Return to Gambits (SK Win!)

[Nocmen]

Curious to see what you think of my meta.

[Empking]

Vote Count 3

Cobblerfone
DeityKabuto
TheJakalope
Nocmen
TheMask (1) - CryMeARiver
Monk
Surye
CryMeARiver (3) - sorasgoof, Surye, Sathoris,
jilynne1991 (1) - Cobblerfone
vezokprika
Sathoris
earworm
C-Worl (2) - vezokprika, earworm
Wredfar
Ironhead
sorasgoof

Note Voting: DeityKabuto, TheJakalope, Nocmen, TheMask, Monk, C-Worl, Wredfar, Ironhead, jilynne1991

With 16 alive, its 9 to lynch.

[jilynne1991]

A meta means nearly nothing, so I don't think that's a very good question. Anyways, I've never played with you, so I don't think anything of your meta.

[CryMeARiver]

The only reason I meta'd Nocmen was to check the validity of this statement:

Ooh previous dislikes and drama.

On a sidenote, why did you come in to only leave this comment? No RVS vote?

I don't know any of the players at all in this list. So I don't have any past grudges to go against.

As it turns out, the only time he RVS's is when he has played with the player in the past.

[Cobblerfone]

I'm sorry, but I just do not like participating in RVS, I'll be fencesitting until I see something that is worth mentioning or catches my eye.

A meta means nearly nothing, so I don't think that's a very good question. Anyways, I've never played with you, so I don't think anything of your meta.

It's like me voting for you is me voting for myself. I can't let this RVS vote stand any longer.

UNVOTE: jil

[Nocmen]

A meta means nearly nothing, so I don't think that's a very good question. Anyways, I've never played with you, so I don't think anything of your meta.

I was asking cry mainly, due to he said he got a meta read on me from it. Which I agree with his meta assement of myself lining up with my meta.

what I don't like from him though, is post 45.

[CryMeARiver]

I'm sorry, but I just do not like participating in RVS, I'll be fencesitting until I see something that is worth mentioning or catches my eye.

A meta means nearly nothing, so I don't think that's a very good question. Anyways, I've never played with you, so I don't think anything of your meta.

It's like me voting for you is me voting for myself. I can't let this RVS vote stand any longer.

UNVOTE: jil

You are town as well.

[jilynne1991]

Who is town as well...Cobbler?

[CryMeARiver]

Who is town as well...Cobbler?

Yes. That was a very protown post.

[Cobblerfone]

Pro-town post? I hardly did or say anything. I may be newer than you but, here's some tips:

1. Don't decide if a person is scum or town based on a single post.

2. Scum can be/fake pro-townishness.

I'm loving the easy going nature of the game so far. Shame it'll probably change soon.

[jilynne1991]

What do you mean by easy going nature? Cobbler, why would you tell someone they might be wrong if they say you're pro-town. I don't quite understand that.

[CryMeARiver]

Pro-town post? I hardly did or say anything. I may be newer than you but, here's some tips:

1. Don't decide if a person is scum or town based on a single post.

2. Scum can be/fake pro-townishness.

I'm loving the easy going nature of the game so far. Shame it'll probably change soon.

You changed an RVS vote based on someone having similar play to yours. Therefore you see that the other person could be town as you know that you're town (hypothetically). That is definitely protown.

I didn't decide that you were town. Your post was protown.

I am well aware of the fact. I am indeed not a dumbass.

What do you mean by easy going nature? Cobbler, why would you tell someone they might be wrong if they say you're pro-town. I don't quite understand that.

Unwanted buddying. Scum can buddy town.

[Cobblerfone]

You changed an RVS vote based on someone having similar play to yours. Therefore you see that the other person could be town as you know that you're town (hypothetically). That is definitely protown.

So that's you're logic? I was expecting that it would have more to do with RVS. I don't know why.

What do you mean by easy going nature? Cobbler, why would you tell someone they might be wrong if they say you're pro-town. I don't quite understand that.

Easy going? Well I haven't done a head count, but not an awful lot of people have been really posting yet.

I didn't understand why he thought that post in particular was pro-town. (I think if anything it's townish not pro-town. But eh, semantics.) Him saying, "You are town," without really explaining why piqued my interest. (and I'll admit, pipped my scumdar a bit.)

[sorasgoof]

Alright, there's a lot of meta going on here. Let me add something to the mix.

Last time CMAR pulled something like he did in post 45 (very ambiguous, hinting at possible power roles?), he was scum (Sherlock Holmes mafia). Doesn't mean anything as far as this game goes.

I've never used meta as the basis of ANYTHING. I go into each game with a clean slate, and I offer this clean slate to every other player. I never "research" other players.

So, everyone just forget meta.

[CryMeARiver]

Alright, there's a lot of meta going on here. Let me add something to the mix.

Last time CMAR pulled something like he did in post 45 (very ambiguous, hinting at possible power roles?), he was scum (Sherlock Holmes mafia). Doesn't mean anything as far as this game goes.

I've never used meta as the basis of ANYTHING. I go into each game with a clean slate, and I offer this clean slate to every other player. I never "research" other players.

So, everyone just forget meta.

Eh? I didn't hint at me being a power role in this game...

[sorasgoof]

Eh? I didn't hint at me being a power role in this game...

I took this:

if people keep pressuring me on the first page business, it will result in the claims of more than one person.

the wrong way then.

[CryMeARiver]

Eh? I didn't hint at me being a power role in this game...

I took this:

if people keep pressuring me on the first page business, it will result in the claims of more than one person.

the wrong way then.

Claims /=/ Me being a PR

[The Mask]

HI SORA!! Hi, jilynne. I miss the days when I'd play in a cluster of games. And HI other people who don't know me. You should cool it with the buddying, CMAR.

MOD: may the cops self investigate?

I don't have an RV on deck but I'm wondering why vezok hasn't claimed yet. hehehehe. I'll wait for CMAR to unvote so I don't look omgusy..... what???

[Ironhead]

Like jilynne, I prefer being deliberate with my vote, even in RVS. However, I think there is enough interaction to be confident in my vote.

VOTE: earworm

because I disapprove of unjustified bandwagoning in RVS. It's too easy for a scum to fly under the radar by casting a bandwagon vote on someone they know to not be scum and not have to come up with a convincing explanation.

[wredfar]

/confirm
gonna catch up

[TheJakalope]

This game certainly got started quickly. I skimmed the thread, nothing major jumps out, I'll try to get some reads later, but CMAR, who appointed you the man who decides who is town or not? Especially when you are making these judgements from very few posts. This isn't very scummy of you, just.. questionable.

[jilynne1991]

I actually don't see anything wrong with CMAR, but being able to make judgements that quickly make me think one of two things: 1) he might be really good at this game or 2) he's a loudmouth who should stop making assumptions so quickly.

[earworm]

Like jilynne, I prefer being deliberate with my vote, even in RVS. However, I think there is enough interaction to be confident in my vote.

VOTE: earworm

because I disapprove of unjustified bandwagoning in RVS

. It's too easy for a scum to fly under the radar by casting a bandwagon vote on someone they know to not be scum and not have to come up with a convincing explanation.

Really.

You want justified bandwagons in RVs? If I had a justification it wouldn't be a RV.

/theoryrant
I like bandwagons in RVs because occasionally they provide enough pressure and/or spark discussion in a way to end RVs. My vote is much better used on someone who already has a vote, then just lay it down on someone who doesn't have any, or worse keep it in my pocket.
/endrant

[jilynne1991]

Earworm seems to be a smart played, but he's still a null read at the moment for me.

[jilynne1991]

EBWOP, I meant player