Mini 1023 - City Watch Mafia - Game Over!

[Tasky]

Vote: Jimfinn

That's a weird reaction to a RVS wagon.

could you restate that "weird" reaction in your own words and explain why ["weird" = scummy?]



I understand RVS-bandwagoning, but 5 votes with 7 to lynch is definitely to much on page 3... so UNVOTE:

VOTE COUNT

jimfinn (4): Plum, Chronopie, FakeGod, VasudeVa
FakeGod (2): TheButtonmen, Thor665
Thor665 (1): KHG
Tasky (1): Budja
TheButtonmen (1): Mysterio

Not Voting (3): Narsis, jimfinn, Tasky

With 12 alive, 7 votes are needed to lynch.

[molestargazer]

@VasudeVa, TheButtonmen:

Sorry, they're going to stay edited in. They're at the top of every page, they're just as easy to find. This way means they're more consistent, rather than just "When I feel we need one". Also means I keep following the game consistently to pick up things like this.

[TheButtonmen]

Also, my vote counts as two votes. @jimfinn YOU DUN GOOF'D

But I won't bring the hammer down with you at L-2.

Vote: TheButtonmen

VOTE COUNT

TheButtonmen (1): Mysterio

Mysterio mind explaining?

[Mysterio]

Super sketchy.

Your comment at jimfinn is that he goofed up which reads to me like you know his aligment (goof'd as opposed to scummy).
Secondly since you stated a wilingness to vote Jimfinn then said you found my attack on him suspicious as he is obvnewb, explain the dissonance there?

Careful. You're skirting pretty close to OMGUS.

The comment toward jim was a joke. Notice how I mentioned my vote counts as double, and he was L-2. I could have brought the hammer if I were a huge douchebag, hence the joke. Thus, there is no dissonance. My suspicion of you is the only reason for voting. I would like you to explain why you thought jimfinn was changing his opinion unreasonably? And also why you felt the need to make multiple posts defending Thor?

Mysterio mind explaining?

Is this a serious question? Obviously, the mod isn't going to reveal my power in a vote count. Have you never played a game with someone who had a double vote?

[TheButtonmen]

Super sketchy.

Your comment at jimfinn is that he goofed up which reads to me like you know his aligment (goof'd as opposed to scummy).
Secondly since you stated a wilingness to vote Jimfinn then said you found my attack on him suspicious as he is obvnewb, explain the dissonance there?

Careful. You're skirting pretty close to OMGUS.

I would like you to explain why you thought jimfinn was changing his opinion unreasonably? And also why you felt the need to make multiple posts defending Thor?

I already explained where I felt Jimfinn displayed what I found to be a fair amount of cognative dissonance. Also mind quoting the multiple posts where I defended Thor?

Is this a serious question? Obviously, the mod isn't going to reveal my power in a vote count. Have you never played a game with someone who had a double vote?

The mod isn't going to reveal your double voting power on the vote count?

Every other game I've played with double voters they have shown up as having two votes (hence them being double voters)

[Tasky]

Obviously, the mod isn't going to reveal my power in a vote count. Have you never played a game with someone who had a double vote?

so are you really claiming double-voter or is it some sort of joke? if it's a joke, stop it. if you are seriously claiming, explain why you would claim so early, I could see no reason to do so.

[KHG]

Is this a serious question? Obviously, the mod isn't going to reveal my power in a vote count. Have you never played a game with someone who had a double vote?

I don't understand. If your vote actually counts double, it's the most logical thing

to

have it appear in a vote count. Unless my irony detector is off.

And, is the double vote the power of "CHARISN'TMA"? In which case Mysterio would be Cpl. Nobbs?

I'm not saying these questions should be answered as of yet; just getting them out there...

[Chronopie]

What Tasky said. Claiming DV this early just paints a target on your back.

Also, ftr: I played a game not too long ago in which the DV was recorded as a DV. (Although Nikanor had to actually type: Vote: Person x2) Here's a VC

[Mysterio]

I already explained where I felt Jimfinn displayed what I found to be a fair amount of cognative dissonance. Also mind quoting the multiple posts where I defended Thor?

That doesn't explain anything, considering you just linked the very same post that I cited to Thor. It seems to me jimfinn's post was in line with what he was arguing from the start, given his response in post #47. So, at this point I'm trying to understand what made you conclude that he was being unreasonable when he acknowledged that the reason for voting was a "null tell", but not the vote itself? Your answer will help me figure out what point of view you're approaching the game from.

Also, why do you need me to quote your own posts? Posts #39 and #46 which you linked earlier are the ones I'm referring to.

The mod isn't going to reveal your double voting power on the vote count?

Obviously, not. As that would have given away both my power and my RC. Also, there may be other reasons why the mod didn't add it to the vote count, and trying to outguess the mod is stupid.

I don't understand. If your vote actually counts double, it's the most logical thing to have it appear in a vote count. Unless my irony detector is off.

And, is the double vote the power of "CHARISN'TMA"? In which case Mysterio would be Cpl. Nobbs?

The bolded line answers the first line. And yes, I'm Corporal "Nobby" Nobbs. Don't stare at my boils, please.

so are you really claiming double-voter or is it some sort of joke? if it's a joke, stop it. if you are seriously claiming, explain why you would claim so early, I could see no reason to do so.

That part wasn't the joke. I am indeed a double-voter. And I claimed as a way to give town some valuable information, but also to see what reactions I could pull from the other players. There is a special "catch" to my power, but I'll reveal it after I gauge a few more reactions.

[FakeGod]

One of the games I'm finishing up in had a double voter who didn't appear in the Vote Count.

In my opinion, Mysterio should've experimented with votes a bit first to see what kind of DV mechanic was in place.

And, is the double vote the power of "CHARISN'TMA"? In which case Mysterio would be Cpl. Nobbs?

I made the connection right away, but I wasn't gonna say anything in fear of revealing more info to the mafia.

Preview: O never mind.

[FakeGod]

I don't understand. If your vote actually counts double, it's the most logical thing to have it appear in a vote count. Unless my irony detector is off.

And, is the double vote the power of "CHARISN'TMA"? In which case Mysterio would be Cpl. Nobbs?

The bolded line answers the first line. And yes, I'm Corporal "Nobby" Nobbs. Don't stare at my boils, please.

And.....apparently that's how our DVoter outed himself in 4 pages.

I would prefer if we stopped any more speculations about roles/powers/mechanics/etc.

[Thor665]

@Tasky - you commented that the jimfinn wagon got too big too quick. Do you believe this is because of people being dumb, overeager, or having that wagon scum pushed?

Also, why no new vote yet?

@FakeGod - 'hey guys, let's stop discussing roles so early (ignore the fact that the only reason it's happening is because someone chose to claim and don't address that aspect)' <---trying to act towny. (oh boo-hoo, "our" DV is outed).

Moar wagon for win please.

[Tasky]

And.....apparently that's how our DVoter outed himself in 4 pages.

how can you be sure Mysterio has the same alignment as you?

@Tasky - you commented that the jimfinn wagon got too big too quick. Do you believe this is because of people being dumb, overeager, or having that wagon scum pushed?

I think the townies on the wagon didn't realize where it was going. since I don't know jimfinn's alignment I can't really say if the wagon was scumdriven or not.

Also, why no new vote yet?

right... we are still in RVS, aren't we?
VOTE: Chronopie for being first of the player list.

[TheButtonmen]

Unvote; Vote: Trasky.

[KHG]

I would prefer if we stopped any more speculations about roles/powers/mechanics/etc.

Care to explain why?

Unvote; Vote: Trasky.

Any explanation? Random vote?

[KHG]

Also, we can assume that Mysterio won't have this power tomorrow.

[TheButtonmen]

Every vote I make is serious.

[KHG]

Every vote I make is serious.

"Serious" meaning what? That's not an explanation for your vote.

[TheButtonmen]

Serious meaning not random.

[FakeGod]

@FakeGod - 'hey guys, let's stop discussing roles so early (ignore the fact that the only reason it's happening is because someone chose to claim and don't address that aspect)' <---trying to act towny. (oh boo-hoo, "our" DV is outed).

(raises eyebrow) alright, if you want to discuss powers/roles/mechanics, go right ahead.

Only reason I said it is because (in the broadest sense) I think I figured out how this Mini Theme game is going to work (and couple other info), but I'm not sure whether the mafia did. Hence me discouraging discussing powers/roles/mechanics.

And.....apparently that's how our DVoter outed himself in 4 pages.

how can you be sure Mysterio has the same alignment as you?

No one cc'd him, and I was assuming Col. Nobbs is town-sided.

But that

is

a good point.

Unvote; Vote: Trasky.

There's no one named Trasky though....

[Chronopie]

VOTE: Chronopie for being first of the player list.

And I'm first on the playerlist, because I pm pre-/in'd the second I saw This game in the Upcoming Games thread. I mean, Sam Vimes has the balls to arrest a Dragon...

[Narsis]

Vote: Narsis

for not posting yet.

oh wait a minute...

Unvote

[Plum]

UNVOTE: jimfinn

VOTE: Narsis

Attempts to be casual, jokey; ignores everything that's gone on, even the chance to acknowledge that stuff has happened for a complete nothing. He doesn't even end up with a vote on anyone.

In other news, analysis of the past page or two coming soon.

[Narsis]

UNVOTE: jimfinn

VOTE: Narsis

Attempts to be casual, jokey; ignores everything that's gone on, even the chance to acknowledge that stuff has happened for a complete nothing. He doesn't even end up with a vote on anyone.

In other news, analysis of the past page or two coming soon.

you fell right into my trap!

seriously...you did. i have a hard time getting into games that already had stuff going on and none of it was directed at me. at least on mafiascum...


so you want to know my thoughts? well tbh i got nothing but nulls right now.

[Plum]

This makes me feel little better about you, to be honest.