Mafia 75: Return of the Mafia! TOWN WINS (really late)

[skitzer]

That is so farfetched in a 30 player game and so unfun to play I can't see anyway you are telling the truth.

[Surye]

Take it up with the mod after the game, it is what it is.

[Matt_S]

And do you think i'm the goon?

Why do you ask this?

Because skitzer set that up as one of his two possibilities for me.

Actually, since it's been established that you're not town, asking that really doesn't tell anything. Forget this line of questioning ever happened. However, do you have any idea how Khelvaster died? That's something that just doesn't make sense.

[Surye]

And do you think i'm the goon?

Why do you ask this?

Because skitzer set that up as one of his two possibilities for me.

Actually, since it's been established that you're not town, asking that really doesn't tell anything. Forget this line of questioning ever happened. However, do you have any idea how Khelvaster died? That's something that just doesn't make sense.

Since I've replaced in, and indeed my previous player, have had no night actions what so ever. I have no information.

[Matt_S]

Who did your predecessor target N0?

[Surye]

Who did your predecessor target N0?

Mod didn't tell me, I can ask if you want. And I misspoke upon review of my role, I could have targeted 2 people per night. When I find the person, they die, and I become a cult recruiter. But alas.

[Matt_S]

I just was curious if you somehow caused the poison death. That greatly confuses me.

[Tarhalindur]

I'm short on time, so I'll make this quick.

Best possibilities for the poison kill that I can think of are 1) somehow the cult killed the godfather through the delayed recruit or by a recruit gaining a kill (both possible but unlikely due to timing) and 2) Battle Mage's first incarnation had abilities other than the ones he claimed (Miller JoaT?).

Quick notes for Skitzer: I'm pretty sure Surye is lying, myself, but he can still wait until tomorrow (where we have to lynch him even in the best-case scenario). If he's a Mafia role other than Roleblocker, we autowin by clearing Grimmy. If he's the Roleblocker (I'd say that's fairly likely, myself) I'd venture that Grimmy is the second scumbag here.

If there is only one Mafia left then we've already won so long as we stick to my plan (since that clears Grimmy for reasons I explained earlier), so we don't need to worry about that scenario at all. If we've lynched three straight non-Mafia on Day 12 and the game isn't over, lynch SpyreX for the win.

We're probably lynching me today because a) Korlash is being an idiot by not acknowledging the win the game plan and I doubt he'll listen to logic until I become confirmed town (read: die) and b) I'd already factored my own death into my plan (either today or Day 11).

[Korlash]

You know if you spent less time calling me an idiot and more times answering the question I posted toward you maybe we would get somewhere but instead you have to keep being obv scum...

Whatever... It's really up to you...

[curiouskarmadog]

my vote is in the right place.

there is no reason to lynch Tar over Surye.

[Grimmy]

my vote is in the right place.

there is no reason to lynch Tar over Surye.

Lynching you or Tar will confirm who you are and narrow down our list of suspects.

Lynch Surye does nothing right now because we pretty much know who he is.

Simply put, there is more to learn from a tar or CKD lynch than a Surye one on this day.

Grimmy

[Korlash]

I think Tar being likely scum if a good reason to lynch him over Surye...

[SpyreX]

YOU WOULD THINK THAT

Wait

Thats right

Ohhh

My bad

Lets get a lynching

[skitzer]

Except, Grimmy...

Lynching Surye causes us to probably get rid of an anti-town role, which is better than gaining information in any circumstance.

FoS: Grimmy

Also, something doesn't link up correct with Tarhalindur's analysis. I think I read it incorrectly.

[Grimmy]

Except, Grimmy...

Lynching Surye causes us to probably get rid of an anti-town role, which is better than gaining information in any circumstance.

FoS: Grimmy

Also, something doesn't link up correct with Tarhalindur's analysis. I think I read it incorrectly.

Surye is a survivor right now, and would benefit more from a scum lynch than a town lynch because he is just as viable a target going into the night as the rest of us are, so this would push him to scum hunt also.

Grimmy

[Surye]

look, short of quoting my PM, i can tell you, i count for a town in a majority count. i' not anti-town. believe me or not is your choice, but don't think lynching me is so black and white. just wait until tomorrow to decide on lynching me, the math does work.

[SpyreX]

Suyre isn't the lynch for today.

The CKD adamancy about it, well.

[Matt_S]

I don't see how Surye would could for town at LYLO, but I don't see why killing him today is better than tomorrow.

[curiouskarmadog]

well, lets kill somebody..if it has got to be me..so be it...I think tar's plan (if he really means it) is solid..I dont think the masons are lying (grimmy?)...I doubt there are 3 more scum...

[KaleiÐoscøpe]

I was actually willing to check if it says "confirmed town" masons in the pm, but since it hasn't been resend yet.

Vote: curiouskarmadog

[Surye]

Oh man, please lynch CKD guys. This is dragging on unnecessarily.

[Korlash]

Fine...

Unvote:, Vote: CKD

I still expect to see Tar dead...

[SpyreX]

In all things I agree with Korlash.

Unvote, Vote: CKD

[Surye]

We haven't had a vote count all day...

[curiouskarmadog]

I think I am the best choice...when I die..it will prove that we have a doc.