Open 269: Multirole Mafia: Over. Town Win

[chesskid3]

CN, why does that semi-serious question any more likely to come from scum? Explain.

[implosion]

Chevre voting Chesskid for making a pressure vote that doesn't pressure is weak...

especially

when there was already a wagon on chesskid. Just because he did something that doesn't achieve the purpose of pressuring, doesn't make him scum. Also, others have brought up how the vote still pressures the target (albeit not as much).

Unvote, vote: Chevre

.

Go go competing wagons!

[JesseSheffield]

I'm not going to pretend like I have anything to add here. The only thing that strikes out to me is that chesskid seems like a total jag and I doubt I'll be listening to anything he has to say.

[Chronopie]

The second Vote Count of Day One

Chesskid3

(3): Andrew, Akira, Chevre

Chevre

(2): gandalf5166, implosion

implosion

(1): ThAdmiral

ThAdmiral

(1): Chaotic Neutrality

Akira

(1): Chesskid3

With

12

alive, it takes

7

to lynch

[Akira]

@chesskid: So there is a reason? In that case, tell me why you think I'm scummy or your vote will have no meaning at all.

Well put, Jesse.

[Chaotic Neutrality]

Because the target of crappy psuedo-not random votes early on D1 is always town?

Haha. You're funny. Town(

I doubt scum would make a claim this ridiculous

), but hilarious.

Bolding mine. I'm sick of hearing this as a justification for blatant scum tells. That logic is

disgusting

. Don't do it.

Why would I vote someone easy to get a be on if I don't think they're scum?

For pressure?

CN, why does that semi-serious question any more likely to come from scum? Explain.

It's because you seriously suggested lynching him on policy. Policy votes are notoriously anti-town, and andrew hasn't even done anything yet.

VOTE: chesskid

[chkflip]

I'm not going to pretend like I have anything to add here. The only thing that strikes out to me is that chesskid seems like a total jag and I doubt I'll be listening to anything he has to say.

I'm not going to pretend like I don't think this is scum trying to float through the first few pages.

VOTE: JesseSheffield

[JesseSheffield]

How much of your scum analysis is based on the first few pages flip?

[smashbro_of_the_SSS]

Vote: ThAdmiral

His avatar actually intimidates me. That's a first.

last game i played as scum against him, and it always freaked me out.




also, i'm going to

vote: chesskid

to start. Not particularly liking his idea of a policy lynch, also, something interesting in ISO.

Nah, gandalf is town in this one.

I wouldn't mind some dead gandalf.

so, chesskid. reasoning behind this?

[gandalf5166]

7 minutes in between? >.>

[Sleepless Assassin]

Ok, so Chesskid and Smashbro are scum. Akira and implosion are town.

Vote Chesskid

To anyone with a problem with L-1 this early, suck it.

I've seen a few chesskid games where he says stupid shit and I'm thinking "the guy's obvtown" while he's being attacked. This isn't one of those games.

[smashbro_of_the_SSS]

why am I scum?

[implosion]

Hm. This bandwagon is quite explosive. At any rate, chesskid needs to get in here and defend himself.

[This is not a hammer threat]

[JesseSheffield]

I don't think chesskid is scum so none of you can expect a hammer from me. I think he's moronic town, running his mouth off because he thinks he's going to run shit when instead he's made himself an easy target and shot his credibility to hell. I think Neutrality is the most likely scum on the wagon. His vote was largely under the radar, with craptastic reasoning, and slid through everybody's expectations because it rides so easily on top of the rest of the wagon.

[ThAdmiral]

I'm not going to pretend like I have anything to add here. The only thing that strikes out to me is that chesskid seems like a total jag and I doubt I'll be listening to anything he has to say.

I'm not going to pretend like I don't think this is scum trying to float through the first few pages.

VOTE: JesseSheffield

Using his own words against him. Lol.

Ok, so Chesskid and Smashbro are scum. Akira and implosion are town.

Yay! Yet another person who says "these people are scum and these people are town" and provides no reasoning why. I'm loving this trend in mafia; it makes games more skill based and fun! (THAT WAS SARCASM)

[chkflip]

How much of your scum analysis is based on the first few pages flip?

On D2 onward? Not very much at all, but when we're at P5 D1? That's all I've got to go off of.

I, too, would like to hear more from Chesskid.

It's notable, to say the least, how Sleepless is very vigilant in his L-1 placement; no matter what he says, however, I will

not

suck it.

gandalf, do you think it would be less worthwhile of a tell if it took him longer than seven minutes to opinion-flip like that?

[chesskid3]

Hmmm yeah I'm on vacation.
There's 1 scum voting me.
2 off the wagon.

ThAd is scum.

Someone hammer me.

[Chronopie]

The Third Vote Count of Day One

Chesskid3

(6): Andrew, Akira, Chevre, Chaotic Neutrality, smashbro_of_the_SSS, Sleepless Assassin [L-1]

Chevre

(2): gandalf5166, implosion

implosion

(1): ThAdmiral

JesseSheffield

(1): chkflip

Akira

(1): Chesskid3

With

12

alive, it takes

7

to lynch

Flavour added to the OP

[ThAdmiral]

Why the wagon in the first place. I sort of missed it being put together.

I am usually against wagons this early as there is normally something fishy about them.

[Chevre]

JesseSheffield, who is your top suspect and why?

Sleepless Assassin, I would really like to hear why you believe smashbro to be scum.

[gandalf5166]

VOTE: chesskid

I realize he's on vacation, but if he has time to do that, he has time to explain his opinion-flip.

[chesskid3]

[quote="chesskid3"]Hmmm yeah I'm on vacation.
There's 1 scum voting me.
2 off the wagon.

ThAd is scum.
this still applies.

should be an easy win now

[chesskid3]

hmm maybe not
gandalf is a good vig shot
but a bad lynch
ThAd is a good lynch

[Chaotic Neutrality]

I think Neutrality is the most likely scum on the wagon. His vote was largely under the radar, with craptastic reasoning, and slid through everybody's expectations because it rides so easily on top of the rest of the wagon.

I provided a small case in addition to my vote, which I believed to be pretty bold and out there. I'm sorry you felt it was under the radar. The reasoning for my vote was semi-craptastic, but this early in the game there really isn't any good reason for a vote. Besides that, I meant to lay my vote on him in this post, but I neglected to.

By the way, you seemed to miss smashbro's vote which was thrown out very weakly for the two contradicting posts about Gandalf (which, compared to the other stuff chess has pulled, is relatively insignificant). Oh, and you forgot SA's vote with weak meta reasoning, if you can even call that reasoning. SA also blatantly put chess at L-1, opening him up to Gandalf's "absentminded" hammer. The two former votes were just after mine, and the latter seriously looks like a staged accident. How is my vote scummy and under the radar, while theirs slips right under your nose?

[Chronopie]

The Final Vote Count of Day One

Chesskid3

(7): Andrew, Akira, Chevre, Chaotic Neutrality, smashbro_of_the_SSS, Sleepless Assassin, gandalf5166

Chevre

(1): implosion

implosion

(1): ThAdmiral

JesseSheffield

(1): chkflip

Akira

(1): Chesskid3

With

12

alive, it takes

7

to lynch

--

You're all so sure of yourselves.

"All day?" Gandalf sneers, "We don't need all day. We got scum, right here. Haul 'em up boys."

It's not long before Chesskid is dangling from the rafters, gurgling and gasping for air, while the rope brutally crushes his windpipe.

Soon enough, it's all over. You lower his body to the ground, confident that he was the one you were after, the killer in the shadows.

Confidence turns into horror, as, after emptying his pockets, you find that he doesn't even carry so much as a pocket knife, let alone the butchers knife needed to make that kind of a hole in the mayor.

Chesskid3, VT.

Was lynched Day 1

--

It is now Night 1, all actions are required within the next 72 hours.