Mini #537 Happy Tree Friends Mafia - Game Over

[competentpsycho]

Ok I have to read a couple of chapters for a final I have this morning, so just a few quick things:

1) I can see why ryan asked to be replaced - being attacked for previous games for a whole page seems retarded and un-needed.

2) I don't buy the morphine crap. Seriously, if I was on morphine in a hospital the last thing I would be doing is posting in a game here. As ryan has said, the unvoting because someone called you out on it seems really fishy. You explained your action as to get discussion going - seemed perfectly innocent to me. Nothing in your post pointed to being drugged up and out of it. Then you unvoted because of one vote on you after you explained using a perfectly good reason. For this I will

vote: roffman

3) Holy - your refusal to vote at first sticks out to me... the only other time I have seen this (posting in random vote stage in beginning but not voting) the person turned out to be scum. IGMEOY

4) Phate - that whole thing about the past games has NOTHING to do with this one and was completely pointless, unless you were just trying to get him to ask to be replaced so you didn't have to play with an "idiot and a tool". Seeing as how the only mafia-related thing in that big ass discussion was you trying to point at ryan here:

Vote: ryan

Roffman doesn't seem scummy to me. He seems like a newb. By comparison, your attempts to throw suspicion on him seem scummy.

Also, if you posted your role PM in a previous game, you must be either an idiot or a tool.

This reasoning is completely retarded. Come on, throwing suspicion on someone's suspicious behavior seems scummy? That's what we do in mafia. Have you even played before? Or are you using craplogic to try to seem to be contributing since you really can't "scum hunt" because you are scum?

BIG FOS: Phate

5) JDodge - I don't know why you would bring up the past game but that in itself doesn't seem scummy. The fact that you kept egging him on for something that was not related to this game seems like you are distracting from the game. I will be watching you closely as well.


Also, I HATE lurkers. You guys better start posting... that includes punkfairy or whatever your name is.

[pacone]

Jeez man, how am I supposed to have fun?

[competentpsycho]

Jeez man, how am I supposed to have fun?

What the hell are you talking about here?

[roffman]

Jeez man, how am I supposed to have fun?

did i miss a replacement or can random people post now?

[competentpsycho]

LOL he's actually in the game - just isn't contributing and makes posts like this that make no sense at all.

[kuribo]

Jeez man, how am I supposed to have fun?

Nice of you to join the conversation.

Why were you lurking?

[roffman]

ok, nice to know

[mildmanneredhero]

I have a feeling that competentpsycho is town. I don't think Ryan would let himself be replaced if he had a night kill. He could have just pushed for us to lynch Phate or JDodge and then killed the other. Of course, it's also entirely possible that this is all some sort of ridiculously elaborate plan. Unlikely, but possible I would suppose.

[kuribo]

I have a feeling that competentpsycho is town. I don't think Ryan would let himself be replaced if he had a night kill. He could have just pushed for us to lynch Phate or JDodge and then killed the other. Of course, it's also entirely possible that this is all some sort of ridiculously elaborate plan. Unlikely, but possible I would suppose.

Yeah, I kinda tend to agree with that. So we have to look at Phate and JDodge, and ask ourselves if either of them knew him to be town and decided to force him out, or if this was just a jerk move on their part.

[Holy]

I'm back...
Sorry guys, I had problem with my CMOS battery and RAM.

I'm too sleepy to post, I'll post tomorrow.

[JDodge]

I have a feeling that competentpsycho is town. I don't think Ryan would let himself be replaced if he had a night kill. He could have just pushed for us to lynch Phate or JDodge and then killed the other. Of course, it's also entirely possible that this is all some sort of ridiculously elaborate plan. Unlikely, but possible I would suppose.

That's a terrible hypothetical. That would assume the following:

Ryan = scum or other killing role (covered already)

Town = willing to lynch one of me/Phate

If scum = willing to kill other for a little grudge, which would also

potentially cast suspicion on ryan

.

Now, do you really think that this is a very plausible situation?

[competentpsycho]

Looking at this from a 3rd person point of view, JDodge makes a good point. If this was an elaborate plan, why would Ryan request a replacement. I guess that really doesn't show JDodge/Phate as innocent, but it does knock out that theory. Other than being assholes I don't see any particularly scummy behavior from JDodge, and only the vote on ryan for voicing his suspicions sticks out for Phate, which I can't see any semi-intelligent scum sticking their neck out for craplogic like that.

On another note, lurkers that stick out to me:

SensFan - random vote only

pacone - random vote and two contentless posts one of which was unintelligible

FairyThatIsPunk - one contentless post - no random vote, no mafia related anything

olliep14 - ZERO posts .... WTF!

Holy - a good number of posts, crap for content, one random vote, and LOTS of excuses for not posting... most being that she was/is too tired, which is strange unless she is a vampire since they are in the morning when she was (apparently) too tired. Also possibly a BS excuse about the CMOS battery and RAM - how likely is it that she had problems with the battery and RAM at the same time. Very suspicious lurking in plain sight, and making excuses.

Unvote: roffman, vote: Holy

MOD can we please get a prod on Sens, Fairy, and olliep

[JDodge]

CMOS technology is usually used in RAM; thus Holy's excuse is perfectly plausible. Also, time zones.

[competentpsycho]

CMOS technology yes, CMOS battery no - thats for the BIOS

I'll admit its not a strong case but its the best I have at the moment and I want to hear more from her (and the others).

[KaleiÐoscøpe]

prods sent.

[SensFan]

Completely forgot about the game, my bad. Unfortunately, I'm in a bit of a rush here, so I have to be brief. Doubtful I'll have much time tonight, but I'll make a big post tomorrow night, guaranteed. Less discussion took place than I would have expected, given the time frame, but I guess that's partly because of a weekend. Even though it's mighty hypocritical of me, I can only assume there are lurkers that need to be pressured. Summary of my thoughts so far will come soon. Sorry again for my absence.

[FairyThatIsPunk]

*FairyThatIsPunk silently laughs at everyone*

[roffman]

*roffman wishes he could stab people over the internet*

[FairyThatIsPunk]

*FairyThatIsPunk gets blow away in the wind, and still manages to keep her hat on*

[competentpsycho]

Does she have a post restriction or something? This is getting annoying.

[JDodge]

I get it. Anyone else with knowledge of HTF characters should get it as well. Don't say what it is if you do, no sense in exclaiming it.

[competentpsycho]

Got it now, sorry not too knowledgeable on this flavor, yet. This may get annoying real quick.

[roffman]

HTF??

[Phate]

Happy Tree Friends?

[FairyThatIsPunk]

*FairyThatIsPunk shakes her finger at Roffman and laughs silently then skips away*