to comment on it.

I see more significance in Xdaamo vs. Vi than in the wagon itself. Xdaamno's explanation in #60 is a a little off in the context of barely serious votes.

And I wish Izzy would make a thoughtful post.

There's no such thing as a thoughtless post. Why aren't you voting for Xdaamnoscum?

EBWOP. But still, a vote for Xdaamno is a pro-town vote.

[tubby216]

****************vote count****************

xdaamno

~ (4)L-3 ,crywolf,Vi,DizzyIzzy,Jdodge

VP Balter

~(2) L-5, populartajo,Hyl

Jdodge

~ (1) L-6, VP Balter

populartajo

~(1) L-6 HowardRoark

not voting

xdaamno,Otto Ulbreicht,Qooq,Cat

with 12 players alive its 7 to lynch

deadline 29 days remaining

[VP Baltar]

I also noticed that you didn't give much opinion on the wagon, yet you're asking everyone to comment on it.

Oh, I have an opinion on it (which I'll get to here in a second), but I didn't know we're on a mandatory disclosure policy. Are we? No one asked my opinion, and I was gleaning much more information by not stating it.

Hey, baltar what do you think of the daamo wagon?

My opinion is probably closest to yours. While I do think some of his answers have been a bit off and overly self-aware, I'm uncertain if he's scum. He seems much too openly confessional for an early game scum.

When he and I played together in EK's Amnesiac Mafia he made some similar errors of putting his foot in his mouth and I greatly exploited those as scum to get an early mislynch on him (I'd post a link, but the thread was deleted as part of the game mechanics).

I like Hyl's post/vote, and not just because it's on our favorite perennial scum candidate.

you would.

I’m reading Vi town right now though, if it means anything.

Really? Why's that? I don't think many people could get confident reads by page 4.

@Dizzy-who are Xdaamno's scumbuddies?

[HowardRoark]

Xdaamno's post 60, post 77 & post 78.

unvote
vote Xdaamno

The thing is that I cant tell wether some people are being serious or not. Dodge and Vi seem serious while cayke and dizzy are prob just joking around. Correct me if im wrong.

Trying to derail the wagon?

I am not sure how much is serious and how much isn’t.

(See comment to populartajo above)

I don't think many people could get confident reads by page 4.

If you play with another player often enough, it sometimes becomes that easy,

[VP Baltar]

Unvote, Vote: HowardRoark

If you play with another player often enough, it sometimes becomes that easy

And how often have Qoog and Vi played together would you say?

[HowardRoark]

I have no idea if Qooq and Vi have played any games together. I've never played with JDodge, yet I see him as town right now. So where does that put us?

[VP Baltar]

Well, you're scum, so I think you have an unfair advantage at the town reads game.

Also, if you have no idea how many games they have played together, then how can you make a value judgement that it'd be easy for her to have a read on Vi based on past experience?