Cthulhu Speed Mafia (Finished)

[TwoHeadedBoy]

To be clear, my "scummy play" has been pointing out that I was wary of posting first because I always suspect the person who posts first?

- Trying to use your meta to excuse scummy play.
- Pseudo-defending another player for no raisin.
- Lying about reasons for voting another player.
- Overreaction to the deaths.
- Attempting to discredit my case on you by concentrating on a single point and making it look silly.
- Said point wasn't even a part of my case (you corrected me; leading to point two above).

PEdit: k.

I get a strong townread from EP's single post so far. Fugi isn't on IRC at the moment, so I'm assuming he's either asleep or busy.

What's your opinion of Cobbler?

~Pie

[Empking]

Vote Count 3

2. vezokpiraka
3. bobsnox (3) - vezokpiraka, Amrun, TwoHeadedBoy
4. Ant_to_the_max (1) - tarsonisocelot
5. RaudhrGarm
6. Nachomamma8
7. Twistedspoon (2) - Ant_to_the_max, Energetic Penguin,
9. Cobblerfone
10. C-Worl (1) - RaudhrGarm
12. TwoHeadedBoy (1) - Cobblerfone
13. tarsonisocelot
14. Stels
15. Amrun
16. Energetic Penguin (2) - Twistedspoon, bobsnox

Not Voting: Nachomamma8, Stels, C-Worl

[Nachomamma8]

Vote: Empking

Specifically to get on TS's nerves.

[Nachomamma8]

I KNOW!

I was scared about posting first because I thought I might die if I did so >_>

So do we skip the RVS in this game and just start arguing right away?

What do you mean? Like random game mechanic that you die as first poster? Do you really need to ask that question?

You seem nervous from this post and scum are generally the only people who need feel that way.

Fos: Ant

I KNOW!

I was scared about posting first because I thought I might die if I did so >_>

So do we skip the RVS in this game and just start arguing right away?

lol people always suspect me day one until they get used to my style, so I figured I'd have at it.

I don't know how you start arguing if no one has said anything, so I don't know about skipping RVS. For now I'm definitely going to

VOTE: Stels

to see what reaction I get

I find it odd that you would need to tack on that rider of "to see what reaction I get". Isn't that the commonly accepted reasoning behind random votes?

just got the PM

Energetic penguin

I have a new RVS policy of voting those players with the best or most interesting usernames

anyways, serious now

looking at the dead list we must have a real mafioso threat considering a watcher, a cop and 2 masons are already dead.

I'm trying to think of a connection between the roles that could determine the mechanic. :/
Any ideas?

This post is full of worthless content and your others talk about leaving the RVS but do nothing to actually make it happen.

VOTE: Twistedspoon

idugd

NEVERMIND.
SCUM CAUGHT ON PAGE 3.
GOGOGOGOGOGO.

Vote: Energetic Penguinscum

[Stels]

VOTE: Energetic Penguinscum Nacho logic wins.

[Amrun]

What is idugd?

[tarsonisocelot]

VOTE: Energetic Penguinscum Nacho logic wins.

Could you explain Nacho-logic to the unenlightened? Or is this just a D1 randomness thing?

[Nachomamma8]

What is idugd?

Me smashing my keyboard in anger at Penguin's scumminess.

VOTE: Energetic Penguinscum Nacho logic wins.

Could you explain Nacho-logic to the unenlightened? Or is this just a D1 randomness thing?

Stels is town.
I am town.
I peg scum.
Stels helps me lynch them.

Logic ends there. If you want actual reasons, why I suppose it wouldn't hurt to ask...

[tarsonisocelot]

What is idugd?

Me smashing my keyboard in anger at Penguin's scumminess.

VOTE: Energetic Penguinscum Nacho logic wins.

Could you explain Nacho-logic to the unenlightened? Or is this just a D1 randomness thing?

Stels is town.
I am town.
I peg scum.
Stels helps me lynch them.

Logic ends there. If you want actual reasons, why I suppose it wouldn't hurt to ask...

What are your reasons? How do you know that Stels is town? Why should I believe that you are town?

I assumed that Nacho-logic referred to some kind of logic behind your suspicions not to some voting agreement.

[Ant_to_the_max]

Bad argument is bad argument.
But basically what I said would be bad is what TS said and you pointed out.

Erm. What?

~Pie

Sorry. First part was reasoning for defending Bob. I claim that what he said didn't fit what you were accusing him of.
I then wanted to point out what TS said fit more for your accusation.

As for Nacho, could your pwetty pwease explain your logic? I think I see what you are thinking. Just want you to confirm it for yourself.

And dang it...forgot to mention it earlier, but just refer to me as Ant

[vezokpiraka]

Nacho sheep

unvote
vote penguin

[Cobblerfone]

BTW, I like how Cobbler's vote on us is a countervote - didn't point it out earlier because I forgot my other head moved our vote. Noted for later though. Not sure if I find Cobbler scummy or not, but I've certainly got my eye on him.

And your vote wasn't on me because of something I said about you? You know that didn't happen. You didn't vote for me because I attacked you, you voted for me because you thought my post was scummy. Likewise, I didn't vote for you because you voted for me, I voted for you because I thought you'll be confusing. Though you do seem to be getting better at organizing yourselves. Keep it up, and you just might see my vote get taken off of you.

[Stels]

@lololololfunnypeople: Wow... Just wow. He caught scum, and a good enough reason. If you can't see it, you are blind. I like how you guys freak out at my first vote.

[tarsonisocelot]

@lololololfunnypeople: Wow... Just wow. He caught scum, and a good enough reason. If you can't see it, you are blind. I like how you guys freak out at my first vote.

What an incredibly helpful and enlightening post...

[TwoHeadedBoy]

BTW, I like how Cobbler's vote on us is a countervote - didn't point it out earlier because I forgot my other head moved our vote. Noted for later though. Not sure if I find Cobbler scummy or not, but I've certainly got my eye on him.

And your vote wasn't on me because of something I said about you? You know that didn't happen. You didn't vote for me because I attacked you, you voted for me because you thought my post was scummy. Likewise, I didn't vote for you because you voted for me, I voted for you because I thought you'll be confusing. Though you do seem to be getting better at organizing yourselves. Keep it up, and you just might see my vote get taken off of you.

This post is paranoid and appeal-y

---

@lololololfunnypeople: Wow... Just wow. He caught scum, and a good enough reason. If you can't see it, you are blind. I like how you guys freak out at my first vote.

What an incredibly helpful and enlightening post...

While I agree that it wasn't helpful in the slightest, I usually only see townies being that big of dicks to other people.

---

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Cobblerfone

I want to see Penguin's response before our vote hits him, right now Cobbler is by far the scummiest scum in this thread.

~Fugi

[TwoHeadedBoy]

@lololololfunnypeople: Wow... Just wow. He caught scum, and a good enough reason. If you can't see it, you are blind. I like how you guys freak out at my first vote.

What an incredibly helpful and enlightening post...

---

[01:57:49] <Fugitive> what is idugd?
[01:57:55] <iPie> good question
[02:09:35] <Fugitive> I really wish people wouldn't use acronyms that can't be looked up on the wiki
[02:10:33] <iPie> inb4 it was just random letter-mashing

» Fri Apr 22, 2011 3:09 am
"Me smashing my keyboard in anger at Penguin's scumminess." - Nacho

inafter

~Pie

[Stels]

@lololololfunnypeople: Wow... Just wow. He caught scum, and a good enough reason. If you can't see it, you are blind. I like how you guys freak out at my first vote.

What an incredibly helpful and enlightening post...

What a sweet compliment.

You monster.

[C-Worl]

Unvote; Vote: Penguin

Nachosheep

[C-Worl]

BTW, with 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

Penguin is at L1

[vezokpiraka]

Hey. Don't you dare steal my lines C-worl.

Also GlaDoS pwns noobs. And Wheatley.

[Ant_to_the_max]

@C-Worl: how many games have you played with THB?

Still waiting for Nacho as well

[C-Worl]

@C-Worl: how many games have you played with THB?

Still waiting for Nacho as well

Played 1 with THB. Have played 3 or 4 with Nacho.

[Energetic Penguin]

This post by Bob makes little sense.

Just got the message.
That's a lot of N0 deaths, more than I would expect from just scum or scum + SK. Could some of them have targeted a Paranoid Gun Owner?

No reads yet so VOTE: Ant_to_the_max.
Was there any particular reason that you thought posting first was dangerous? If yes, are there any other things we should be wary of?

I'm always suspicious of the first person to post/question the previous night's events, so I'm wary of posting first. That's probably what ATTM meant.

You're suspicous of the first person to post or the first one to question the night's events? You did both of those, yet you claim you're wary of doing such. There's no reason to defend him either. If he's town he should be able to explain himself.

[quote="bobsnox]Not liking the EPenguin nitpicking. I see scum do that all the time early in the game. It's actually the reason I was voting Stels (seen it from Stels before).

UNVOTE: Stels

VOTE: Energetic Penguin[/quote]I can buy that you think nitpicking is a scumtell. Voting stels for that reason doesn't make any sense because he hasn't posted yet and it sounds like this may be something he does out of personality.

To be clear, my "scummy play" has been pointing out that I was wary of posting first because I always suspect the person who posts first?

If so, that's crap. But it's Day One so I expect crap I guess.

Well I think you should drop the idea that posting first is a scumtell. It makes no sense and you run into oddities like suspecting yourself.

@lololololfunnypeople: Wow... Just wow. He caught scum, and a good enough reason. If you can't see it, you are blind. I like how you guys freak out at my first vote.

What freakout? Only one person responded to your vote. As for this "good reason", how is anyone to decide if its good or not if they aren't told what it is? Just because you think you've noticed it doesn't mean you call other people blind.

@People voting for me: What's the reasoning?

[C-Worl]

@People voting for me: What's the reasoning?

You're scum.

[TwoHeadedBoy]

@People voting for me: What's the reasoning?

You're scum.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: C-Worl

Can we please have mutilvig shots?

~Fugi