Mini 549 (Tarhalindur Mostly Mountainous) - Game Over

[Earwig]

..........................Earwig, I'm happy because you are scum and my vote is on you. berry is suspect though...............

Would you be willing to provide reasons?

[thenextepisode]

blackberry, if you were so keen on keeping this theory to yourself, then why couldnt you have just kept it to yourself entirely?
and i dont know if its just ecto's playstyle, but he seems overly aggressive and it feels scummy to me
and 3 votes on earwig is making me uneasy

unvote

[thenextepisode]

EBWOP

unvote

[Ectomancer]

Does anyone feel that the FoS count is significant?

Earwig, I'm happy because you are scum and my vote is on you. berry is suspect though.

Might I recommend reading Rule 6a again? - Tar

Ordinarily I think not really, but I've never had it tracked in the vote count before. It might be interesting to see, but I don't know how significant it will really become.

BlackBerry, it is odd that you would mention a theory, but not want expound upon it, even if it turned out to be false. Is there still some portion of the theory you are hoping to be born out that revealing would render invalid? Otherwise I'm not quite following your reasoning.

I have hope that one day my theory will have signifigance in something. But I do not wish to reveal my theory as I do not wish people to adapt to it or analyze it before me.

Satisfied?

Yep.

[Ectomancer]

BlackBerry, you might have missed when I asked you about Jester's comments on Rosso's posts 26, 28, and 33? Would post 97 fall into the same category?

[Ectomancer]

blackberry, if you were so keen on keeping this theory to yourself, then why couldnt you have just kept it to yourself entirely?
and i dont know if its just ecto's playstyle, but he seems overly aggressive and it feels scummy to me
and 3 votes on earwig is making me uneasy

unvote

I think you could check just about any of my games for that answer. Lazy scum.

[Blackberry]

BlackBerry, you might have missed when I asked you about Jester's comments on Rosso's posts 26, 28, and 33? Would post 97 fall into the same category?

I looky at RC's past games. I can not find a distinguishable pattern. Am I allowed to reference other games? I found one where he posted absolutely nothing the first couple pages and he was town.

thenextepisode and ryan are both on my scumrader (even though my scum radar probably sucks), but I am unsure why... here are some potential reasons:
1) They both are attempting to throw suspiscion on me because I want share a theory? How is that scummy!?!?
2) They both appear unintelligent to me
3) Perhaps I am offended they do not capitilze their names
4) Perhaps one or more of them scare me because of his image icon

I have come to learn (through reading and college courses) that analying ones opinions can lead us to more likely make an error. As a result, I am not going to state my exact justifications for said opinions, because I could be completley mistaken. I believe it is impossible for one to know one's exact REASONS for said opinions.

By the way -- if Ectomancer is scum, you are doing a brilliant job (aka I'm pretty sure you are pro-town).

THENEXTEPISODE -- Because I thought the theory was going to be signifigant and I could share with yall my revelation. But it did not work in this case. (red font means harass him)

[Blackberry]

POST 80

what was your theory, blackberry?

POST 82

oookay then i guess i dont want to know the theory

POST 101

blackberry, if you were so keen on keeping this theory to yourself, then why couldnt you have just kept it to yourself entirely?
and i dont know if its just ecto's playstyle, but he seems overly aggressive and it feels scummy to me
and 3 votes on earwig is making me uneasy

I do not comprehend why you go from "fine I don't care" to reasking me again why I had a theory." You did this AFTER other comments were said and ryan got somewhat frustrated with the thing.

This has led me to believe you have used ryan's frustration as an idea to spread suspiscion on me because I "won't share my theory." If my thoughts are right, this leads me to believe you are scum and ryan is just a townie (aka he isn't scum).

UNVOTE, VOTE: THENEXTEPISODE

[thenextepisode]

your logic is flawed.
i didnt ask what the theory was again in the 3rd post, i just suggested that if you have a theory, keep it to yourself until you know that you can show it, otherwise its just a red herring.
using craplogic to try to throw suspicion on me is a scumtell, but it doesnt warrant a vote

FoS: Blackberry

[Blackberry]

your logic is flawed.
i didnt ask what the theory was again in the 3rd post, i just suggested that if you have a theory, keep it to yourself until you know that you can show it, otherwise its just a red herring.
using craplogic to try to throw suspicion on me is a scumtell, but it doesnt warrant a vote

FoS: Blackberry

Although I do not believe my logic is flawed, you not voting for me makes me question, JUST slightly, my suspicions on you. In my opinion, a typical mafia move would be to attack me back and vote me. Yet you didn't vote me, you just FOSed me. Which makes me waver my opinion of you O_o.

[SlySly]

Satisfied?

I think it is the consensus of the town that a full explanation of your theory would be satisfactory.

[Tarhalindur]

Johoohno has not posted in 72 hours and has not indicated V/LA status. As such, he has been prodded. He has 96 hours to reply, or he will be replaced.

Seventh Vote Count

Blackberry (1) - Dean Harper
Earwig (1) - Tamuz
ryan (2) -Nyktorion, Rosso Carne
Tamuz (1) -

Johoohno

thenextepisode (2) - SlySly, Blackberry

Not Voting (5): Ectomancer, ryan, Earwig, Jester, thenextepisode

FoS Count:

Blackberry (1) - thenextepisode
Ectomancer (2) - Earwig, thenextepisode
Earwig (2) - Ectomancer, Nyktorion

Before anyone asks - yes, players have multiple FoS'es. The only limitation on FoS'es is that you can only have one FoS on a player at a time (Rule 1 excepted). -Tar

Indigo

indicates a player in danger of replacement.

Current Deadline:

~12:00 AM, February 21, 2008 (GMT -6)

Second Mod Deadline Review:

~12:00 AM, January 30, 2008 (GMT -6)

[thenextepisode]

tar-
on the front page my name is indigo, but i posted today
so im assuming htats a mistake

Seeing as your user name is "thenextepisode" and not Johoohno... yes, yes it is. Fixed! -Tar

[Ectomancer]

Satisfied?

I think it is the consensus of the town that a full explanation of your theory would be satisfactory.

Actually, I was content with his explanation for not revealing it yet and was willing to let him ride. It will be something interesting to bring back out when he's had more time with it.

[Johoohno]

I've been prodded, but I've never been away (I follow this game most thoroughly and is really enthusiastic about deadlines and activity-prods).

I notice that of a lot of people (Earwig, SlySly, SlySly again and Tamuz) are not reading rules or posts very thoroughly. (Scums feeling they can afford being sloppy readers?) I'm still satisfied with my vote on Tamuz.

The long going mock fight between Blackberry and Ectomancer, which ended up with peace a few posts ago, strikes me as interesting (bussing?)

Finally I think that we might have a serial killer amongst us, making this game MOSTLY mountainuous (or those of you who are more knowledgeable than I, is there a setup name for vanillas, scums and a SK?). There are quite a few players, myself included, keeping a really low profile.

[Ectomancer]

A mock fight? I asked questions and he answered them. Are you seeding a future lynch pairing? Bad Johoohno...

An Sk is a good speculation for what

Mostly

mounainous could mean. We still need to watch out for other possibilites and let the evidence guide our assumptions.

[Blackberry]

Satisfied?

I think it is the consensus of the town that a full explanation of your theory would be satisfactory.

I think it is the consensus of myself that the town can bite me.

[Nyktorion]

Finally I think that we might have a serial killer amongst us, making this game MOSTLY mountainuous (or those of you who are more knowledgeable than I, is there a setup name for vanillas, scums and a SK?). There are quite a few players, myself included, keeping a really low profile.

You are right, we have quite a few people staying under the radar (Tamuz, ryan, Dean Harper, yourself), which also makes it a bit harder to choose a specific one to pressure. However, your last post stands out quite a bit in that regard: you suggest the existence of an SK, and in the same breath, you announce that you are keeping a very low profile yourself. Since your keeping-a-low-profile seems to be intentional, this makes me belief that you might be one of the scums, or the SK.

Unvote, Vote: Johoohoo

Btw: Rosso Carne, you promised to shake things up in your post #53, and said you wanted to read up in post #73. I would still be very eager to see the results of those things

[Tamuz]

Thats dumb johohoo

Unless a mod specifically tells me to read their rules carefully because they are special, I don't. I've played enough games that I expect a standard.

[SlySly]

I think it is the consensus of myself that the town can bite me.

Is it possible to be more pro-town than this?

unvote

vote:Blackberry

[Tamuz]

Only if you're Battousi

[SlySly]

Only if you're Battousi

No offense to Battousai, but QFT!!!

[SlySly]

its his own theory, and although i think it might be helpful, its just metagaming. and metagaming does not win games.

Well hello! You must have forgotten to login as BlackBerry

I think it is worth noting how quick Blackberry and Rosso Carne are to defend each other.

[thenextepisode]

yeah blackberry is definitely on my scumdar, and RC's quick defense places him there too

[Tarhalindur]

Another day, another prod. Jester has not posted in 72 hours and has not indicated V/LA status. As such, he has been prodded. He has 96 hours to reply, or he will be replaced.

In addition, Dean Harper has been pinged to see if he is still V/LA or not. (No prod due to indicating V/LA status in the thread.)

Eighth Vote Count

Blackberry (2) - Dean Harper, SlySly
Earwig (1) - Tamuz
ryan (1) -Rosso Carne
Tamuz (1) - Johoohno
thenextepisode (1) - Blackberry
Johoohno (1) - Nyktorion

Not Voting (5): Ectomancer, ryan, Earwig,

Jester

, thenextepisode

FoS Count:

Blackberry (1) - thenextepisode
Ectomancer (2) - Earwig, thenextepisode
Earwig (2) - Ectomancer, Nyktorion

Before anyone asks - yes, players have multiple FoS'es. The only limitation on FoS'es is that you can only have one FoS on a player at a time (Rule 1 excepted). -Tar

Indigo

indicates a player in danger of replacement.

Current Deadline:

~12:00 AM, February 21, 2008 (GMT -6)

Second Mod Deadline Review:

~12:00 AM, January 30, 2008 (GMT -6)