Mini 1039 Lost: Season One (Over)

[jasonT1981]

The only issue I have is that if the game is true to the show, name claiming could give away town power roles.

[Dekes]

I want a name claim from dekes. It's important. Just a name claim.

What Faraseradayaphim said (is there a an option to abbreviate this without offending one of you?).

I watched every episode of Lost mutliple times and I cried on two occasions. So yeah, you could say, I'm somewhat interested in this show.

Vote: Amedisk

for never having watched Lost and yet thinking he'll be doing fine.

[Dekes]

EBWOP: Sorry, Ademisk, of course

[chesskid3]

What if 2-3 people who have seen the show put together a list of 12 main characters from season 1, and anyone _not_ on that list had to explain?

[dramonic]

That has got to be the silliest idea ever posted.
How are people who haven't seen the show supposed to explain anything?
Also, Reck prolly supplied fakeclaims to the scum.

[Faraseradayaphim]

More to the point if we're scum why the fuck aren't you voting for us?

Actually, brother dearest, he is voting for us. His random vote just happened to be on us.

On another note, my Lost knowledge is minimal. I watched two episodes of the first season. Like my other half, I am against name-claiming. I feel like, in most games, name-claiming will only give away power roles, especially some of the more obvious ones. Also, if scum don't have fakeclaims, I will lol.

What if 2-3 people who have seen the show put together a list of 12 main characters from season 1, and anyone _not_ on that list had to explain?

No. That's absolutely silly.

If you have a dayvig, have fun, if not I won't be endorsing this wagon unless he does something scummy.

Hey, dram, do you consider this scummy?

Watched a lot. But missed some episodes.

I want a name claim from dekes. It's important. Just a name claim.

Is this blatant rolefishing scummy?

Also, HH, I'm interested: why the chainsaw on Vezok? You've played with him before. You know how terrible a player he is. So why the chainsaw defense?

Also, I'm shocked and appalled at the number of people ignoring our proclamation of the policy lynch on vezokpiraka. The people ignoring it are definitely being anti-town by not reading the game.

~Seraphim

[jasonT1981]

Im interested in lynching scum based on in game evidence. not on policy due to other games in the past that have no bearing on this game.

[Ademisk]

FaraSera, why do you insist on a policy lynch for Vezok? I've never played with him, and I don't think everyone else did either, so maybe you can explain your intent on killing Vezok regardless of his role in this game?

[dramonic]

Vezok isnt a good policy lynch.

[xRECKONERx]

Faraseradayaphim (1): HackerHuck
vezokpiraka (1): Faraseradayaphim
chesskid3 (1): jasonT1981
jasonT1981 (1): chesskid3
Ademisk (1): Dekes

Not voting (7): dramonic, BloodCovenent, TheLonging, jenniwren, vezokpiraka, MagnaofIllusion, Ademisk

12 alive, 7 to lynch.

[vezokpiraka]

I have role related information to want dekes to claim name. It's obvious I won't claim what it is.
Also how can you out PRs by name claiming?
It's not like John has to be pr and Jack too and Sawyer too and all of that people. Also this is vanillaless if I remember correctly.

[chesskid3]

Vezo, If you were for example Jack Shepard ---obv doc is obv

[vezokpiraka]

If you say so.
I still want Dekes to claim. I promise it won't put PRs in danger.

[Faraseradayaphim]

ROLE RELATED INFO? Forgive me if I don't automatically a) trust you to be town and EVEN if you were town I don't think I trust you 100% to work in the best interests of the town with this info.

[Faraseradayaphim]

Also of course I can't think of any pro town role off hand that would need to know a specific player in the game's role name to help them. It seems to be a very odd piece of information to be after.

[vezokpiraka]

I actually have a good reason to want Dekes to claim.
I am day name-cop. I targetted Dekes with my ability. I picked him at random and I really want to see something.
Do you understand why I want him to name claim?

[Faraseradayaphim]

Vezok isnt a good policy lynch.

Cool. Is he scummy though? you didn't answer that question a few posts before you put by Sera.

EDIT: Yes, he should probably go ahead and claim now actually. Why did you target dekes and why this early in the day?

[vezokpiraka]

I really wanted to use my ability cause it's a day ability and I act on impulse.
Check out Sunny in Philadelphia game RECK hosted. I was a day vig and my first post day vigged someone. I like to use day abilities because there is always the possibility of day vigs.

[Faraseradayaphim]

That's some really horrible logic right there.

I'd also be interested in getting a nameclaim from you. At this point you've already outed your role so there's no downside to it that I can see. A scum name cop's also not impossible Sera thinks so we want you to get everything out there. If that all fits then we think Dekes should claim.

[chesskid3]

Vezo should nameclaim after Dekes, in any case.

[vezokpiraka]

I'm Boone Carlyle.
I am going to out him without a claim.
Dekes is Ethan Rom. He probably has a fake claim. Let's wait to see what he tells us.

[chesskid3]

Oh man I see your point about names not implying roles now. Since when I think of Boone, I think 'haha what a nub', not 'wow that guy has amazing deductive powers'

[Faraseradayaphim]

AH. VEZOK. Ethan's fucking obv scum. Like he's the scummiest character and main big evil of season 1.

I really can't see Dekes being town.

Unvote Vote Dekes.

[Faraseradayaphim]

You should have waited vezok, I think but spilled milk and all that.

[chesskid3]

oh ya I forgot to vote.
UNVOTE:
VOTE: Dekes

Random remarks:
Farady/Seraphim, your avatar is Ethan.
Also @Faraday You're the one who told him to claim, I said claim after Dekes, but nobody listens to poor chesskid.