Mini 1190: Game over

[SleepyKrew]

Why should a miller wait to claim?

[Hoppster]

I don't think scum would make a mistake like SK did.

Do you not feel that SK's post felt like an over-eager rush onto the wagon?

[Empking]

Especially given that Empking's initial vote for CC seemed semirandom, and between that and the FoS on me, it seemed to have solidified. Empking, why did you claim so fast?

1. I think I'm a semi-likely Cop investigation and didn't want to waste a lynch and investigation.
2. To get us out of the RVS.
3. Just to inform you, its the done thing nowadays. The choice was mostly instinct.

Preview
Hoppster: Possibly but I think overeagerness in the RVS is a null/town tell.

[Captain Corporal]

"Idiodic town"... I like the sound of that.

Also, to answer Hoppster's question, I believe the miller claim is a null tell.

P-EDIT: They shouldn't, imho, Sleepy. That's what I was getting at when I said "Nice roleclaim".

Also, as long as we're out of RVS, UNVOTE:

[SleepyKrew]

By "nice roleclaim", I mean "good job on claiming that straight-up".

They shouldn't, imho, Sleepy. That's what I was getting at when I said "Nice roleclaim".]

[Empking]

By "nice roleclaim", I mean "good job on claiming that straight-up".

They shouldn't, imho, Sleepy. That's what I was getting at when I said "Nice roleclaim".]

What are you getting at?

[SleepyKrew]

Tis a contradiction, no?

[Captain Corporal]

Is there a point to Sleepy's post?

P-EDIT: Oh. Nevermind. When I said "they shouldn't", I was reponding to Sleepy's question, which asked why should millers wait to claim. When I said "They shouldn't", I mean "They shouldn't wait to claim".

[Empking]

Yeah I agree with CC here.

[SleepyKrew]

Blargh.
UNVOTE:

[Captain Corporal]

I'm going to wait for some input from other.
In other words, I'm going to sleep.

So far everyone is null.

[SleepyKrew]

So my attack on you with shitlogic isn't scummy in the least?

[Sundy]

Hello people.

EST, town, Batman, and I forgot the last question

I don't even feel like doing a RVS since you guys jumped into action so fast.

[SleepyKrew]

VOTE: Sundy

[Empking]

Batman was the last question.

Sundy: What do you think of Sleepy's mistakes?

[Thomith]

I leave for a day and already 2 pages and we are out of RVS, something tells me this is more different to newbies than i imagined.
Anyway.

1. What timezone are you in? GMT
2. Scum or Town, which is more fun? Town
3. RVS or RQS? RVS
4. Batman or Superman (hint: Batman)? this is relevant how?

no really i can understand how the first 3 could help us but what is the 4th question there for? also tell me if i am understanding right, millers claim early so they don't mess up cop reports later in the game/ to reveal sanity, that is how i think miller claims are used anyway.
and seeing as it seems we are out of RVS i will hold back my vote for now.

[Toro]

VOTE: Sundy

This ain't random is it?

[SleepyKrew]

Absolute fluff. Do something.
PEDIT: No Toto.

[Sundy]

Well I kinda liked CC while everyone else was up in his face, so that's a mark against SK.

Having the initials SK is another mark against him.

Claiming that CC voted Miller-claim = not reading thread, making up case = bad. Looking for contradictions = possible genuine scum hunting? Calling his own logic "shit" and saying others should think him scummy for it = kinda town. Changing directions and voting for me = why?

I have a contradictory read ATM. SK looks like someone trying to be really aggressive and awesome with a slight hint of town despite himself.

[SleepyKrew]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Thomith
Thank you Sundy

[TBuG]

Thomith, any... y'know, opinions, speculation, anything useful...?

For now I'll chalk SK's mistakes up to simple human error and confusion, though he's kind of all over the place.

Why should a miller wait to claim?

I guess I was just misguided, it didn't make sense to me because, as scum, claiming miller instantaneously can deflect suspicion, and it will likely perplex my future read of Empking... Buttt in light of Empking's explanation it makes sense. That and the fact that I haven't played in a while so I should probably screw my head on a little tighter.

[Captain Corporal]

One last post Hello, Sundy, looking forward to playing in a game with you again!
Sleepy, I'm willing to give you the benefit of the doubt. Pressure isn't so bad.

P-EDIT: @Thomith: Lol, it was just for fun. Which, co-incidentally, is what we are meant to be having, and what the game is intended for.

P-EDIT: I agree with you on your "Bad logic admitted = slight town tell" point, Sundy.

P-EDIT: @Sleepy: What's up with voting Sundy and Thomith? Trolololol.

[SleepyKrew]

Makes em contribute.

[Thomith]

Awful questions they may be, but I still want everyone to answer =p

If even you think they are aweful questions, why ask them? I don't care about answering questions but if they won't help in the long run i dont see the point.

Sleepy did you read the thread before saying CC voted for the miller claim or even acknowledge who he voted for?

The EK claim seems town, as if i am understanding right a miller claims Day 1 so the Cop isn't hindered in the long wrong.

[SleepyKrew]

I did read the thread, and I misread CC.